Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD 4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD

04-11-2016 , 07:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TehBankertin
Jon paul put in his application to be vigged I see. GLGL
Perma resident of get Vigged land.

I meant Bopolis, not baudib.
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:08 PM
also think mucks has decent wolf equity. real lack of #presence and #command in his posting that usually jumps out to me

i'd give a caveat about the post restriction and how some people are posting differently because of it but I don't feel like its applicable in his case (or rather, my case on him) really
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by fnord_too
Only if everyone here cooperates. So probably not, but we can try, and that might yield information.
cool

vote kruze
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by corycurren
Listen we're like 2 hours from EoD and we have like an insurmountable amount of votes to be able to move wagons quickly at EoD so we need to start consolidating now

If you do not have a super strong wolf read, I ask for your hand to help deliver justice and to join me on Slow_Ben. He will soon awaken when we do, and you will understand
I'm not getting the same feeling about monte that you are

Quote:
Originally Posted by benneh
i didn't see a question. quote it if i missed it



every single post aside from a 2hour stint in rocket league around noon-ish, but i still read MOST of the posts during that time
You're missing:

Boner2


from your list is all
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bloobird
lolno
should I take that as you not being afraid I'll soul read you again because you are Town and know you are Town?
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:08 PM
I would like to lynch between Gamer Dude, Kaze, and peskypenguin rn
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by benneh
would appreciate people's thoughts on mor_tilt, who I strongly think is a wolf given his (lack of) posting and inability to make more than 1 read in his 30~ posts
I read his posts, they suck. There's no defending them.

Honestly though, the biggest challenge in this game is going to be discerning which of the low hanging fruit should be kept around. In a game this size, there's going to be so many people who flat out are not participating, many of which are villagers. We can't just give wolves carte blanche to open fire on the slankers.

So benneh, why Mor_Tilt4mePls over any of the ~dozen other players just like him?
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bloobird
like

Kruze shot an active villager who most people didn't want him to shoot
.why are we complicating this?
the idea being that the behavior isn't necessarily wolfy for him and it's generally good for people to make votes based on reads
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:09 PM
lol @ anyone wolf reading me for posting over

i live in australia morons
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ace of Spaids
jcohen, what do you think about the wagons?

Why are you voting Allundberg?

Why not a top wagon?
i havent gotten there yet, quite frankly

i explained my allund vote when i made it. and now with batm having 35 extra votes, it doesn't seem like our votes will matter much. and theres 2 hours left. so i havent focused on the wagons yet
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:09 PM
btw without a PoR, benneh is prob at like 250 posts and ~lock clear
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by benneh
would appreciate people's thoughts on mor_tilt, who I strongly think is a wolf given his (lack of) posting and inability to make more than 1 read in his 30~ posts
WAT?!?!

na fair enough not really engaged so far prob has something to do with having a lack clearing role so something something hair something
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jcohen
i myself have done the same thing as a wolf in a mash before. but now I'm doing it as a villager, so apparently its role-neutral. i think its more just that i have no clue how to reenter a thread when I'm thousands of posts behind, and it gives me something to do
ok so instead of, you know, investigating a lead you yourself think might be hot or just interacting with some bros, your feel it best to request an assignment from somebody who may very well be mafia

and in the case of monstrman it's even worse because you just wasted however many minutes describing monstrman's actions to himself

makes like no sense iyam. something I'd expect out of a Manitowoc County resident
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:09 PM
Here's what my soul says about Slow_Ben

Monte's wolf game mostly consists of him trying to match his villager range but he lacks endurance for the most part and trails off, saving bursts of energy for times like EoDs that people consider "heavier" and to keep himself out of energy. His effort here is pretty middling.

The counter-argument is "maybe Monte doesn't give a **** about a ~120 player game" but I don't think you get this Monte in that situation. I've seen Monte give zero ****s as a villager many times, and for the most part he just becomes low volume and has more bite. Monte's traditional villager range he's very direct and interactive with the thread.

Monte's still posting to appear like he's giving a ****, but he clearly doesn't. I don't think as a villager not giving a **** about the game he even bothers to make it appear that way.
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:09 PM
lolbatm forever

hope he's a wolf so there's some proper raging going on in wolf chat
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mexineil
Your other posts so far don't seem to agree.
A meaningless comment to Stuck

Quote:
Originally Posted by mexineil
Wrong on two counts:

1) I'm a villager, and
2) it wasn't my first post.

Congrats on the ten years though I guess
Moderate defence against Shortline99's vote

Quote:
Originally Posted by mexineil
I'm in the mood to INTERACT
Quote:
Originally Posted by mexineil
Has anything actually relevant happened?
A fair question, at this point 2400 posts in thread

Quote:
Originally Posted by mexineil
Thingy appears to be villaging based purely on the tone of his kinda annoyed reply to Viggo. Seen this exact thing before I'm sure.
His first read, and he puts it on someone who's later peeked

Quote:
Originally Posted by mexineil
Someone, convince me that someone else is a wolf.
Isn't that the point of interacting, to find your own wolves?

Quote:
Originally Posted by mexineil
Ok good start.

This game is gonna feel a bit weird with so many people I've never played with.
Soft encouragement of Panther's case on someone who later flips villager, and then he drops the entire thing.

Quote:
Originally Posted by mexineil
<skepticalface.gif to thingy>
Quote:
Originally Posted by mexineil
ffs Thingy I will not rest until you acknowledge me.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thingyman
hahaha

sorry




I reread chrja and I have him as slight villa lean, but I did try to be skeptical and I can see him POTENTIALLY making those posts as a wolf, so he can't join the list - yet, at least

stay tuned for updates to the Thingylist
Extent of the Thingy/Mexi interaction.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bloobird
mexi wolfing, I've soulread him like this before, pretty sure I've done it again
Quote:
Originally Posted by mexineil
lol why? Just lolBloo and carry on

Plus one read on one player in a game of over 120, probably not worth killing yourself over.

Seems like you really do care about this game.
@stuck

Quote:
Originally Posted by mexineil
lolBloo

No idea what think you're seeing differently to any of my other villa games. Also, you said I'm being reactive not proactive and then said how I (proactively) tried to get people to interact with me. Keep your story straight at least.

Don't worry, you'll come around on me soon I'm sure. Good to have you in the game anyway.
Quote:
Originally Posted by mexineil
Rawrs seems wolfy
Quote:
Originally Posted by mexineil
sup

What did I miss?
This is far from a convincing villager case. Mexineil. It's possible this is legitimate disinterest in the game from a villager. But it's also possible to be legitimate disinterest from a wolf trying to put on an appearance.
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Beck Novo
I would like to lynch between Gamer Dude, Kaze, and peskypenguin rn
what do you think about rawrs?
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:10 PM
GENERAL STUFF

I'm a bit upset at people treating me like I'm a child or as if I'm not self-aware.

It's very easy to dismiss my arguments or my reads by simply hammering home the "metsy" rhetoric, so I at least ask that those who are villagers do me the respect of not immediately disregarding anything I say, since I have far more insight into my relationships with certain people than any of you have. One of the most reliable ways of reading people is ascertaining whether they would have the reads they have as a villager.

RE: JIMHALPERT

JimHalpert is an excellent player. As such, I have high standards for his choices.

He had not once mentioned my name before opting to peek me, yet he immediately made this decision despite having had focused on a number of other people. This is strikes one and two and three. Why me? And why not someone else? And why not consult the thread?

From your points of view, you are viewing it as a rational choice because you would've made the same peek. That's all fine and dandy, but I am saying it would've been wolfy of any of you guys to peek me. I am saying it is wolfy for JimHalpert.

Me and Jim have played together on Mafia Universe for the past several months. My experience with him both during this period and during back when we played tons of games together on 2+2 leads me to believe that there is no way he would want to peek me here.

I just realized that I can't even link to MU games. So I will quote:

Quote:
i dont really care for your constantly WAAAA SOMEONE THINKS I COULD BE A WOLF IN AN INTERNET TEXT GAME
get 0ver it br0
Quote:
im pretty sure thingy is a villager tho?
i hate to admit i vote him on purpose because he gets mad at me when hes villa and it helps me read him, alas you do what you gotta do
(these are from the same game, and we were both v/v)

Please read this last quote and make up your own mind about JimHalpert's thoughts about my rants when he's a villager. He says me doing that helps him read me, yet here he uses it as an excuse to immediately peek me?

Add to this that most old schoolers are WELL aware that I am hardly ever mislynched. It would be the same as JimHalpert peeking mets or Swiitch -- those are horrible peeks. Jim wouldn't waste it on that.

Am I calling him a lock wolf? Not at all. I said 70%, though this still prompted accusations of me being self-centered in my reads, thank you for that.

This is a game of werewolf and we are trying to evaluate whether people are doing things they would do as a villager. I have given clear proof that there seems to be a mismatch surrounding JimHalpert's actions that at the very least demand an explanation or consideration.

RE: FORSYTHIO

Scratch this read, because I just reread some of our old games we played together and he misread me in the first 3 that I checked, so he's apparently just historically bad at reading me, since it seems he even misread me for the same things back then :P
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Beck Novo
I would like to lynch between Gamer Dude, Kaze, and peskypenguin rn


meh
Nah
Don't think I've seen a post by them
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Loretta8
any other regular AIDSers i need to know about?

benjaminAO was AIDSing earlier but no one seemed to really care
Yeah BenAO is on the list

Ace of SpAIDS sometimes
Lordjvk sometimes
Jon Paul obviously
BATM obviously

Some of the newer players I dont really know the meta with honestly, I havent really been super active recently
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CPHoya
I want to note that I am profoundly uncomfortable with the mexineil wagon because Banks is on it, but that I am also profoundly uncomfortable with the KruZe wagon because it really does seem rooted in very KruZe-y ambiguity

unsure what I will eventually opt to do about this but I STRONGLY advocate for someone to please kill BATM
Thats a dumb reason for not wanting to kill mexi. If you think I'm a wolf I'm a known busser so you should feel Better about the vote that before. If you're wrong I'm probably right so you should hop on.
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by benneh
specifically

@VAGOS
@CPHOYA
@MOOCHER
@NL
@JCOHEN

and even @younguns who i'll extend a SPO to, even though he's in my orange pile
Mor's posts are almost all short, empty garbage that is irrelevant for all purposes. He cared a lot - comparatively speaking - about stuck being a wolf, shorty being a villager for cursing at thingy, and about the mechanics of the prizes. He was studied in not taking firm positions re: KruZe, which is a bad look. I would have to work very hard to make a convincing argument that he's doing villager things, which means I shouldn't bother trying to lean that way.
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:10 PM
I have issues with Mexi being a wagon because mechanically we should lynch players that have had serious interactions and a good pool of posting. Pushing him for lynch after he posted 14 times early on day one is never a good target for info.

I'm trying to be less aidsy so I won't keep pushing really good town players for day one lynch since most of you disagree on doing so.

I'd put up players like Beck Novo, Lissa2, dLGN, Panther instead. These players have had the posting for us to get info upon death pending either alignment. They were low content players who I have read non villagers.
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by grant2
I don't disagree with the thrust of your post. I get a similar feeling about her improving over the day. which makes me glad because I want the 2 alliance to be real.

Your phrasing seems very forced. My sense is you invested time into analyzing her and you want to have a concrete results to show for your work. I think this makes you two highly correlated to have similar alignment.

v/v or w/w.
i would agree that i do feel some pressure to come up with a conclusion when asked to ISO someone and then actually iso'ing them. I'm not sure if thats a bad thing though, because my conclusion could just as easily be "i have mixed thoughts on this person"

i don't think any of my phrasing was forced other than wanting it to accurately convey my thoughts. but if thats what you think then so be it
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote
04-11-2016 , 07:10 PM
oh, thingys posts suck btw

i almost gave myself 5 extra votes to say that earlier
4/11 Anniversary X Werewolf Mishmash GAME THREAD Quote

      
m