Want your thoughts on France...should filthy (or anyone) be cluing Food (uppercase) if France is meant to be hit? Other than that concern, I think it's the strongest fourth word.
Also thinking more about staff. Wouldn't we have gotten veterinarian - 3 (instead of 2) if staff was ours?
Chef doesn't hit soul too well. We'd be having this same conversation over that word if he went chef, I agree with your analysis: re same clue for line or France in the combo. They need 5, so even if we get this wrong it's probably 50/50 to still win. He basically has to use food to hit soul, so I don't think there's much we can really read into the specifics. I'd say go France.
Also, just wanted to say my coworkers and I do a weekly codenames hour now, and earlier today we got a Columbine - 3 clue for mass, shoot and memory. HR was not on that zoom call. Memory was the tough one, but it came up when I questioned why he didn't clue a more recent mass shooting. ****ing america...
Amazon
Boom
Brazil
Chair
Contract
Current
Embassy
Genius
Groom
Himalayas
Hotel
Knot
Marathon
Mine
Mona Lisa
Mountie
Onion
Peanut
Princess
Ranch
Skates
Smoothie
State
String
Tank