Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread 3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread

03-15-2011 , 01:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zayana
I don't necessarily think he should be the lynch mets. I think he is a better wagon than a lot of people. I think it's ridiculous that a lot of people have called him a wolf and he doesn't have any pressure at all. I think he should get some pressure.

Plus he's voting Vuroth.
pressure for what? what has he done that should give him pressure

and what has vuroth done that makes him such an awful vote

this is what im not liking about you this game zay

i usually understand where your thought process is; you usually explain it well; i may not always agree, but at least i get it

please tell me in 100 words or less:
why you are voting exo
why exo voting vuroth is horrible
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 01:17 PM
Context matters and player-specific reads matter. These two quotes are for Andynan, a player of who I peg as a 'carefree player, especially when villager.'

I think it is slightly more likely that Andynan is a wolf trying to level us out of wagoning him by welcoming a wagon than it is Andynan as a villager who is 'having fun' by being wagoned. It feels like an emulation of being carefree.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Andynan
I see that I am wagon and I think it is adequate, we are on our way to victory

Quote:
Originally Posted by Andynan
if this is an exercise in pressuring me, its kind of gay, get me to 8 votes or something that gets my juices flowing
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 01:17 PM
for example
i was on titan for a while

you didnt jump on even tho you think he can be a wolf

but you vote exo

even tho you dont necesarily think he should be the lynch?

ok fine

ZAYA, GUN TO HEAD, WHO SHOULD BE THE LYNCH?
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 01:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by okse54
i seriously hate this post
Okse, your style of play is combative and because of that, will easily get you mislynched. I find that a common theme in Werewolf around these parts.

On the bright side, I think you're a villager precisely because of your combativeness. You also railed against me following metsandfinsfan earlier - your post just now reminded me of that.

You're actually another easy villager read.
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 01:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by vuroth
clipped...
Brutal post. Even if the 2 most inactive are both wolves, that leaves 2 wolves among everyone else.
I have a lot of unknowns, first time playing with a few. So there are probably wolves in them, but it doesn't seem like there would be enough wolves in them. It's just a guess, I could be wrong. That's why I want to see what they have to say.
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 01:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by metsandfinsfan
for example
i was on titan for a while

you didnt jump on even tho you think he can be a wolf

but you vote exo

even tho you dont necesarily think he should be the lynch?

ok fine

ZAYA, GUN TO HEAD, WHO SHOULD BE THE LYNCH?
I'd have to reread him, but right now I'd say Titan. He feels like Archer to me, he was a wolf there.
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 01:22 PM
why is a vuroth vote so horrible zayana?

why?
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 01:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zayana
I'd have to reread him, but right now I'd say Titan. He feels like Archer to me, he was a wolf there.
Spoiler:
then you should probably be voting him instead of sponging bsball
Spoiler:
donuts
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 01:24 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by metsandfinsfan
pressure for what? what has he done that should give him pressure

and what has vuroth done that makes him such an awful vote

this is what im not liking about you this game zay

i usually understand where your thought process is; you usually explain it well; i may not always agree, but at least i get it

please tell me in 100 words or less:
why you are voting exo
why exo voting vuroth is horrible
I'll break it down for you, next post, it'll take a bit.
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 01:32 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by vuroth
Brutal post. Even if the 2 most inactive are both wolves, that leaves 2 wolves among everyone else.

I know her style has evolved since she started playing here, but this post doesn't fit what I know of Zayana's village game.



This only comes up after bsball pointed out that birdman hadn't been posting much. Kind of like rather than coming up with his own read, he read bsball's post and decided it smelled like an opportunity to drive a mislynch.

i.e. wolfy lean



Zayana answered this I think, but no gimmick. I've played WW with some friends elsewhere, and I've played the occasional game here over the last 6-8 months. Probably less than 12 pog games in total.



This post was aimed at luckayluck. Honestly, LL is capable of making posts that I feel he 100% has to be lynched for as a villager. So definitely his post was role neutral.



Obviously none of us can read him day 1 with any reliability.

Look, if you're going to choose to follow mets because he's a 75% bet to be villa, and he's a strong villa then just say you're playing the odds and have done.


I'm still pondering the titan/rebonk/oske interaction at the end of page 3, but I will say this. okse's snap vote for exo on page 4, right after mets gogogo, was poorly timed. Lean wolf.

Oh and UAW needs to post more. His entrance was wolfy, but nothing else stands out as yet.

My strongest villa read is CPHoya.

/braindump off
i must have only skimmed this before

but on reread, this is an amazing post
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 01:33 PM
I present LuckayLuck's "You're either a Villager or You're Not" List.

CPHoya
Filthy
Luckayluck
Metsandfinsfan
Okse
Rebonk
Voruth
Wowlucky
Zayana


Andynan
Birdman
Bogan
Bsball
Enty
Exo
Titan
UAW
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 01:35 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Titanrulez
?
This is such a staunch defense of oske that I don't see them both being wolves.

Quote:
Originally Posted by rebonkulous
Do YOU guys think mets is a wolf?
I kind of get what rebonk is saying, but this last line reads like an attack. I think the village way to handle titan/oske's questions is to explain and move on, and rebonk's tone in that specific conversation is a bit wolfy.

I probably won't vote rebonk today, as I have stronger leans, but that's my read on that little tiff.
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 01:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by metsandfinsfan
bsball

your role in the following:
2/21 slow game
2/3 madmen
disney
attack of awesomeness

you do use it a lot. i still dont like it in context. but i want to know your roles in those games and im too lazy to recheck
don't remember
villager
villager
villager
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 01:43 PM
I leave this thread by leaving my vote on:

[ANDYNAN]

I consider him a very good lynch today. He has not been his "usual" carefree inquisitive self, instead, I find him emulating it, in particular with his invitation of votes (a wolf ploy of reverse psychology).

I would find a lynch of players on the 'blue' list of mine disappointing, and would be approving of a lynch of players on the 'red' list. On retroactive observation of metsandfinsfan's list, I find it is essentially the same. I did not copy, so we approached the same conclusion independently (as he had his list first). LuckayLuck's crystal ball finds the likelihood of lynching a wolf increased by the presence of metsandfinsfan and mostly accurate reads, I set the line at 66.6% of a wolf lynch today.
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 01:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by metsandfinsfan
why is a vuroth vote so horrible zayana?

why?
Because I think Vuroth is a villager right now.

Here's the thing, hope this makes it clearer for you... Yes, my reads on Luckay, WowLucky, filthy and CHoya are meaningless because it's the first time I've played with them... but I gave them day 1 villa leans for the posts I included. Filthy is because of tone on a lot of posts, not sure about him at all. I don't really have a read on birdman at all. I'll reevaluate once I have something concrete to work with, but this is my day 1 crapshoot. Current order villa to wolf:

bsball8806 - villa
Vuroth - villa
metsandfinsfan - villa
okse54 - probably villa
LuckayLuck - villa lean (154)
rebonkulous - maybe villa

WowLucky - probably villa, mets 325
filthyvermin - v?
CPHoya - 168, 172

Andynan - ?
UAW710 - ?

birdman10687 - ?
enty - hasn't posted

bogan4life - calling me villa right away, sucking up?

exoendo
Titanrulez - Archer
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 01:51 PM
so exo is purely poe?
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 01:57 PM
Not 100%, I had my own thoughts about why Vuroth thought the comment was wolfy... So I'd think villagers would speculate as to what they are.

Quote:
Originally Posted by exoendo
non-comittal/non-substantive read

vuroth
Exo votes him for it here. I mentioned what my thoughts had been a few posts late and thought this was weird at the time.

So he got a w? at the time and hasn't been around to change my mind.
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 01:59 PM
i think exo thinking it was a noncommittal/not substantive read isnt wolfy
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 01:59 PM
and you voting him still bothers me

but ill back off you

for now
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 02:00 PM
He is POE in the respect that he hasn't been villagery and other people have to me. I think he should have a little pressure mets, I'll be voting Titan EOD though, unless something changes.

I could be wrong on some of my villa's I know that, I'm not clearing the list for the game. It's just my current thoughts.
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 02:03 PM
andynan
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 02:07 PM
Would you feel better if I was voting Titan? I hate that this game is sucking me in so much. I'm seriously fine with exo/bogan/titan wagons... I've said that before.

Titan >>> Bogan

Someone else that was in Archer should tell me if I'm crazy or not with respect to Titan.
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 02:10 PM
titan vote is better than exo at this moment

at least you have a reason for it

titan made a few posts i found villagery. his fakefight he tried starting with me ... was wolfy, but his backoff of it seems villagery. i dont know. im going ot reassess

i decided im not pushing titan today
but i wont fight a titan lynch
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 02:21 PM
I just reread Titan, what posts did you think were villagery? He cleared me way, way too early imo. Maybe he has a reason, but it doesn't feel right to me.

I hate that Andy's probably a good vote.
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote
03-15-2011 , 02:41 PM
****** VOTE COUNT ******

# Player name Vote
4 andynan wowlucky
0 birdman10687 wowlucky
2 bogan4life filthyvermin
0 bsball8806 bogan4life
0 CPHoya andynan
0 enty  
2 exoendo vuroth
1 filthyvermin andynan
0 LuckayLuck andynan
0 metsandfinsfan andynan
1 okse54 exoendo
1 rebonkulous uaw710
0 Titanrulez rebonkulous
0 UAW710 bogan4life
0 Vuroth  
0 WowLucky okse54
0 Zayana exoendo

lead votes:
4 - andynan
2 - wowlucky
2 - exoendo
2 - bogan4life
1 - okse54

to gabe for doing all the work

night at 10pm server
3/14 Vanilla Slow Werewolf Game Thread Quote

      
m