whatever

lame

you're either a wolf or terrible villager

literally everyone else knows im a villager except you?

loretta

Milhouse is jumping off a bridge? I'm there!

Anarchist,

This transcends any subject and is solitarily one of the worst opinions I have ever heard on anyhing.

And that is being kind.

I'm honestly trying to help you think differently.

This is fundamentally flawed. Whether it is better to view good guys or bad guys depends on the state of the game. Enough good guys viewed, and you can lock the game. If you can't lock it, you can at least come close if there are also unviewed players you trust.

Viewing scum works well when you get them all, but you never do. It is worth getting someone who wouldn't be lynched otherwise, and it can be worth finding scum if that person's interactions help you find others.

Basically, cop usually wants to view players of the same alignment he already has, so for example three town is usually better than two town and one scum. But most important is number of viewed players who live a while, and number who are uncertain one way or the other as to whether they'd have been lynched without being viewed.

why would you rather peek villagers than wolves?

Having read about four posts itt I could totally get behind this

anarchist

are you guys leveling? just like if u have peeked villas you can lock the game,

peeking a wolf serves the same function

if u peek a wolf and kill it, you get closer to lokcing the game

lol

zanmato - here's a reread of the last page, with my notes:

you have these long block posts. by now i'm gathering that that's part of yr personal style, I guess. they strike me as pretty wolfy, and not in a wolfy-but-not-a-wolf kind of way.

they're not easily digested. that's not a good thing.

see, i don't get how xxs is saying "flytrap is wolfy but ldo not a wolf", when the same thing could be applied to gad.

idk what to think about this whole mechanics discussion of power evils. yea, it's standard to float a decoy wolf if a wolf PR is in danger. usually not *until* the wolf PR is in danger, though, and usually not until EODish, anyway.

i tend to talk mechanics when the situation calls for it. this mechanics talk, especially with the game-ending-jester, seems - unfocused, at best.

in terms of contradictions, you're all over the place here. the previous quote had you mentioning "what if killing a jester ends the game", and here you're saying, "it's good to assume that there wouldn't be something like, killing a jester ends the game"

likewise, random mechanics (in a sense) discussion. maybe the first is wolfy, maybe not. depends on who it is. it's contextual. you can't draw a general rule from it.

it's a fair guess that we've got neutrals. null tell to suggest it.

idk how esse has you as his top villa

or me as top wolf, but that's a separate issue

i don't even know what this comment is in response to. but the blanket "which good guys don't do as much as evils" -

I'm not sure what yr saying and I'm not sure what yr experience/knowledge base is here. yr tone isn't noob-villa-asking-questions - it's woof-muddying-waters.

as usual, a significant percentage of people voting me are wolves.

you make it waaaaaaaaaay too easy

we're lynching flytrap today btw

hey ess, seriously

you're one of if not the best player in this game

do you think im a wolf?

cause a lot of people do

so i must be doing something very wrong

this is true, but, again, textually more difficult than necessary. zanmato, I guess you've played this elsewhere? as mafia? yr referring to cops, towns, and scum. so, not the local ww lingo.

same POV, but more to the point:

Duckburg:

I'm not looking for items.

I am looking for masons, good village play, and teamwork. We'll stand together and kill wolves.

You've honestly lost me.

1) Items tend to be good for those who pick it up.
2) Wolves can talk with other wolves and tell each other to pick up items.
3) Therefore, I read the story posted by the mod, keep track of which items have been picked up so I don't pick them up myself, and then I pick up whatever sounds coolest and most likely to be an item.
4) To hopefully get items in the hands of villagers, I list other items that I think might be items.
5) Yes, I probably did list the more likely to be items on the top of my list.

if that came from where i think it did

luckay

lol heart xpostaments

you get the luckayluck veto. The item strategy posted by flytrap probably doesn't come from a wolf.

I look forward to your lead in lynching wolves still though.

he's not a worse vote than me, but pretty nearly

@Pyromaniac: To your last point, I was talking about what loosekannen had said. I wasn't the first to raise the issue, so I agreed about it rather than trying to take credit for some huge revelation. And the part about evils do it more than goods, that obviously meansI'm saying that I think the post in question (with the "... as villa") is a scum tell.

How is that "woof" muddying waters? My terminology is a little different but it should be clear what I mean. I'm trying to use "good" and "evil" so everyone can understand exactly what I'm saying. And as for my discussions about mechanics, it's not random,I've been talking about things that are important. In complicated games, mechanics matters and everyone understanding it all is pro-good guys. Again, not muddying waters, trying to clear them.

i think you're villa, but idk

yea i haven't really been into this game yet, maybe i'll just sponge you today

By the way, Pyromaniac does seem to have been looking into my posting rather than just casting aspersions. Good guy, I think. Just wrong.

Don't lie to me - stop looking for something you cannot find.

And start masoning with me.

i wish i had a million votes so i could vote for all of you a lot of times

By the way, it's a longshot, but if someone wants to pick up book, it's worth a try