Aston is a she, FWIW.

Inb4 bob is sexist

In before Ethics 101: Hosted by Chilltown.

I think anarchist and tbop are villas

Maybe chill too. And tbob has a point regarding Mac being the kind of guy people will talk themselves into voting. But that leaves me without a wolf. Hoping lkj is villa too.

i agree with this except i think tbop is slightly more villagery than anarchist

i also think you are a villager, and i still have lkj as a villager

I mean Chill is probably a villain in this game and a sociopath in real life who feels that it's okay to tank a game like this for meta reasons for future games, and he should apologize to the world for feeling that way.

Meh, as I write that, it doesn't fully fit because he tries hard as a wolf too. He could be doing this regardless of affiliation. Vote stays there for now until Chill either begins trying or offers a full apology for his moral fiber.

Anarchist and Chilltown are the best wolf leads of people who have posted so far (somewhat by POE), but we need everyone else to join the game.

lkj why do you think hardcore/mcavoy/me are villagers

I want you to explain what you think I am going to say first.

I barely do think this. Basically the small sampling of posts from each didn't contain anything that pinged me. But it's not like I'm treating you as clear.

You're probably the clearest of that threesome by virtue of being one of the people in the thread trying.

Woah woah woah there.

How can you even make that assumption right now?

Sounds like LKJ knows what I am.

Explain your read bro.

I think you're going to stonewall and refuse to answer.

Haha. I meant villager, not villain.

re: bolded. you're making your play uneffective by commenting on the reasoning behind it. also I wonder how much can anyone actually get from casting a vote like this. I don't think I could ever read someone reacting to an early d1 vote 'for being utr and unknown' as wolfy, and I think the reason is your vote doesn't require any reaction. so this strikes me as forced.

regarding mcavoy, that's true. people like wagoning him. having said that, I found his reaction to my early stuff wolfy too. I was mostly directing my 'wolves are lurking' comment at him, since he was online at the time and posting a lot on the pub. so he was lurking, he was clearly avoiding the thread, he made like 150 posts in the pub and only one here, and it's basically a very forced, bad vote that he never found himself compelled to explain. the fact that he checked out of the thread is just as alarming as his activity level after the thread was up and he could post but chose not to. so yeah, although I agree he is usually a copout lynch, I like the votes on him.

mcavoy

Explain your villa read on me and I will.

Because tanking to mess with your meta is more likely to be done as a villager than as a wolf if that is your true intention. Villagers get lynched over being uncharacteristically UtR.

Then again, the fact that you announced it in the thread probably makes that first paragraph a level one read that I shouldn't trust. Why would you announce that as your intention if that's truly what you were doing as a villager?

So maybe my vote is in the right place.

So you're waffling now.

this is exactly the kind of comment I expect Xkf to make early as a villager. it's hard to talk about his wolf game meta since it's just a game (and I've been wrong about Xkf every single time I played with him...) but as a villager he spots inconsistencies in other people's reasoning in interrogatory mode, which is a very interesting trait.

I need to research that further but it might be a registered mark of villaging Xkf (or can be entirely role neutral and I'm stupid).

...

ok I wrote that and went to see Police Squad game because I thought I saw something to that extent there, but I didn't. so I may be on to nothing here, but he's done the same type of comment as a villager in Duckburg finest vanilla game:

and Xkf's reaction...

hah it's funny how I got a different memory of it. but still, I find the reaction similar here. gotta dig deeper, but I feel that comment makes Xkf >rand to be a villager.

he is also not trying hard and not making reads list, which is good because this is something I saw in his wolf game but not in many of his villa games.

Yes. God forbid I waffle while I try to figure out the game during the first half of d1. I should pridefully tunnel like a ****ing idiot on d1 like some certain players prefer to do.

So, are you confirming that you're stonewalling the ethics question?

I didn't even read that post.

Why would I care when you've openly tanked a game to do nothing but troll me?

I didn't tank a game with the intention of trolling you. I followed this theorem:

I don't think I did much of any trolling before ~d3 of that game, when you decided to make the dumbest case imaginable on me and then pretend that it wasn't dumb. Such things SHOULD be mocked; I was doing the noblest thing a person could do in that spot.

In any case, petty and immature desire for revenge doesn't justify tanking if you're a villager here, so I encourage you to go ahead and play the game.

I'll play if xnerd plays too.

I like the way this game is progression, very slow.

I'll be able to bink off the wolf team d1 I bet.

Votes from post 2 to post 74
Night in 06:47:28
---

Votes	Lynch	Voters
4	McAvoy	hardcoreUFO (5), Anarchist (7), Xkf (4), globetrotter (5)
1	hardcoreUFO	McAvoy (1)
1	LKJ	Chilltown (13)
1	Chilltown	LKJ (24)
1	AstonMartinDB9	TBobLP (11)
5	not voting	AstonMartinDB9 (0), Crossnerd (0), Felix the Cat (0), starrazz (0), VarianceMinefield (0)