You seemed pretty obviously villagery in HP - I had you as one of my most likely villagers that didn't have mechanical reasons attached to it - and that seems a little absent here. Phone posting makes some sense but it's weird for nike to think you're so villagery when if anything you've been notable less villagery

so this is what the MFFNike wolf game looks like?

Do you think you can read birdman better than most given the relation?

What do you think of him this game?

Same question for him

No

Probably >rand villa, not >>

good question

that's what i thought!

whatever reasons people had for wolf reading you last game were invalid and should be ignored and forgotten

I wasn't the only person who thought you were a super obvious villager

keep in mind that the further games go the worse the village gets in terms of people knowing up from down because the wolves are killing off everyone with a clue

this factor is largely mitigated by the accumulation of information but by the time a game gets late the village is usually headless chickens

lynching you and manasi was ridiculous

He's posted very little but it's excusable considering his eye stuff. I felt like I had him pegged as a wolf in HP but I was very wrong so I'm wondering why you're reading him as such here

This may be the first post of Xkf's that I have agreed with this game.

It's kind of freaking me out.

this feels like a villagery reaction to that list

Ya not sure if there were any worse lunch options for the village on those days. I think if UD is a villager here it should be pretty obvious once she's done phone posting

Sun you never told me if you were intentionally ignoring me in HP before I ITA'd you

I’m better at reading village leans, or maybe still bad but it’s easier for me think someone is villa this early?

Contrary to what I said earlier about not being able to read Sun Tzu, I think he is likely a villager given his engagement and his “watch and analyze” methods. He seems to be playing the same as in HP, but admittedly idk his wolf style but I don’t get those vibes from him.
I think VR has also been villagery because she posts a lot and makes sense to me, aside from voting birdman for voting her I think we are on similar wavelengths.

As for wolves, I am kinda suspicious of everyone. It’s hard to say because there are quite a few low posters who I can’t read. The CQ/xkf thing was weird but seems almost completely off topic and not really about this game— which fits my limited meta on both of them as just chaotic af. I can’t tell on Birdman, all my meta is irl and his behavior seems role neutral based on that. Obviously no read on CC but I’m not sure I like that Outdrawrd came in, voted her, and then pretty much dipped.

This is more than you asked for, I’m just thinking out loud. I plan to go through the thread tonight to make actual notes when I have some time.

I'm wondering what if cq is a villager and what if birdman and/or xkf are wolves

I feel like I would owe vr something

thanks! i like this post. maybe it's just because we have similar reads but i'm inclined not to vote for you today.

did either of CQ/xkf come off as more villagery or more wolfy, or were you not able to draw a conclusion you feel strongly enough to share?

They’re both complete wildcards to me and tbh my eyes glazed over trying to follow their conversation. I only have meta for them as villagers and they both seem consistently erratic. Like, CQ was aggressively trying to clear Xkf— why was that such an ordeal lol??

sort of. I saw you asking me to respond but I didn't feel like it was worth responding to. I probably should've just said I wasn't really wolf-reading you so much as sticking you in poe due to not seeing anything villagery yet

but there was some degree of hoping you would kill me as well as some degree of being stubborn in not feeling like I should have to respond to **** I don't care about

kind of wanting to die is pretty lame I guess

and I guess I was also kind of being a dick so I'm sorry

in the future, I'll try not to do that, but I'd also prefer if you just let flippant comments go

it’s funny because i have been thinking if cq flips villager you are very likely a wolf

lol, fair enough. i felt the same way.

there it is

MFFNike

VR-

i asked you to show me where i was trying to push UD

and also why you think i am wolf?

i'm not a wildcard i'm a villager

it's funny because I was thinking you were setting up to push me if cq is v

I think I have sun more villagery than birdman