Quote:
Originally Posted by Riki
which parts did you disagree with?
His conclusion that i was scum. obv
Quote:
Originally Posted by dorian78
Ok. I need to go run some errands, but I want my thoughts on pairings out there first.
1. bhuber makes sense as a possible pair with just about anyone, as he more or less has zero interactions with any of the others that are being considered.
2. road doesn't really make a good pair with any of the suspects besides bhuber. Before MSU's claim, my Doc vote wasn't gaining any traction, and I was this close to switching to road as my other scumread. Well, or MSU because he was way too good at intentionally scumming it up and I was falling for it. Riki and I both were set to vote road yesterday, and if either of us were going to bus a teammate, Ratchet was by far the best choice. I mean, look at how much credit Doc got for going after Ratchet, even before he was cleared by the cop.
3. Riki and I make an odd pair. He went after me really hard at the start of the game, waffled back and forth on me at the end of day 1, and then buddied me super-hard day 2 before MSU's claim. Like, I posted all my reads, and he basically said, yup I agree with almost everything. I guess it's possible from other people's perspective, but I know I'm town, and it just seems like a ton of interaction for 2 teammates.
4. I think road/Riki is unlikely, and I know road/me is wrong. If it's not road/bhuber, I see scenarios where lynching the 4 of us doesn't win us the game. That means I probably need to at least consider someone else. My first inclination is Banks, simply because of the day 1 final vote tally. Whether or not that's seriously worth considering would require me to go over Banks's interactions with Ratchet and all the other suspects, and that's a very daunting prospect. I'll gladly put that effort in if it gets to the point where I need to, but it doesn't seem necessary yet.
TL;DR
I still like road/bhuber the best, followed by bhuber/Riki.
I can totally see how bhuber/me is viable to everyone else, but I know it's wrong.
I don't think road/Riki seems right.
I know road/me and Riki/me are wrong, and I don't think they should seem right to others.
bhuber flipping mafia doesn't tell us anything about anyone, barring future interactions today. road flipping mafia tells a fair bit more. For now,
road
Lol this seems opportunistic. What are the math behind this thought? From what I read there you think there are a bigger probability that bhuber are mafia than me.
You are just assuming in your conclusio nthat either of us flips mafia. Try to consider the fact that we could flip villagers. I know i will flip villager, and then what info have you gained?
I think bhuber wil lflip villager, and then what info have you gained?
I think this is the wrong way to look at it.
I mean, if i were to be lynched and flip scum, then you would say that riki couldnt be my partner, which means bhuber would be next for lynch. The the info gained with lynching me is no bigger than lynching bhuber, because he would be lynched anyway - from your train of thoughts.
I just dont see why it makes sense to not lynch who you find most scummy in this situation.
Anyways, this only makes sense of you to screw up intentionally if you were scum with bhuber, which I as of now dont find likely
Quote:
Originally Posted by Riki
basically
i mean there's also the stuff i mentioned yesterday where he's kind of been floating through this game and i can't think of many new or original ideas he's mentioned during this game
and i briefly read his game 3 filter and thought he's been much softer here than in that game, despite being the seer for the first time in that game
also i like that dorian has been doing some work today and probably want to lynch him less than road/bhuber
I dont think this is true. I can try to find some posts from game 3