Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread 3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread

03-18-2011 , 10:43 AM
D 1 voting:

Quote:
Originally Posted by well named
****** VOTE COUNT ******

# Player name Vote
4 andynan wowlucky
1 birdman10687 bsball8806
2 bogan4life filthyvermin
1 bsball8806 bogan4life
0 cphoya andynan
0 enty  
2 exoendo vuroth
1 filthyvermin andynan
0 LuckayLuck andynan
0 metsandfinsfan andynan
1 okse54 exoendo
1 rebonkulous birdman10687
0 titanrulez rebonkulous
0 uaw710 bogan4life
1 vuroth  
1 wowlucky okse54
0 zayana exoendo
3  

lead votes:
4 - andynan
2 - exoendo
2 - bogan4life
1 - birdman10687
Quote:
Originally Posted by bsball8806
Other than the fact that he has been so detached from the thread-which is pretty wolfy in and of itself, bogan's posts are way too "logical" from someone that has clearly not read the thread (and has been so detached). All of his reads follow (in the sense that he doesn't have any inconsistencies or controversial reads) in a way that wolves love to employ. Wolves love nothing more than to not read the thread, make a few early reads that nobody really will disagree with, and then stick to those reads for d1 and then disappear for the rest of the day.

The post about giving titan a d1 pass because of what is happening in Japan, while "nice", is wolfy. Also, in that same post, why would he "start" to think filthy? He never explained his reasoning for voting him- I actually think someone pointed this out, but I think this vote came soon after I pointed out that I thought filthy was wolfy in a long-ish post and it was possible he was semi sponging me.

The underlined post is wolfy because it just reeks of one of those perfectly logical posts that really means nothing- is he trying to say that he's happy keeping his vote on filthy because UAW and I voted for him (bogan)? That makes no sense, especially since UAW never even mentioned bogan. I don't really understand what the first parts of the post and the second parts of his post have to do with each other (wolfy)...and if he somehow tries to relate them to each other, that's (wolfy) bad too.

I feel pretty good about this one- I also seem to remember villager bogan being more "troll-y" than this. There have also been a few people who are softpushing but not voting him/people who are soft defending him, which makes me feel a little better.

bogan4life
bsball puts out his case on bogan

Quote:
Originally Posted by rebonkulous
zayana until mets gets here and I bother to get on a comp
lol me

Quote:
Originally Posted by vuroth
I agree this isn't the bogan game that I've seen in the past, but it's SO different that I don't really have a read on him.

Zayana is my strongest wolf lean, but I don't see traction.

Out of my wolf leans with votes, I'd be most comfortable voting

filthyvermin

I don't have a strong opinion on any of the top 3 votegetters - bogan I already addressed, andynan pwned me in the mafia game, but like Bogan this is miles off what I've seen from him. My only note on exeondo is how he defended wowLucky.
vuroth votes filthy but says zayana is prolly wolf

Quote:
Originally Posted by enty
why should i vote bogan iyo ?

i reread the last half of andys posts, not really seeing the wolf.
i liked what okse pointed out about filthy: doesnt remember the case on exo, dismissed the points in his head, but has him as wolf.

filthy
enty jumps on giving filthy 3 votes at the time

Quote:
Originally Posted by Zayana
Bogan
zayana votes bogan

Quote:
Originally Posted by vuroth
sick xpost there's a zayana vote now.

zayana, which is what I wanted.
vuroth goes off of filthy to vote zayana which was his biggest wolf lean. really villagery here imo because filthy had 3 votes at the time and looked like a more legitimate wagon. If he were a wolf, he would probably want to continue to push filthy as a counterwagon to andy.

Quote:
Originally Posted by okse54
http://forumserver.twoplustwo.com/59...l#post25430161

this is where i start my case on him

oh and filthy
then okse jumps on the filthy wagon giving filthy 3 votes again, would've been 4 if vuroth hadn't swithced just before him. I think enty looks really bad here as he was trying to lynch two different people opposed to andy here. enty prolly a lock wolf at this point, especially since he missed all but the last two hours of D1.

Quote:
Originally Posted by enty
ive never played with bogan but i agree with bsball that his posts/reads seem detached and lack basis.

bogan

also zaya you feel a little weird ima keep my eye on you for the next days !
prob not voting you today though
he then switches onto bogan here.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Andynan
im shattered guys I gotta go to sleep

bogan sponging bsball

be good to Z if I go!
andy votes bogan

Quote:
Originally Posted by okse54
sigh looks like filthy isnt happening

andy > bogan though
and okse then reluctantly jumps onto andy, making the votes 5/5.

Quote:
Originally Posted by well named
****** VOTE COUNT ******

At #585

# Player name Vote
5 andynan bogan4life
0 birdman10687 bsball8806
5 bogan4life filthyvermin
1 bsball8806 bogan4life
0 cphoya andynan
0 enty bogan4life
0 exoendo vuroth
1 filthyvermin andynan
0 LuckayLuck andynan
0 metsandfinsfan andynan
1 okse54 andynan
1 rebonkulous zayana
0 titanrulez rebonkulous
0 uaw710 bogan4life
1 vuroth zayana
0 wowlucky okse54
2 zayana bogan4life
1  

lead votes:
5 - andynan
5 - bogan4life
2 - zayana
1 - okse54
enty looks worst from this all, i think vuroth looks ok despite voting a villager, exo bad for staying off wagon
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 10:45 AM
catching a train now will check in later.
birdman how come it took you so long to get here ?
how come you never posted your bsball is lock wolf explanation post ?
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 10:45 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by enty
stupid daylight savings screwed me up.

figured EOD was 10pm+6 = 4 am but you guys switched to DST and we didnt so its now 10pm+5.

sorry
the flogging hurt.

so that sucks about mets. zaya villa was his n0 peek i guess, anyone know the other one ?
cphoya villa n0

zayana villa n1
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 10:45 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Birdman10687
I don't get it bogan. If you are a villager, shouldn't you be trying to keep me from voting you? I honestly don't understand your strategy. Why don't you try to win?
I dont care if you vote me, i believe you to be a wolf and know that you will push my wagon no matter what i say.

Sure Bsball was a villa but do people honestly believe d1 was a w/w wagon
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 10:45 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Birdman10687
rebonkulous
ummmm no
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 10:46 AM
question to the people thinking im a lock wolf at this point.

what is your plan after i flip villa ?
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 10:46 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bogan4life
I dont care if you vote me, i believe you to be a wolf and know that you will push my wagon no matter what i say.

Sure Bsball was a villa but do people honestly believe d1 was a w/w wagon
First off, I'm not even voting you. If you are a villager, I don't want to lynch you. I just want you to explain why you lied to bsball. Like, what reason as a villager would you have to make up stuff? Just explain it to me.
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 10:47 AM
bbl for real now
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 10:47 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by okse54
ummmm no
ummm no what?
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 10:47 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by enty
catching a train now will check in later.
birdman how come it took you so long to get here ?
how come you never posted your bsball is lock wolf explanation post ?
I don't have work on Fridays.
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 10:48 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by enty
stupid daylight savings screwed me up.

figured EOD was 10pm+6 = 4 am but you guys switched to DST and we didnt so its now 10pm+5.

sorry
the flogging hurt.

so that sucks about mets. zaya villa was his n0 peek i guess, anyone know the other one ?
i always hate when people make reads like what im about to do, but could we assume that if enty was in wolf chat he wouldnt have been able to mess up daylight savings time
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 10:49 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Birdman10687
ummm no what?
.
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 10:51 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Birdman10687
ummm no what?
ummmm no way we are lynching rebonk today

period end of story

mets isnt here to be all metsy so ill step in, rebonk is off the table.

unless bogan flips wolf which i doubt he will, im probably never voting rebonk this game
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 10:52 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rebonkulous
cphoya villa n0

zayana villa n1
<3 zaya!!!!
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 10:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Birdman10687
First off, I'm not even voting you. If you are a villager, I don't want to lynch you. I just want you to explain why you lied to bsball. Like, what reason as a villager would you have to make up stuff? Just explain it to me.
Its easy to get reactions out of people once there blood is boiling and we misread his reaction to me. When i play ww as a villager i try to get people to spew so you experts can examine it all as we all know how easy i get bites.

With that i bid you a good night <3
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 11:04 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by enty
stupid daylight savings screwed me up.

figured EOD was 10pm+6 = 4 am but you guys switched to DST and we didnt so its now 10pm+5.

sorry
the flogging hurt.

so that sucks about mets. zaya villa was his n0 peek i guess, anyone know the other one ?
I was his N1 peek... CPHoya was his N0...

Oh... and...

enty
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 11:09 AM
Sorry guys, the last 24 hours or so have gone nothing like what I expected. I'm in full M-I-L entertainment mode. I should absolutely be able to catch up tomorrow, if not sooner.

V
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 11:11 AM
i might be biased because i was on the bsball wagon, but i feel like the wolves would have been slightly more likely to vote UAW than bsball for a couple reasons

#1 if UAW would have been lynched we prob spend all 3 days focusing on how bsball has to go still. which would derail the village for another day. while if bsball is the lynch UAW isnt necessarily going to be the focus of the village the next day, he can help himself by just posting more.

#2 even if it failed the wolves wouldnt be connected to the mislynch of bsball which is always on the wolves minds

also im a bit suspicious of those people who were convinced bsball couldnt be a wolf, it was clear to me he was the best wagon and to be so sure he was a bad wagon doesn't seem to fit so well

i want to do a reread later but off the top of my head those included

filthy
exo

obv if UAW ends up being a wolf none of what i said would apply, but if we assume it was V/V wagons for a second, do people agree it would be in the wolves interest for UAW to be the lynch yesterday?
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 11:21 AM
You're assuming UAW is a villager
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 11:25 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by okse54
i always hate when people make reads like what im about to do, but could we assume that if enty was in wolf chat he wouldnt have been able to mess up daylight savings time
People don't usually sit in wolf chat saying oh how much time left til EOD... plus he was playing Taboo in skypechat at the time. I believe I even made a comment that I would be distracted for 14 minutes and then be able to play. Granted I didn't say why I'd be distracted, so that doesn't mean a whole lot I guess.
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 11:30 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by okse54
i might be biased because i was on the bsball wagon, but i feel like the wolves would have been slightly more likely to vote UAW than bsball for a couple reasons

#1 if UAW would have been lynched we prob spend all 3 days focusing on how bsball has to go still. which would derail the village for another day. while if bsball is the lynch UAW isnt necessarily going to be the focus of the village the next day, he can help himself by just posting more.

#2 even if it failed the wolves wouldnt be connected to the mislynch of bsball which is always on the wolves minds

also im a bit suspicious of those people who were convinced bsball couldnt be a wolf, it was clear to me he was the best wagon and to be so sure he was a bad wagon doesn't seem to fit so well

i want to do a reread later but off the top of my head those included

filthy
exo

obv if UAW ends up being a wolf none of what i said would apply, but if we assume it was V/V wagons for a second, do people agree it would be in the wolves interest for UAW to be the lynch yesterday?
I was convinced he couldn't be a wolf. He was the most villagery I think I've seen from him. If I wasn't seer cleared I'd be in that list.

Enty, Titan I'm pretty sure are wolves... not sure on Bird anymore... I'd round the list out with Bogan right now. I'll give it some thought and reading this weekend. I do not want to be at odds with you like in flowerew though, so I will listen to what you have to say and your wagon analysis is usually pretty spot on.
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 11:48 AM
On hindsight the UAW wagon looks way cleaner than the Bsball wagon
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 11:56 AM
The people I listed yesterday in my villa section I'm pretty sure can be treated as clear villas. Two are dead now of course...

My thoughts right now...

LuckayLuck - The only person that was thinking like I was yesterday
Vuroth - villa
okse54 - villa
rebonkulous - villa, reevaluate him if Bogan is a wolf

UAW710 - need to see a wolf game of his, flowerew?
exoendo - villagery vibe beginning of day 2, has tapered off

filthyvermin - has had villagery moments, but done some shady things, will get attention this weekend.

WowLucky - I think he and I are playing a different game, based on posted comments

birdman10687 - wildcard for me, I have no clue what he is

bogan4life - d1 w/w wagons ftw maybe? I'll give this more thought

enty
Titanrulez
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 12:03 PM
# Player name Vote
2 birdman10687  
1 bogan4life bsball8806
5 bsball8806 uaw710
0 enty bsball8806
0 exoendo uaw710
0 filthyvermin uaw710
0 luckayluck birdman10687
0 metsandfinsfan bsball8806
0 okse54 bsball8806
0 rebonkulous uaw710
0 titanrulez uaw710
5 uaw710 bogan4life
0 vuroth  
0 wowlucky bsball8806
0 zayana birdman10687

I color coded the votes based on my thoughts of the voters, thanks to Titans comment and I agree... the UAW wagon does look a lot cleaner... but I'd lean toward v/v wagons yesterday. How/when did UAW catch on as a wagon? I wish I had been keeping a spreadsheet this game, I need it right now.
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-18-2011 , 12:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bogan4life
LOL its not my fault bsball was playing a bad game and seemed like a lock wolf. Its you or enty today soon
Bsball was not playing a bad game, seriously. I don't want to see that from anyone else either. He was seriously the most villagery I've ever seen from him. Reread his day 1. If people say this kind of stuff it's just going to bug me. I know I'm dead N3, but I kinda want to figure this out before then.

I'm also bummed that everyone that I normally would have been working with thought I was a wolf and if mets hadn't peeked me, you still would... and I'd have probably been lynched today for TMI, because I "knew" bsball was a villager.
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote

      
m