Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread 9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread

09-20-2013 , 06:27 AM
ok

was just wondering
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 06:30 AM
Votes from post 7798 to post 7851
Night in 13:30:37

---
VotesLynchVoters
1 Xkf Askthepizzaguy (21)
1 diskoteque vixticator (3)
1 bhuber2010 ihcjay (12)
8 not voting Xkf (2), UncleDynamite (0), UAW710 (0), No Lynches (0), LeonardoDicaprio (16), diskoteque (0), bhuber2010 (0), Ashington (0)
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 06:31 AM
Where the hell did my post go.

Forum ate my homework.
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 06:34 AM
Briefly, repeating:

It can easily be read the opposite way: You can read it as a scum sacrificing day one to cause a mason to be lynched, to spare vaya.

However, disko is the instant lynch next day. And, then the natural progression is, was he trying to save scum vaya. That's 2 for 1 mason, a bad trade for wolves.

Further, the wolves didn't murder fanmail when it failed.

I just don't see that as disko's move as scum. The softness of the counter, the way the wolves were positioned, the play to continually no-lynch fanmail after.... you go for broke murdering fanmail afterward because you have to collect your prize after you out yourself to try to lynch him.

A scenario where he's willing to trade himself for fanmail but not murder him for 2 more nights? Completely off the wall.

Is he that much of a beastly wolf that he could do that?

I'd do a lot of **** and I'd never fricking do that.
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 06:36 AM
I give him mad props if he pulled that crap as wolf and got away with it.
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 06:38 AM
no-murder, not no-lynch. But he was a no-lynch as well. It's just mind-boggling to me if disko is scum after that.

I will admit that move got me, it definitely got me. Even now trying to second-guess myself, I still don't see it really happening.

Please, I legit ****ed it up with Anarchist, tell me where I screwed the pooch here if I am wrong.
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 06:42 AM
Why does disko out himself to destroy fanmail, when if he clearly thinks that fanmail is a mason claiming, he can't just murder fanmail?

A townie tries the fake counter, because a townie can't murder fanmail. He has to try to lynch fanmail if he thinks fan is scum.

A wolf doesn't need to out himself to destroy fanmail by lynch there, and, he could have gotten bussing credit for saving fanmail and lynching vaya instead, then, murdering fanmail.

And when his scum gambit blew up in his face, and vaya died, and he got immediately suspected, he still no-murders him the next night?

That's just begging to lose a game.

That's the correct play for disko as wolf, isn't iot?
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 06:43 AM
it*
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 06:44 AM
So yeah, I agonized over the whys, and put disko as clear for that move.

If I overthink'd it, I think I'm not alone in doing so.
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 06:45 AM
I guess I am doing an all-nighter, I have errands in the morning and then I'm out of here by 10.

You won't see my ass again until EOD, and even then, I might be balls deep, so forgive me if I stop giving a crap about this game at that time.

9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 06:47 AM
I just might check and see if Ash is a possible lynch and move my vote there. Other than that, I really dgaf
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 06:47 AM
You consider that an honor, Ashy.
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 06:52 AM
Maybe I'm the balls deep wolf.
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 06:55 AM
All right, since I miss like half of the game every day, can you guys keep my posts on this page in your mind a little bit and pretend like I am still here commenting, and these are my comments.

If there's nothing else, I'll continue vac prep.
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 07:15 AM
I have UncleDynamite as lock town in 99% of all cases.

There is one, singular, exception:

1) Bhuber and xkf are both not wolf.
2) But Ashington does flip wolf.

Then, UncleDy is the guy who came to his most heroic defense, using his own townie credits and meta history that I absolutely can't be arsed to confirm for myself, that he does that flinch as villager and never as wolf.

It's a long shot, but it's the only way I see UncleD as wolf.
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 07:17 AM
bhuber
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 07:18 AM
In summary, Two scenarios left in my mind that I'm willing to explore:

(Jay/Leo are excused for the rest of the game because town no lynches them for 3 rounds while I wail about it)

Scenario 1:

xkf/bhuber are excellent lynches. Both could in fact be wolf, if I'm hella wrong about everything this game. But I lean more towards one being wolf, and then:
Ashington.

Scenario 2: The farfetched long shot

Just Ashington and UncleD, and the only circumstance UncleD is wolf.
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 07:22 AM
Suggested lynch progression:

1) xkf, of xkf versus bhuber.
2) If xkf is villa, lynch bhuber
3) If xkf is wolv, lynch Ashington.
4) If Ashington is villa, and xkf is wolf, return to lynching bhuber
5) If xkf and bhuber are both villa, lynch Ashington
6) If scenario 5 is accurate, lynch UncleD after Ashington, and in no other circumstance.
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 07:28 AM
Bhuber

Best lynch today IMO.
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 07:30 AM
7) If bhuber lynch today and flips wolf, lynch Ashington
8) If Ashington flips villa after bhuber lynch, lynch xkf.
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 07:38 AM
bhuber

I really don't know what to make of two posts in two days from disko.

I similarly don't know what to make of pizza's almost obsessive tunneling of me, especially now that yet another of my early votes has flipped wolf. Nothing short of my reveal is gonna make this headache inducing crap stop I guess.

Xkf and jay might be the last two. I don't feel great about any particular vote at this point.

I'm going to be traveling this weekend and my volume will be very very low.
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 07:57 AM
Votes from post 7798 to post 7871
Night in 12:04:21

---
VotesLynchVoters
4 bhuber2010 Ashington (1), No Lynches (1), diskoteque (1), ihcjay (12)
1 Xkf Askthepizzaguy (37)
1 diskoteque vixticator (3)
5 not voting Xkf (2), UncleDynamite (0), UAW710 (0), LeonardoDicaprio (16), bhuber2010 (0)
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 08:00 AM
Yes, this is a good spot for wolf pizza to be voting. 4 on bhuber, 1 on xkf.

It's almost like the wolves don't want to vote for my candidates for some reason.
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 08:05 AM
Just think what an easy lynch I become if I strongly convince people to lynch xkf and he flips townie, and then bhuber dies and flips wolf.

Gosh, don't I look like such a sap then.

And yet, the wolves don't go for the easy two-mislynch.

Why is this, pizza ponders
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote
09-20-2013 , 08:06 AM
It should be stunningly obvious to the rest of you.
9/12 The Three Musketeers Vanilla+ Werewolf Game Thread Quote

      
m