Quote:
Originally Posted by bhuber2010
riki - bhuber
fonisian - doc
TehBankertin - riki
achro - no peek
road - banks
dorian78 - did you leave a clear peek?
Slendy - did you leave a clear peek?
Still havent heard from these two but for the sake of discussion, I'll allude to my thoughts now (I have slendy as a pretty hard town lean so I am not as concerned about him although I still think it would be useful to know 100% if either of them left explicit peeks).
Since we know that cue did not leave an explicit peek, it means the mafia took a calculated risk in killing him over a number of players that DID leave explicit peeks. This means that their peeks were wrong or the mafia didnt not believe them enough to glean that that person was indeed the real cop.
A level 0 read would therefore be that the following people look bad/didnt have believable cop cover IF indeed their claims were correct: riki, tehbankertin, and roads.
I know riki's claim was correct, so the wolves either didnt believe it or riki is scum.
TehBankertin not dying alludes to the fact that his peek was wrong, or he is mafia.
Roads peek was wrong, or he is mafia.
____
I'll get back to this point in a second.
This is all fascinating, and I wish I'd thought to go back and look at it sooner. I'm just not used to this kind of info being the prime factor in who is chosen for the nightkill. I think it is also worth looking at from not-bhuber's perspective, and so I double-checked. I don't remember Slendy leaving a clear peek, and if he did, it was with a different word, cause his filter says he first used the word "peek" on day 2. Like someone else mentioned, we know fonti was right, and so I'm leaving her out of the scenarios.
If the team is road/bhuber, they knew Riki was wrong, and they didn't believe Banks. This team is probably also having little to no communication on N1, so I can believe them coming to a choice that doesn't fit what everyone here seems to look for.
If the team is road/Banks, they didn't believe Riki.
If the team is Riki/bhuber, they didn't believe road.
The other teams (Riki/road, Riki/Banks, and bhuber/Banks) all neatly solve everything from this angle (except fonti, who's a constant outlier in every scenario). These are all teams I haven't considered much, and this fact tells me I should start considering them more seriously.