Chrja makes that weird list
Quote:
Originally Posted by chrja
I just thought about this when checking the player list.
Aksdal
Anarchist
captain binkles
chrja
El_Timon
Gadarene
Horatio Kane If i am remembering right somebody who played more with him please confirm
JimHalpert
McAvoy
metsandfinsfan
Nofear3838
Willi
younguns87
All the people i got in green are usually easy to read if they just play there obv villa game.
So please just do that.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene
Can you say more about:
Aksdal
binkles
El_Timon
Nofear
Plz?
Gad instantly calls it out
Quote:
Originally Posted by chrja
sure about there play so far this game or what i consider there obv. villa mode?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene
Oh, I'm an idiot and I misread that.
Can you say more about what constitutes binkles and Nofear's "obv villa game[s]"?
Says he misread it (maybe thought it was villa leans?). Now asks about binkles and nofears obv villa games
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene
Both, why not
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene
I think you're thinking about the Pokemon vanilla+ with the POKE masonry. I'm pretty sure I've seen binkles in "reread anything" mode as a wolf, or at least as a neutral (HP4).
Quote:
Originally Posted by chrja
Binkles i already explained.
NoFear is to me about presences in the thread, when he is here he is commenting on a **** load of things as a villager -
If he reminds you of that guy in a group that has a saying on anything and feels like nobody really listens to him, he is a villager.
Quote:
Originally Posted by chrja
I know he has done it as a neutral in a big mish mash. But thats still a hole lot easier then doing it as a wolf in a small vanilla
ok the whole point of showing this was just to show how they get chatting, as I think it's relevant momentarily.
cliffs
-chrja makes weird list
-gad calls it out
-chrja explains
-gad disagrees
-chrja changes subject below
Quote:
Originally Posted by chrja
Mac
get in here and play
It's important to note that these conversations are happening simultaneously. So Annie/Gad are in the middle of their interaction while Chrja/Gad are too.
Annie has already voted gad and asked him to tilt
Chrja votes mac
Quote:
Originally Posted by chrja
So gad.
The two of us should have a talk.
What are your opinion on annie so far ?
Change of subject I mentioned
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene
I never used to be able to read him very well because he was Anarchist-y.
Now he's not as Anarchist-y, so I don't have that excuse. Turns out I might just be bad at reading him.
So far I think it was fairly villagery (if annoying) of him to try and get me mad to figure out my role, but odd (and kind of wolfy in a not-making-waves sort of way) that he outed the tactic immediately like that when I didn't bite. So no real idea yet.
What do you think of him?
Says he's unsure and says why its kinda villagery but kinda wolfy
Quote:
Originally Posted by chrja
I think he is wolfy, and this is why.
pops in without any reads yet.
Votes you
This is a lie
I think he is a wolf that is having a hard time coming up with any reads. Therefor he tries to use some meta to get into the thread.
Most here know that you at times have a temper - but no way in hell he expects you to blow up because of one vote.
He is lying and trying to look villagery while hiding behind a meta reason.
Thats wolfy.
Chrja explains its wolfy to gad
doesnt vote tho
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene
This isn't a bad point.
Gad saying hes making sense
Quote:
Originally Posted by chrja
Anarchist
Then the vote
**** I read this as chrja getting caught up in a conversation he wants no part in (the list/obv villa game stuff), changing subjects, seeing if he has an out to vote annie, and then does. Again:
- Caught in a bad spot with the list/obv villa stuff
- Changes subject
- Asks gad what he thinks of someone else
- Gad says unsure
- Says he thinks its wolfy of Annie. DOESNT VOTE
- Gad says its a good point
- THEN VOTES
That order is so so so important
Quote:
Originally Posted by chrja
Are you ****ing kidding me?
are you even reading the thread ?
lets us take them from the top.
I found the exchange between annie and gad to be fake. As i believed and still does that Annie was lying about thinking that hes vote would make gad blow up.
So first i ask at question to Gad to see if he is seeing what I am - And to see if it might be a likely w/w exchange. (btw i found gad's answer very wishy washy so i am definitely not ruling out w/w)
The third question is me trying to get annie to admit he was lying.
My question to YG was to get into a conversation with him, so far the only thing from him i remember is his case on me, To asses if he is a villager i need to see what else he has - And i am still waiting for a response.
Horatio calls chrja out and here's the response. He says not that it's because he thought Annie/Gad was w/w, but that covnersation shows NO SIGNS of that. None. It's not a "im skeptical of you guys". Its a "uh i dont like this conversation, i wonder if i can push this guy" conversation.
I think this is massive villa points to both Gad and Annie due to the way this went down, and more to Gad for his change of subject and pausing to vote until seeing if Gad will maybe follow
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene
How was my answer about Anarchist wishy-washy, chrja?
Quote:
Originally Posted by chrja
first off the first 2 paragraph are just excuses.
Then first you give him a villa lean, then you half way retracts that lean and say you don't really know.
Thats wishy washy, like you don't really like to commit on anything.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene
If I actually don't really know, isn't the correct answer to your question that I don't really know? You're asking me based on two posts of his, one where he votes me with no explanation.
The first two paragraphs weren't excuses; they were context. I often find it helpful.
Quote:
Originally Posted by chrja
sure.
you just did it in a wishy washy way. I may not mean anything. I just expected you to be more straight forward.
It can't be(or i know it isn't) the first time somebody tries to tilt you, I was expecting you to be able to looked at how he did it and try to get a better lean on him.
Quote:
Originally Posted by chrja
to elaborate.
I thought the way he did it was wolfy, like he did it "half hearted"(can you use that in english?)
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene
Usually I just try to ignore them. Jim has done it as a wolf the last two times we've played together, but beyond that (even though I maintain that it's not pro-villa) I feel like it's basically role-neutral because some people (like Mac) will do it as a villa because they think it tells them something about me (it doesn't anymore, if it ever did) and some people will do it in either role just because they're kind of childish that way. Anarchist could be doing the Mac thing, or he could be balancing because he feels he'd do it as a villa. I'm not sure yet; I don't have any particular snap feeling about it. That's as straightforward as I can be.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene
half-hearted is definitely English, and I agree with that sentiment
also I meant to say the last two times that Jim and I have played together when he's been a wolf, not the last two times we've played together period.
Chrja through here wants like, no part of actually arguing with Gad. Its "oh I think they are w/w obv" to the guy he doesnt know, but he's very careful not to get into an accusatory interaction with Gad. It's kinda meek and trying to appease him by trying to explain what he meant etc.
