This seems like a blatant case of post-facto reasoning, and the "I was intending to look like a wolf" screams "****, these players are good, and they got me, how do I get out of it? Oh, I know! I'll act like I meant to say that and attack the people who attacked me!"

I did this a bazillion times as a beginner wolf.

What I said was such a blatant off-topic, being new made it the perfect bait for wolves imo.

Anyone have a similar read of the situation?

Villagers ask people to mason all the time. It's probably even less a wolf tell when it's with someone that hasn't posted yet. At worst it's completely null, and I don't really believe swiitch read that post and was like "zomg, wolf wants to mason with sun!"

By weird you just mean "not reasonable" or "illogical"

But swiitch knows that people who come up with random slightly illogical or paranoid theories about why so and so is a wolf tend to be villagers, this seems pretty made up.

Pretty obviously the wink is a joke, based on the fact that the reasoning he's responding to can be used in the same way to say "Oh then you must be a wolf (since I know I'm a villager)"

I don't think it makes sense to call someone a villager just because they can provide a reason, except for people who are really bad at it, wolves will tend to be able to give reasons for reads, c.f swiitch's reads...

But it's not really wolfy.

I'll allow this one. The followup explanation is kinda weird too.

So I don't mind you being serious early or think that's wolfy, but it's wolfy to supposedly be in serious mode early and then call 4 people wolves when you only actually find 3 of them wolfy, and it's wolfy to do it in a joking manner rather than say, quoting the posts and doing what you did here.

I wanted to dismiss the ipod remark as role neutral, but Larry's recent post kind of supplements the notion that he is a wolf imo.

Do whatever you feel is correct. I have done both in the past, and I feel like they both worked.

However, just by mentioning you have a good case on someone, you might set them on edge a bit, so that can aid in your case down the road (if that makes sense - just by mentioning that you think you have a wolf, can put some wolves on the defensive.).

Sun kind of let me have it a couple of games ago when I dropped a line that I had an early wolf lean, but then a few posts later I eliminated him from contention.

This is poor logic. As a villager your number one goal should be to clear yourself by hunting for wolves, not by attempting to take the thread down a path that has nothing to do with finding wolves/clearing villagers.

Systolic, you are so wolfy to me right now.

but it did, DUCY

People who say that they made a post that they intended to look wolfy, I find wolfy.

clear through day 1, ldo

wolf, ldo

I understand that it looks weird, but I think that if Titan truely believed that posting early talking with people was wolfy then as a wolf he wouldn't be doing it. However,if that is the case, I now wonder why post something you really don't believe?

p.s. this opening post is pedobear approved
p.p.s. Before its asked, no i dont think swiitch/WN are wolfy/clear for the first two posts I quoted.
p.p.s. bowling anyone?

I don't want you to take this the wrong way, but the fact that you said this made me smile

I am wolfy to you because I am attacking you. However, you have to understand that as a villager, my job is to find wolves. I am going to point out interactions and posts that strike me as wolfy. It is unfortunate for you that you have been the wolfiest to me, and I can understand how it might frustrate you towards me to be called a wolf by me, but that does not make me inherently wolfy.

This is true, but he is new, so I'll give him the benefit of the doubt that it is his newb villager defensive mechanism

you on the other hand could be easily be pushing for his mislynch

It really didn't, if you ask me.

I know I'm not a wolf, and I believe pretty strongly that Systolic is not a wolf, either.

I'm also aware that systo is pushing for his lynch, but does it strike anyone other than me that systo seems more genuinely wolfhunting than Switch?

You're still making no sense. Because the "covering your wolf partner" is at least a logical, albeit wrong, thing to say.

What I'm asking is if you intend to quote posts and just say "obvious w/w" with no reasoning to them in this game.

You seem to be saying you only do that as a wolf so that's good.

I'm not soft pushing you.

How is it a self contradiction. I'm asking you for your sample size. You're saying that you "used to do it as a wolf" which, to me, implies a fairly large sample size. I'm under the impression you've played only a handful of long games. Am I right or wrong? That's all I'm asking.

Lol no its not.

Sounds very very defensive..... if you have a strong read on me, you should not be concerned with how I feel.

The fact that you actually say it's fine since I'm only posting baseless reads as a wolf and that I'm not doing so here so I'm not a wolf after you told me about my wolf tell seems like you're trying to find reasons to clear me, a villager.

Yeah that's what I think a wolf would do.

I have no history with you however and cannot proceed with confidence. I'll let others with history with you take a shot at reading you before I convince myself you're a lockwolf.

WAT

Ok now I'm gonna try to actually decipher what you said.

I also realise I'm not very coherent or perfectly logical atm so I think I should sleep now and wolfhunt again tomorrow.

lol xpost

I don't know what titan and gtpitch are talking about but they are both villagers

I do not like this at all..... Gt seems like a good villager to me, and this is very ?????

Ok here we go.

When did I call you a wolf? Never afaik.

Also - only wolves clear villagers? That's strange - because - as a villager - I try to find other villagers and then just assume the people that are left are the wolves. Its actually much easier to clear villagers than to find wolves.