Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread 10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread

10-28-2011 , 01:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Silman
Trust that I have a reason. Remember this post and ask me in a few days.
Ftr I don't get it either
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene
Okay, so claim time:

I am the village randomizer. I out this for the following reasons:

1) This is not typically a village role, which lends credence to my suspicion that I'm a miller.

2) It is certainly not a particularly helpful role for the village, which means I'm not likely to get nked by the wolves/neutrals by revealing it. Ideally this means that I can stick around for a while and do my best to give good reads and stuff to help my team win like I did in GoT. (For example: A. Ertbjerg villa lean, and derwi, VM, and Silman wolf leans -- derwi on some tone stuff, VM because of his sustained focus on neutrals, Silman because he's previously said that a focus on neutrals is a wolf tell, but yet he's calling VM villa here.)

3) I would not be at all surprised if my power didn't actually work, just as I was supposedly a double voter in Dark Tower but just turned out to be a miller with no special voting powers at all. In any event, I'm probably not going to even try to use my power until I'm sure that circumstances warrant, because I don't want to be responsible for accidental bad outcomes.

I'll reread this morning and try to give some more reads. I'm sure I'm just going to get ITAed or vigged by villas or lynched anyway, but everything in this post is 100 percent truthful.
i definitely don't think these are good reasons to out your role. you're not even sure what the role does, yet you're already convinced that it's useless to the village. just use it and see what happens ffs. lastly, how can you be so sure you're going to get ITA'ed or vigged when you're like 4 posts into D1?!

Quote:
Originally Posted by officedog
Gad WTF???? Why would you say this?

I've never known a wolf to be a randomizer! And it can be terrible helpful to the village! If someone admits in thread their move didn't get the right results, odds are 99% they are a villager.

As for being a miller, I think you're either way paranoid, or this is wolf cover. AORN, I'm voting paranoid. But damn, this was not a good move.
qft
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Loretta8
i explained this already, getting killed by the wolves when you're a villager isn't very annoying, i take it as a compliment when the wolves kill me n1, but getting hit by the village vig when you're a villager is really goddamn annoying
A good, Loretta:
thoughts on xxsooted and Palo?
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:03 PM
night in 6:57
---
VotesLynchVoters
4CalledDownLightHadis, officedog, Old Man Willow, Swiitch
2XXsooted ShadowZero, silman
1 GadareneCalledDownLight
1Hadis iamnotawerewolf
1officedognecro
1 Palo Gabethebabe
1 ShadowZero FCBLComish
1VarianceMinefieldsupine
23not votingA.Ertjberg, berksonz, bobman0330, Bremen, cakewalk, crackedquads, derwipok, Gadarene, XXsooted, jjhender, kruze, Loretta8, monikrazy, Palo, rdgb, UAW710, Telcontar, TheNothing, Thiradell, VarianceMinefield, vyk07, wisski, younguns87
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Silman
Trust that I have a reason. Remember this post and ask me in a few days.
Okay.

I'd like to take a shot at Variance during the next ITAs. General reaction?
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Silman
A good, Loretta:
thoughts on xxsooted and Palo?
i cant remember a post by either, will reread

gad, don't shoot VM
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene
Okay.

I'd like to take a shot at Variance during the next ITAs. General reaction?
I'm not actually too opposed to this. I'd really like him to come back to the thread and talk first though.
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:05 PM
Feel free to tunnel on me, cakewalk. I'm not getting into it anymore.
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:06 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene
Okay.

I'd like to take a shot at Variance during the next ITAs. General reaction?
I will prolly beat you to it
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:06 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Swiitch
sure, you picked OMW ahead of any of the others, never voted any of the others or anything like that, you just took a random shot because digger is god.
yep, except not random bc digger said he was a wolf. in fact, it was possibly more educated than most.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Silman
Loretta8
Palo
xxsooted

these 3 players will be the focus of my attention today.
I wouldnt want to lynch any of these.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Swiitch
He took a 'hero' shot during the ITAs and he never advocates them as a villager, iirc.

Plus, look at his posting so far, you think he's more likely to be a villager or a wolf?
its not a hero shot. dead villa thought he was a wolf. dead villa read more than me. the people that wanted me to follow their consensus had me as a viable target. ergo, their reads are no good.
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CalledDownLight
its not a hero shot. dead villa thought he was a wolf. dead villa read more than me. the people that wanted me to follow their consensus had me as a viable target. ergo, their reads are no good.
Who had you as a viable target, prior to your hero shot?

Also, why not one of the other 3 that digger mentioned?
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CalledDownLight
its not a hero shot. dead villa thought he was a wolf. dead villa read more than me. the people that wanted me to follow their consensus had me as a viable target. ergo, their reads are no good.
I also love this line of thinking.

When was the last game you played as a villager where you had perfect reads?

Just because someone has a read that is incorrect, doesn't mean you discount all of their reads.
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Silman
A good, Loretta:
thoughts on xxsooted and Palo?
xxsooted seems to be doing his standard villa thing, can't fathom why people think he's wolfing

also, for camel toe in his entrance post
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:11 PM
at least a few more people are voting now even if the votes on me suck
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CalledDownLight
I wouldnt want to lynch any of these.
Why not, o wise one?

You already admitted to not reading all that much, why do you not want to lynch any of those three?
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Swiitch
He took a 'hero' shot during the ITAs and he never advocates them as a villager, iirc.

Plus, look at his posting so far, you think he's more likely to be a villager or a wolf?
i just read all of his posts in the past few pages, nothing he said really strikes me as wolfy. idk why his 'hero' shot would be conceived as a wolfy line. IMO if he's guilty of anything it's following the reads of an extremely strong player (RIP digger). this itself isn't grounds for a wagon.
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:13 PM
Can I put CDL on ignore yet?
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Swiitch
Who had you as a viable target, prior to your hero shot?

Also, why not one of the other 3 that digger mentioned?
was definitely in a list or two. let me look.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Swiitch
I also love this line of thinking.

When was the last game you played as a villager where you had perfect reads?

Just because someone has a read that is incorrect, doesn't mean you discount all of their reads.
this one I have perfect reads. I dont have any so none of them are wrong. I thought silman and gabe were prob villas but not sure anymore.
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Silman
A good, Loretta:
thoughts on xxsooted and Palo?
Palo on the other hand has contributed absolutely nothing except for a bizarre miller claim and doesn't really seem interested in finding wolves

he could definitely be a wolf
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:13 PM
Swiitch, it seems to me you are the only one pushing CDL, and you are pushing very hard. can you share with us why you feel so? other than his posts seem wolfy
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Swiitch
Why not, o wise one?

You already admitted to not reading all that much, why do you not want to lynch any of those three?
I like them all and they are above average players so absent compelling information there are more preferable lynches to me.
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by FCBLComish
I will be around for about 40 minutes, and then gone for the day. I will miss the ITA period.

3 targets:

Supine
Bremen
CDL

Tournament is going well so far, read the bridge thread for my bad beat story.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Supine
I need to leave and will miss first ITA. Will post more later if I am still alive.

top3:

VM, and Gadvoters:



Bremen
CDL
here are 2 people putting me in top 3 in attack lists. I aint scared of attacks tho.
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:17 PM
Care to revisit your reasoning for your vote on me, CDL? I responded to you last page or so, but you appear to have ignored it.
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by cakewalk
i just read all of his posts in the past few pages, nothing he said really strikes me as wolfy. idk why his 'hero' shot would be conceived as a wolfy line. IMO if he's guilty of anything it's following the reads of an extremely strong player (RIP digger). this itself isn't grounds for a wagon.
yes, it is when he never mentioned any of the other 3 players that digger said were wolfs. CDL is also adamantly against people taking random shots in games with ITAs, he and I have had issues with this before, and when he's a villager he's always been adamant about not taking hero shots, so why can he break his own rule?

why did he specifically hit OMW and not one of the other 3, why is his vote on Gadarene, who wasn't mentioned by digger?

If he's going to sponge a dead player to take his shot with, then sponge him all the way.
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote
10-28-2011 , 01:19 PM
To be clear: thinking that I am a wolf because chris flipped miller is absolutely ludicrous and totally beneath you.
10/27 Shadows of Amn Mishmash Game Thread Quote

      
m