Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) 2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16)

09-17-2013 , 06:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TimeLady
Shortline, OCD, telcontar, xxsooted, Jdalla and CDL are all >90% villagers. Sun tzu and wahoo are lock villagers. Noah, neil, globe and Hoya have been villagery today. I still think soah is more likely a villager than a wolf.

Still think Elliot is mad shady as hell, but no one else seems to be talking about that.
I don't think we should be hard-clearing telcontar for his TEPM case/vote

I'm not saying we should lynch him any time soon but I don't think bussing is out of the question
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Noah
I think I remember the last game I played with you was the one CDL was in also. Hoya modded. You don't think his play here is very in line with his village game?
you mean he's trolling and trying to be wrong about everything?

yeah, I'd definitely sponge that
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:03 PM
I'm here now and catching up

I called last night wrong obviously. happy to talk about my thought process there, because I'd possibly do it again. But I would prefer to talk about what actually happened and who is now a wolf.
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:04 PM
I'm also hoping that moni gets resolved at some point...if he is power wolf then of course wolves push to lynch tepm/thingy over him

We can't just clear him forever
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:04 PM
Think there's any chance Roundtower posts today?
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:04 PM
Votes from post 845 to post 1380
Night in 1:56:52

---
VotesLynchVoters
13 RoundTower Nicholasp27 (6), JDalla (22), globetrotter (39), TimeLady (27), Felix the Cat (28), atakdog (15), CPHoya (32), bobman0330 (3), shortline99 (58), CalledDownLight (36), aaronk56 (2), metsandfinsfan (44), Luckbox Inc (16)
3 OrangeRake Neil S (16), chuckleslovakian (11), OneCrazyDuck (4)
3 TimeLady Sun Tzu (24), XXsooted (8), soah (23)
3 soah J.D. (7), Tao1 (6), Youngplayer9 (1)
2 ZomgHax Senor Cardgage (7), vaya (13)
1 keshaldra Noah (23)
1 JDalla ElliotR (1)
1 Neil S BombayBadboy (1)
1 CalledDownLight wahoopride (4)
8 not voting ZomgHax (0), Telcontar (4), RoundTower (1), OrangeRake (9), monikrazy (3), legend42 (4), keshaldra (0), DiggertheDog (25)
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:04 PM
xpost woo
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:04 PM
How do we trigger a countif?
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by soah
you mean he's trolling and trying to be wrong about everything?

yeah, I'd definitely sponge that
Ah okay, I see what you are getting at, I thought you were wanting to bertstare because you think he's a wolf.
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TimeLady
Gone through well nameds posts and got this:



combining this with his earlier reads post, which iirc had tao second to bottom (after thingyman, the other 'peeked wolf').

non-zero chance tao was the fake peek he was killed for
"possibly giving up free stats" = not a wolf peek
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:05 PM
Ok, 13 is ridiculous

neil
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:06 PM
Quote:
happy to talk about my thought process there, because I'd possibly do it again.
Quick, do this now.
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:06 PM
Can someone please comment on my keshaldra post from earlier?

Felix, you asked for it in the first place and have said nothing.

I'm not even caught up with the thread yet and think he's been super wolfy and yet no-one seems to be talking about him at all.
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:08 PM
Atak, you are right...I completely forgot about the roleblocker there

Chuck, u should know well that I always claim with all villagers, so your post is incorrect...claiming with wolf is very different and shouldn't be done be a villager
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Felix the Cat
Dear lord Shorty, this post makes baby Jesus cry.

You're telling me that if you're a wolf and you need to quickly kill 2 seers and an angel to make winning easier and you have 2 kills to play with... you kill one seer candidate and his peek (who happened to have, as far as I can tell, either no peek or an implausible one)... just for snits and giggles? You really have no sense of urgency about, y'know, actually killing seer candidates?

I don't even know what to say.
obviously forsy was a seer candidate too

yes it makes sense to kill 2 seer candidates with some overlap such as one being another's peek

no one is suggesting that forsy was killed only because he was WN's peek
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Noah
Can someone please comment on my keshaldra post from earlier?

Felix, you asked for it in the first place and have said nothing.

I'm not even caught up with the thread yet and think he's been super wolfy and yet no-one seems to be talking about him at all.
I also have kesh pinging my wolfdar and would join you in this crusade
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by shortline99
HEY GUYS THERE ARE FIVE VILLAGER POWER ROLES THREE OF WHICH ARE DEFINITELY NOT SEERS AND PROBABLY WOULD NOT LEAVE PEEKS BECAUSE THEY DON'T WANT TO GET SEER HUNTED

SOMETIMES IT IS OKAY TO NIGHTKILL PLAYERS WHO DO NOT LEAVE PEEKS
also seers sometimes don't leave peeks
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Felix the Cat
Unless alternate universe seer soah peeked alternate universe wolf vig/RB Thingy, which I believe was the assumption.
I said as much wrt vig. I added the RB in my next post.

But by the time nich was voting, soah clearly hadn't pushed the whole thing so that would have been a silly assumption for nich to make — and even making it, he should have mentioned the existence of a roleblocker. He didn't, thus I conclude he wasn't actually trying to work out the mechanics of the situation.
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Felix the Cat
Meh whatever, that is a suitably convincing case that we should read WNs peek as Forsy.

RoundTower in that case

Now I'm even more interested in why Forsy died because explaining it away as "wolves killed possible seer and his peek" is astoundingly sponge level thinking.

I hope the cable guy gets my interwebs hooked up before EOD.
if forsy didn't leave anything peekish other than "soah is a wolf" then I assume that post had something to do with why he died

either because soah is a wolf or to make it easier to lynch soah
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Noah
keshaldra:







Big fluffy reply to well named voting him. Lots of words, says very little.











Lots of words about SK stuff. Immersing in conversation that is easy and doesn't go anyway definitive.







EOD is what I hate. Has a strong opinion on TEPM, although it's stated mildly, and an opinioin on the counter wagon to TEPM that gets more clear, but doesn't move his vote. Talking about both wagons in a close race at EOD but showing no urgency to do anything about his reads and remaining off-wagon.

Conclusion: wolf
i like it!
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by shortline99
6 posts
18 posts
2 posts
6 posts
4 posts

Who are the wolves that are posting?
I wouldn't rule out digger, atakdog, senor and luckbox at this point, though I'd probably go at them in that order
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Noah
Can someone please comment on my keshaldra post from earlier?

Felix, you asked for it in the first place and have said nothing.

I'm not even caught up with the thread yet and think he's been super wolfy and yet no-one seems to be talking about him at all.
I'll get back to it, Shorty tarding out distracted me.
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TimeLady
I wouldn't rule out digger, atakdog, senor and luckbox at this point, though I'd probably go at them in that order
eh, swap luckbox and senor
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sun Tzu
obviously forsy was a seer candidate too

yes it makes sense to kill 2 seer candidates with some overlap such as one being another's peek

no one is suggesting that forsy was killed only because he was WN's peek
If you think about it that's precisely what shorty is suggesting

(hint: in vacuum all villagers are equally likely to be angel/rb/seer who didn't leave a peek)
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote
09-17-2013 , 06:18 PM
I'm not going to vote for RT because I do not think that he is a wolf. This is based on many posts but I'm just quoting this one to point out one thing:

Quote:
Originally Posted by RoundTower
I am down with not autolynching Thingy now that soah has effectively unclaimed. still OK with lynching him for, you know, being wolfy

TEPM counterwagon is not going to convince me, I could live with Neil S or moni though

still want to hear from the shortline camp on 'hell no don't ever kill Thingy here', because the existence of that camp alone is enough to make me vote Thingy
The odds of RT-wolf writing this line are close to 0% if Neil and moni are villagers. He would already be drawing lots of bad attention to himself by going so hard on Thingy. It makes no sense that he would explicitly endorse every village bandwagon and hard-oppose the only wolf wagon. But really though, even regardless of Neil and moni's roles, it's hard to see him not only being so adamantly wrong about Thingy, but also TEPM as well.

Shortline's theory is based around the wolves really wanting Thingy lynched d1, not necessarily that they were saving TEPM for a day. RT's behavior doesn't even fit that theory. If that were really his goal, and if he wants to minimize the hit to his credibility, then he didn't need to argue for moni and Neil over TEPM.

Being wrong is not wolfy and RT was not wrong in a wolfy way.
2009 Werewolf Reunion Game (2013/09/16) Quote

      
m