Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread

01-09-2024 , 06:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ScotchOnDaRocks
Send Texas back to not being back

That game might have been scheduled eight years ago or something like that before all of realignment

I get the sentiment that with realignment the OOC doesn’t matter that much anymore. But there’s not really a good reason to cancel the game

Just funny how people cried all year that Michigan wasn’t playing anyone. Then when they do play someone people ask why

You shouldn't have to play anyone in OOC when you play in the B1G East division and then also have to play an extra game in the B1G title game.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-09-2024 , 07:48 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NotReddBoiler
You shouldn't have to play anyone in OOC when you play in the B1G East division and then also have to play an extra game in the B1G title game.
Michigan's schedule next year is probably the toughest schedule of all time. Not only is scheduling Texas beyond stupid, even putting Fresno State on there--a team that clearly has a heart beat and can beat you if you play your B minus game--is inexcusable. Somebody should be fired. Seriously.

If JJ doesn't come back all the Michigan haters are gonna have a lovely time next year. 7-5/8-4 is the most realistic projection. If JJ does come back there's still no way michigan is running the table vs that gauntlet. 9-3/10-2 is the most likely endpoint. And if there's ever a time to let a 9-3 team in the playoffs it should be michigan next year.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-09-2024 , 07:56 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NotReddBoiler
You shouldn't have to play anyone in OOC when you play in the B1G East division and then also have to play an extra game in the B1G title game.
I agree which is why during the course of the season I gave various peeps the back of my hand when they cried about the schedule

Michigan gave themselves no room for error, but they were flawless and earned it
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-09-2024 , 07:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ILOVEPOKER929
Michigan's schedule next year is probably the toughest schedule of all time. Not only is scheduling Texas beyond stupid, even putting Fresno State on there--a team that clearly has a heart beat and can beat you if you play your B minus game--is inexcusable. Somebody should be fired. Seriously.

If JJ doesn't come back all the Michigan haters are gonna have a lovely time next year. 7-5/8-4 is the most realistic projection. If JJ does come back there's still no way michigan is running the table vs that gauntlet. 9-3/10-2 is the most likely endpoint. And if there's ever a time to let a 9-3 team in the playoffs it should be michigan next year.
Calm down, you just won it all…and definitely some teams in P2 will end up with 2 or 3 losses and in playoffs
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-09-2024 , 08:37 PM
not recognizing the equity in quality losses
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-09-2024 , 08:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ILOVEPOKER929
Michigan's schedule next year is probably the toughest schedule of all time. Not only is scheduling Texas beyond stupid, even putting Fresno State on there--a team that clearly has a heart beat and can beat you if you play your B minus game--is inexcusable. Somebody should be fired. Seriously.

If JJ doesn't come back all the Michigan haters are gonna have a lovely time next year. 7-5/8-4 is the most realistic projection. If JJ does come back there's still no way michigan is running the table vs that gauntlet. 9-3/10-2 is the most likely endpoint. And if there's ever a time to let a 9-3 team in the playoffs it should be michigan next year.
It isn't the hardest schedule of all time, but it is LDO much, much more difficult than this year. Penn State no longer being an every year thing helps. So does Oregon, Washington, USC and Ohio State all losing their quarterbacks. They'll reload, but it'll be a step down.

Even if JJ doesn't come back -- and my worthless opinion is that he should for several reasons -- I don't think 4 or 5 losses is the most realistic projection. Barring massive portal departures, there is going to be an old, moderately experienced OL that's been in the same system for years now, good RB options, decent WRs and, more importantly, a lot of production on defense. I'd put 9-3 at the middle of the bell curve. If JJ comes back, add a win. Of course that's today, who knows what it'll look like come Labor Day.

The wild card (again an LDO) is whether Harbaugh leaves.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-09-2024 , 08:56 PM
some of UM fans don't think Harbs is gone?
remember that time in high school a bro let you know your girl was cheating?
hurt like a kick in the dick when you heard it but started the healing
this is like that
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-09-2024 , 09:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by REDeYeS00
some of UM fans don't think Harbs is gone?
remember that time in high school a bro let you know your girl was cheating?
hurt like a kick in the dick when you heard it but started the healing
this is like that
I'd say it's 80/20 he's gone. But it's definitely not 100%.

They're going to offer him a boatload of money to stay. This isn't going to be one of those deals where a guy goes to the league to triple his income. He knows he's in a good place with the program he's built - the cupboard is going to be well stocked and another run is possible if JJ and some other guys come back. Family stuff could keep him in Ann Arbor.

If he leaves, it's because (a) he's Harbaugh, competition is in his DNA, he can check off national championship, time to get that Superb Owl win, (b) he's sick of the NCAA bullshit, (c) he thinks the NFL lifestyle is better, or some combination of those.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-09-2024 , 10:11 PM
jim will never be better than his older brother until he wins a super bowl
simple as that
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-09-2024 , 10:32 PM
Harbaugh has to get out of town.

He already served two separate suspensions this year. What is next year going to look like when it all comes out?

The only way he preserves his legacy as a Michigan hero is to get the hell out now.

And red eyes is correct. Until he bags a Super Bowl, he’ll always be little jimmy.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-09-2024 , 11:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by pokeraz
The only way he preserves his legacy as a Michigan hero is to get the hell out now.
Nah, further NCAA witchhunting will only cement his standing with the base.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-09-2024 , 11:34 PM
tick marks recorded on the pantry door of mother harbs measure season win totals
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-09-2024 , 11:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by electricladylnd
Aren’t you the one that sht on Michigan all year? Their defense wasn’t that good and they would lose 3-4 games in the Sec this year?
What does that have to do with Michigan posters saying drivel like the SEC is a fraud because they finally didn't win the title, Georgia is a "loser team," etc? Just lol.

FYI, I'm the one who picked Michigan to beat Bama (almost the perfect score), then to gut Washington, and stand as the legit champion. I detailed the Michigan rise like no one else on here. You already know this but your ego is butt hurt over that reality so you need to misrepresent. And I'll stand by if the opposition was LSU, Georgia, Florida, Bama, Tennessee, Mizzou, Auburn, A&M, Ole Miss ... they don't go anywhere near undefeated in conference.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-10-2024 , 12:12 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ILOVEPOKER929
After winning THIS game Harbaugh is officially and unequivocally the greatest coach in Michigan history. And JJ is the greatest QB in Michigan history.
I agree with that. He's more title prominent than Bo ever was, unfortunately (loved the guy), even though Harbaugh has a way's to go to catch Bo in several respects. I agree Harbaugh GOAT Meechigan Man coach.

A little known fact about Bo, to give him his full due. As AD, he fired Bill Frieder in his famed "I'm leaving after the tournament" signing ... then he, Schembechler, coached the perennially underachieving men's hoops team to the title, with Fisher of course titularly at the helm. In his autobiography, Bo recounted his visits to the practices and locker room, and said something along the lines that the Frieder soft prima donnas nearly shyt their pants when they got a load of Bo. They responded with the title. I love that story. I played college ball. I know The Man when I see it and when I don't, just like those dudes in the Michigan locker room did. So Bo got his title, in my book.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-10-2024 , 12:35 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by StoppedRainingMen
Michigan deserves this, Michigan fans deserve this, Harbaugh does not deserve this
Quote:
Originally Posted by FellaGaga-52
Hard disagree. He's obviously a god at building programs ... San Diego, Stanford, Michigan ... and also had great success in the pros. He's on the shortlist of excelling at both. Walsh, Jimmy Johnson, Carroll, Harbaugh ... who else, I'm sure a few more?? The spectacular flame outs attempting both are legion.

As to bending rules, something just short of 100% of them do that. I don't get it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ILOVEPOKER929
After winning THIS game Harbaugh is officially and unequivocally the greatest coach in Michigan history. And JJ is the greatest QB in Michigan history.
Just going to throw out that there may be some recency bias here. With minimal research going off my memory of them ready to let him walk.

He was hired in 2015 and from 2015-2020, he was 6-12 vs OH St., Mich St., and Penn St. Including going 0-5 vs OH St. and 0-9 vs top 15 teams on the road. Michigan was ready to let him walk, but said if you want to stay we'll cut your salary in half. From like 8 million to 4 million. He swallowed his pride and stayed. Good on him. Since then he's like 33-3 with a national championship.

I don't see him sticking around. He got his Alma Mater a natty. Next logical step is to take the Bears job, have his pick of who he wants at QB, and bring a Superb Owl to the franchise he couldn't when he was their QB. Now that would be an accomplishment and upstage his brother.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-10-2024 , 01:13 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by FellaGaga-52
What does that have to do with Michigan posters saying drivel like the SEC is a fraud because they finally didn't win the title, Georgia is a "loser team," etc? Just lol.

FYI, I'm the one who picked Michigan to beat Bama (almost the perfect score), then to gut Washington, and stand as the legit champion. I detailed the Michigan rise like no one else on here. You already know this but your ego is butt hurt over that reality so you need to misrepresent. And I'll stand by if the opposition was LSU, Georgia, Florida, Bama, Tennessee, Mizzou, Auburn, A&M, Ole Miss ... they don't go anywhere near undefeated in conference.
They don’t go anywhere undefeated but beats the team that was able to go undefeated… I know you picked them over Bama and Washington but you talked **** about them all year too. It’s similar nonsense like saying the sec is a fraud.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-10-2024 , 03:50 AM
Season's end conclusions:

PAC12 still sucks. Should be banned from the playoffs.

Michigan clearly the second best team in the country.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-10-2024 , 04:00 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by REDeYeS00
some of UM fans don't think Harbs is gone?
remember that time in high school a bro let you know your girl was cheating?
hurt like a kick in the dick when you heard it but started the healing
this is like that
I wouldn't be confident one way or the other. Harbaugh is not a normal human being. Trying to project what this guy's gonna do using normal logic doesn't work.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-10-2024 , 04:48 AM
sigh. Nice hand ILP.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Steve00007
So what happens if Michigan gets stripped of the title? Does that mean I wasted my time with this game? Am I supposed to pretend this game didn’t happen?
I believe in "vacated wins" as much as a 'transgender man.' I won't even make an exception for Michigan.

Quote:
Originally Posted by KING GREEAR
Checking in on this forum once or twice a year is usually a depressing experience. All the great posters who have moved on, this place looks like a ghost town compared to its prime. But I guess thatÂ’s life.

Cheers to all the Michigan fans, and especially to all the Michigan haters. What a ride.

Also, unban GREEAR10. HeÂ’s served many years of imprisonment. He might be the only thing that can save this place from becoming a fossil on the internet.
Welcome home. and +1.
Quote:
Originally Posted by GoldenBears
I think this playoffs was actually a great example of this, as this year was closer to a 12 team playoff than a 4 teamer.

Taking UM out of it, Georgia and Oregon were the two best teams, and both of them got knocked out in the de-facto quarterfinals. The chaos will compound.

Take the second tier of teams like Missouri or Kansas State or Arizona or whatever - the 10-15 "really good but not great" teams. In the 4 team playoff system their odds are basically zero since the ceiling is either 10-2 team that finishes like #10 or an 11-1 team that doesn't garner enough respect and finishes like #5-#7, and so they don't get in. Now, at least a couple of those teams will get in every year, so their odds are not zero.

And, even when such a team did catch lightning in a bottle (Michigan State, Cincinnati) they had to face Georgia and death star Bama and they got smoked. Sometimes that will still happen in the 12 team system , but sometimes they will continue to run hot and other underdogs will clear the way for them.

Like K-State might make it and face a gauntlet of Texas, Oregon Georgia and the sportswriters are like "they just don't have enough talent to win those 3 games in a row" but once in a while, they upset Texas, then get to face Washington instead of Oregon and then Bama knocks out Georgia who gets knocked out by Michigan and boom, they have tangible equity.

Not to mention all the times over the past decade where the #5-6 team that barely missed the cut (TCU, Stanford, Ok State, Boise State) might genuinely just have been the best team in the country that year


Next year is going to be sick. My only complaint is that the last minute conference realignment has really given us a dearth of big OOC games, and the schedules are crazy unbalanced. Like, Iowa going 10-2 will probably be less impressive than if Florida somehow manages to go 8-4. And, I really, really wish we could break up the K-State/Arizona and Utah/Baylor games and get some B1G/SEC opponents for the Big-12
I can't see it. Teams like BYU and ASU won or shared a title pre-playoff, which includes the two team playoff. Once that happened no one won it that surprised you with their helmet. I think the past two years showed what happens when small offensive linemen have to get beat up by bigger players, and then come back and do it again next week.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-10-2024 , 05:41 AM
More than anything, the playoffs show that online/dline runs college football. When is the last time the best QB in the four team playoff won the thing?
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-10-2024 , 06:00 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by electricladylnd
They don’t go anywhere undefeated but beats the team that was able to go undefeated… I know you picked them over Bama and Washington but you talked **** about them all year too. It’s similar nonsense like saying the sec is a fraud.
I talked no shyt about them. I told you their exact history and exactly who they are now. And I guess you can't handle the truth of that. In fact, I heartily respected their journey from OSU whipping boy, to Big 10 bully surpassing OSU but still fodder for the top dogs, to now a serious contender for the title. That's exactly what I did.

Last edited by FellaGaga-52; 01-10-2024 at 06:09 AM.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-10-2024 , 06:08 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CowboyCold
Just going to throw out that there may be some recency bias here. With minimal research going off my memory of them ready to let him walk.

He was hired in 2015 and from 2015-2020, he was 6-12 vs OH St., Mich St., and Penn St. Including going 0-5 vs OH St. and 0-9 vs top 15 teams on the road. Michigan was ready to let him walk, but said if you want to stay we'll cut your salary in half. From like 8 million to 4 million. He swallowed his pride and stayed. Good on him. Since then he's like 33-3 with a national championship.

I don't see him sticking around. He got his Alma Mater a natty. Next logical step is to take the Bears job, have his pick of who he wants at QB, and bring a Superb Owl to the franchise he couldn't when he was their QB. Now that would be an accomplishment and upstage his brother.
It's recency bias what he did with the Michigan program, the San Diego program, the Stanford program, and the 49ers?? Nice try. That's a fail.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-10-2024 , 06:19 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ILOVEPOKER929
I wouldn't be confident one way or the other. Harbaugh is not a normal human being. Trying to project what this guy's gonna do using normal logic doesn't work.
He is indeed a very odd duck. It's very hard to get a handle on him personality-wise. He's definitely hyper competitive but yet it doesn't come across in the same way that it does of so many others of that ilk. There's some kind of factor with him akin to the way Belichick presents himself, everything is camouflaged. Perhaps we are going to learn from posts on here that he actually isn't great at building programs -- we seem to be getting hints in that direction, lol -- but I'm gonna go with the record. You do what he did in four places ... it's Rick Pitino. And that's not recency bias, it's the career record.

Last edited by FellaGaga-52; 01-10-2024 at 06:31 AM.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-10-2024 , 12:37 PM
The Finebaum tears is an underrated aspect of Michigan’s natty.

https://www.freep.com/story/sports/c...n/72162887007/
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote
01-10-2024 , 06:14 PM
Saban retiring. Whoa.
NCAA Football 2023 Season Megathread Quote

      
m