Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior

03-18-2008 , 11:18 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kyleb
His "perfect mechanics" are anything but. Yes, the mechanics are responsible for his injuries.



The same people who are telling you he has perfect mechanics are the same people who are in charge of front offices, scouting departments, and minor league pitching coaches.

The people telling you that Prior's mechanics are messed up are:

-Mike Marshall: A former Cy Young who is an outcast in baseball circles because he invented his own arm/body action and firmly insists it is the only correct way to throw a baseball from a mound. While not a diplomat, much of what he teaches is quite accurate and baseball is slowly coming around to many of his ideas, especially pronating the release of all pitches (Roger Clemens is a perfect example of this).

-Chris O'Leary: Never played baseball past 9th grade.

-Kyle Boddy: Some idiot on a message board.
-tdarko: Another idiot cosigning every bit of this

In other words, it's a bunch of outsiders looking in. People talk about Moneyball and how the stat nerds were excluded from the front offices; this is no longer true. Observational analysts who have a different take on mechanics are the new "stat nerds."
Added a lil' somethin'.
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-18-2008 , 11:25 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kyleb
I'm sure there are teams who incorporate Marshall's mechanics. However, like performance analysts at first, they do it quietly - being an outsider in baseball is a death knell for many reasons. Hell, you can read Ball Four and Jim Bouton's story to show this is true - Marshall was derided as being a weird guy even in the 1970's!

Pitchers almost never "fix" their mechanics. Muscle memory is a strong thing; these pitchers have arm actions that are nearly impossible to change after 20 years of throwing a baseball like they do. Changing their mechanics will lead to ineffective pitching, which means less time on the mound, which means less pay in their pockets and probably release from a team. The only people that change their mechanics are people that are coming off major injury (UCL replacement, shoulder surgery), and even then we don't see it very often. However, one shining example exists: Roger Clemens pre-injury is way, way different than Roger Clemens post-injury.
This is very true and as I was reading I was going to cite Clemens as one of the only examples that popped into my head right off the bat.

The optimal age range for learning, whether it is spanish or simply motor skills is 9-13 and this has been proven in the area of motor behavior. For instance, if you give a kid a bat at the age of 6 and start throwing him balls, that skill would not be age appropriate--this is why t-ball or coach pitch is a mess...also if you were to work with that same kid, those skills would dissipate as soon as they entered, they simply do not have control of their body yet. Same goes for a major league pitcher that has been doing the same motion for 20 years, it is like trying to knock down a brick wall. This isn't to say it can't be done, it just means that it is very hard.
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-18-2008 , 01:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kyleb
BTW, when I say Prior's arm is late in showing up to the party, this is exactly what pitchers should look like at footstrike:

I know you said you were going to ignore Pedro's motion. But isn't Pedro's arm in the same position as Prior's at footstrike?
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-18-2008 , 01:46 PM
i was under the impression he posted Pedro simply to show Pedro because Pedro is the awesomest.
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-18-2008 , 01:54 PM
kyleb/tdarko,

you've pretty much indicted the Cubs coaches for Mark Prior's mechanical and workload problems. is there another example that they've made egregious errors with pitcher development? such as Kerry Wood? what's going to happen to Jeff Samardzija? in college his mechanics were not anything to write home about, and he missed significant time due to injuries, though they could also be football related.
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-18-2008 , 09:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by gusmahler
I know you said you were going to ignore Pedro's motion. But isn't Pedro's arm in the same position as Prior's at footstrike?
Sort of. Pedro points his shoulder to the target after throwing much better, indicating that although he throws from a low 3/4 delivery, he is taking the ball in a straight line to the target as best he can. Prior does not.

I'd have to do a better analysis to give you the right opinion, but I'm sure there are some injurious flaws in his delivery.

Quote:
Originally Posted by sylar
kyleb/tdarko,

you've pretty much indicted the Cubs coaches for Mark Prior's mechanical and workload problems. is there another example that they've made egregious errors with pitcher development? such as Kerry Wood? what's going to happen to Jeff Samardzija? in college his mechanics were not anything to write home about, and he missed significant time due to injuries, though they could also be football related.
I want it to be clear that it's not just the Cubs in this particular instance - many teams overwork their pitchers and fail to understand proper pitching mechanics as they relate to injury. How do you fix someone that has never failed? Mark Prior broke the mold of amateur pitchers - he was so insanely dominant in NCAA baseball that no coach could have told him anything. He appeared in the MLB and was well above-average the same year he was drafted. When you are that big of a talent, why would you listen to anyone who doubted your ability?

Kerry Wood also has terrible mechanics. Not sure on Samardzija, but that was a terrible draft pick by the Cubs anyway.
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-18-2008 , 11:22 PM
Sylar,

You would be surprised at how many pitching coaches within each organization have very little understanding of pitching mechanics. A lot of these coaches were incredibly talented pitchers and big leaguers and they could simply do it but they haven't the slightest idea why or how. They don't understand the kinetic chain and they don't understand a lot of the concepts needed to get a pitcher developed. Much of what they do is what they see around them--this is where towel drills come into play and many other detrimental drills etc.

All of them have an incredible amount of game knowledge and have an incredible amount of in-game stuff to provide to upcoming players. The best are the ones that understand mechanics and have the experience to pass on the in-game knowledge.
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-19-2008 , 12:35 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kyleb
Oswalt's mechanics are near-perfect, IMO. His stats are obviously very good.
He's hurt every year at some point. Not major injuries though.
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-19-2008 , 12:40 AM
interesting that tom house studies this kind of stuff and basically signed off on Prior's mechanics. Does he just suck at life? Also, if you could do this with Wood that would be awesome.

One other question - does Maddux throw more over the top than basically everyone?

One more - How much does Prior landing on his heel hurt him? Is that just a byproduct of bad mechanics or is it something he could control seperately from his other bad mechanics. I know this was something Marshall said was really bad for guys like Wood and Prior.

Last edited by Your Mom; 03-19-2008 at 12:43 AM. Reason: more questions...I'm full of them.
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-19-2008 , 02:03 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Your Mom
He's hurt every year at some point. Not major injuries though.
Oswalt has chronic oblique strains. That's not really something mechanics can fix; it's a genetic predisposition. Besides, it's not a "bad" injury, since it proves that he is recruiting power from his whole body, including his core.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Your Mom
interesting that tom house studies this kind of stuff and basically signed off on Prior's mechanics. Does he just suck at life? Also, if you could do this with Wood that would be awesome.

One other question - does Maddux throw more over the top than basically everyone?

One more - How much does Prior landing on his heel hurt him? Is that just a byproduct of bad mechanics or is it something he could control seperately from his other bad mechanics. I know this was something Marshall said was really bad for guys like Wood and Prior.
I don't necessarily agree with Tom House on everything. The idiotic towel drill is one of those things. He also insists that changing a pitcher's arm action is bad and that we should just look to refine their timing. That's not necessarily wrong, and it will make the pitcher more efficient, but it really doesn't fix the root cause of the problem a lot of the time, unless you equate timing with "arm up at footstrike," which he doesn't.

Throwing against a firm glove side and building a more natural tempo downhill are two things that are excellent pointers, however.

I can do something for Kerry Wood fairly easily, since Chris O'Leary basically dissected his motion already. Wood features poor timing at footstrike as well.

Prior landing sharply on his glove-side heel is not necessarily bad. The common wisdom of landing on the ball of your foot or landing flat has been proven to be irrelevant. I'm pretty sure Marshall doesn't care about this; he doesn't list it in his "flaws" of the traditional motion available here.
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-19-2008 , 05:24 AM
For those of you who have HBO On Demand, check out the latest Real Sports episode. It has a part about Mike Marshall that's fairly interesting to watch.
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-19-2008 , 07:16 AM
This rules.
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-19-2008 , 10:48 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kyleb
I can do something for Kerry Wood fairly easily, since Chris O'Leary basically dissected his motion already. Wood features poor timing at footstrike as well.
can you provide a link to this?
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-19-2008 , 10:51 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by tdarko
Sylar,

You would be surprised at how many pitching coaches within each organization have very little understanding of pitching mechanics. A lot of these coaches were incredibly talented pitchers and big leaguers and they could simply do it but they haven't the slightest idea why or how. They don't understand the kinetic chain and they don't understand a lot of the concepts needed to get a pitcher developed. Much of what they do is what they see around them--this is where towel drills come into play and many other detrimental drills etc.

All of them have an incredible amount of game knowledge and have an incredible amount of in-game stuff to provide to upcoming players. The best are the ones that understand mechanics and have the experience to pass on the in-game knowledge.
wow, this is quite interesting. i've heard a lot about bad pitching coaches at MLB level who just happened to get a job, but i thought career minor league coaches had to have a track record that proves they don't ruin arms with their instruction.

i guess i am really pretty naive about the coaching situation, never having witnessed downright abuse of a kid's arm.
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-19-2008 , 12:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kyleb
I can do something for Kerry Wood fairly easily, since Chris O'Leary basically dissected his motion already. Wood features poor timing at footstrike as well.
Quote:
Originally Posted by sylar
can you provide a link to this?

Chris O'Leary's website: http://www.chrisoleary.com/projects/Baseball/index.html

The analysis page on the website, including the Wood analysis:
http://www.chrisoleary.com/projects/...ses/index.html
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-19-2008 , 12:42 PM
"Not sure on Samardzija, but that was a terrible draft pick by the Cubs anyway."

According to Hendry, he was #1 on their draft board out of everyone that year. Hmmmmm. That is somewhat alarming. I'm interested to hear your opinion on why it was a terrible pick. I understand that they overpaid, but I hadn't really considered his other deficiencies.
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-19-2008 , 04:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TonyDanza
"Not sure on Samardzija, but that was a terrible draft pick by the Cubs anyway."

According to Hendry, he was #1 on their draft board out of everyone that year. Hmmmmm. That is somewhat alarming. I'm interested to hear your opinion on why it was a terrible pick. I understand that they overpaid, but I hadn't really considered his other deficiencies.
i'd like to know the answer to this also.

btw, to anyone interested here are some pitching clips of jeff. no idea why he gets compared to daniel bard and roger clemens with the sox.

http://www.pitchingclips.com/players...samardzija.htm
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-19-2008 , 04:39 PM
Samardzija has awful mechanics and isn't a pitcher. He is a thrower. And that's fine if you're 18 years old, but Samardzjia is 22.
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-19-2008 , 04:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kyleb
Samardzija has awful mechanics and isn't a pitcher. He is a thrower. And that's fine if you're 18 years old, but Samardzjia is 22.
ok, you are going to need to explain it to the rest of us. what is mechanically different between throwing and pitching?
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-19-2008 , 08:46 PM
kyle,

great work as always...I for one will read any and all of these that you do.

Are there any young pitchers who you would point to as having "very good" mechanics? I guess I would love to see a Will Carrolesque rating system of every pitcher in the bigs and their injury risk based on mechanics, but that is probably a tall order for you

James
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-19-2008 , 11:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by sylar
ok, you are going to need to explain it to the rest of us. what is mechanically different between throwing and pitching?
Not much. However, Samardzija has no secondary pitch, and his fastball doesn't have a lot of movement. Just because he can throw 97 MPH doesn't make it good.
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-20-2008 , 12:13 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by James282
kyle,

great work as always...I for one will read any and all of these that you do.

Are there any young pitchers who you would point to as having "very good" mechanics? I guess I would love to see a Will Carrolesque rating system of every pitcher in the bigs and their injury risk based on mechanics, but that is probably a tall order for you

James
Thanks for the comments.

As for young pitchers whose mechanics are good, I like James Shields a lot. I wrote a piece on him that I submitted to The Hardball Times. Carlos Gomez stopped writing Bullpen Mechanics, and with any luck, I'll be taking over the column. Hopefully Gassko and company likes the article I wrote!
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-20-2008 , 12:32 AM
Great stuff as usual.. as an A's fan I have to wonder if Rich Harden's health issues are a result of poor mechanics..
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-20-2008 , 12:36 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kyleb
Samardzija has awful mechanics and isn't a pitcher. He is a thrower. And that's fine if you're 18 years old, but Samardzjia is 22.
I think one of the reasons the Cubs were high on him when they drafted him was because of his work ethic and they thought they would be able to work with him. From what you and Tdarko have said, it seems unlikely they will be able to make any major changes based on his age. I tend to agree. He seems quite raw for a 23 year-old college drafted pitcher. I initially thought that might be based on inexperience, but he pitched a ****load in college. Also, not that impressed with his college numbers, especially playing in the Big East. He also didn't pitch that well in the Florida State League, which is definitely a pitcher's league.

BTW - appreciate these threads Kyle. Keep doing them. I still have a lot of misconceptions about mechanics based on things I was taught while I was playing.
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote
03-20-2008 , 07:14 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by sweetwater
Great stuff as usual.. as an A's fan I have to wonder if Rich Harden's health issues are a result of poor mechanics..
It's possible. I'd have to look more, but I know Carlos Gomez wrote something on HBT about it as well. It bums me out too, since I'm an A's fan.

Quote:
Originally Posted by TonyDanza
I think one of the reasons the Cubs were high on him when they drafted him was because of his work ethic and they thought they would be able to work with him. From what you and Tdarko have said, it seems unlikely they will be able to make any major changes based on his age. I tend to agree. He seems quite raw for a 23 year-old college drafted pitcher. I initially thought that might be based on inexperience, but he pitched a ****load in college. Also, not that impressed with his college numbers, especially playing in the Big East. He also didn't pitch that well in the Florida State League, which is definitely a pitcher's league.

BTW - appreciate these threads Kyle. Keep doing them. I still have a lot of misconceptions about mechanics based on things I was taught while I was playing.
His college numbers are not impressive, his stuff is really not that great, and while his work ethic is purportedly good, he's old for his level and still didn't pitch well. It's not the wasted draft pick that matters (because who cares about a fourth-rounder, really), but the money spent on him.

Thanks again for the comments. Hopefully we'll see less posts here and more of my stuff on HBT.
Pitching mechanics: Mark Prior Quote

      
m