2/3 The Battle of Disneyland Mishmash Extravaganza: Game Thread!
02-04-2014
, 02:47 PM
02-04-2014
, 02:47 PM
02-04-2014
, 02:47 PM
02-04-2014
, 02:48 PM
02-04-2014
, 02:48 PM
02-04-2014
, 02:49 PM
02-04-2014
, 02:49 PM
02-04-2014
, 02:49 PM
lol okay
god forbid anyone QUESTIONS THE GRATE AND POWERFUL VYK
give me a break. you never give reasons & then you are wrong. i am suspicious of her myself so i wanted your reasons. totally outs me
he peeked well named wolf
guess that isn't game changing or clearing really
but i've got a villa read on him
and on you too
Quad feels like a villager to me today. sorry i voted you last night.
nah, Charry could be a villager. not sure about quarrr.
god forbid anyone QUESTIONS THE GRATE AND POWERFUL VYK
give me a break. you never give reasons & then you are wrong. i am suspicious of her myself so i wanted your reasons. totally outs me
he peeked well named wolf
guess that isn't game changing or clearing really
but i've got a villa read on him
and on you too
Quad feels like a villager to me today. sorry i voted you last night.
nah, Charry could be a villager. not sure about quarrr.
02-04-2014
, 02:49 PM
02-04-2014
, 02:49 PM
02-04-2014
, 02:50 PM
Quote:
(about ash's last 2 posts)
(in response to Gad continuing to accuse him)
^ responding to Gad
So basically, Ash jumps on a TTT post that was clearly intended to be a joke and gets chewed out for it. I think Ash is telling the truth about not being familiar with Tom as a player - he picked out a weird post from someone he thought would be an easy target (RIP Ash) and called him a wolf. I tend to think this makes Tom a villager. There'd be no reason for Ash to pursue a wolf bro with his first read in this spot - imo. Also it's pretty clear from his posting afterwards that he did not anticipate it developing into a big deal, and that he was not familiar with Tom's meta. Two things that, if they were both wolves, would not have been the case.
Then, Gad jumps on Ash for the post, and vehemently defends it to Monkey, who says that Ash is just being silly, and that having four wolves at this point in the game is actually villagery. He later rescinds this when Ash corrects him about the meaning of an earlier post.
I think this looks good for Gad, I know he's a good wolf but this seems like an unnecessary place to bus so aggressively, to personally begin a discussion about Ash who had previously drawn no attention/heat whatsoever. If Ash is a godfather, I suppose there's an argument to be made that Gad could have been trying to cast suspicion on him early to get a peek later ...? Eh, doesn't really fit imo. Ash isn't the kind of player that gets peeked, he's the kind of player that gets shot. Also, no one would have remembered something from so early on D1 when they actually decided to take the shot near EoD. I think it's much more likely that Gad is just a villager with a good read.
As far as MB is concerned, I can't really decide one way or the other, and would appreciate others' input. I guess I'd say minor wolf points for it, not because he was defending Ash, but because he backtracked on it at the end. Like he may have decided Ash did look bad and wanted to distance himself from him in the end.
(in response to Gad continuing to accuse him)
^ responding to Gad
So basically, Ash jumps on a TTT post that was clearly intended to be a joke and gets chewed out for it. I think Ash is telling the truth about not being familiar with Tom as a player - he picked out a weird post from someone he thought would be an easy target (RIP Ash) and called him a wolf. I tend to think this makes Tom a villager. There'd be no reason for Ash to pursue a wolf bro with his first read in this spot - imo. Also it's pretty clear from his posting afterwards that he did not anticipate it developing into a big deal, and that he was not familiar with Tom's meta. Two things that, if they were both wolves, would not have been the case.
Then, Gad jumps on Ash for the post, and vehemently defends it to Monkey, who says that Ash is just being silly, and that having four wolves at this point in the game is actually villagery. He later rescinds this when Ash corrects him about the meaning of an earlier post.
I think this looks good for Gad, I know he's a good wolf but this seems like an unnecessary place to bus so aggressively, to personally begin a discussion about Ash who had previously drawn no attention/heat whatsoever. If Ash is a godfather, I suppose there's an argument to be made that Gad could have been trying to cast suspicion on him early to get a peek later ...? Eh, doesn't really fit imo. Ash isn't the kind of player that gets peeked, he's the kind of player that gets shot. Also, no one would have remembered something from so early on D1 when they actually decided to take the shot near EoD. I think it's much more likely that Gad is just a villager with a good read.
As far as MB is concerned, I can't really decide one way or the other, and would appreciate others' input. I guess I'd say minor wolf points for it, not because he was defending Ash, but because he backtracked on it at the end. Like he may have decided Ash did look bad and wanted to distance himself from him in the end.
This does look bad for MB, I plan on reading him and seeing what I think as soon as search is working again.
02-04-2014
, 02:50 PM
02-04-2014
, 02:51 PM