Quote:
Originally Posted by Polarbear1955
So if it is kind of bogus they do not get to play in the CFP who do you have them replace? Either of the two undefeated CCs? The SEC champ with the same record that just beat them? Or a power 5 champ with the same record that beat the team that beat them?
Who do you think the best 4 teams are? So that means drop all the bullshyt and write down the name of the best 4 and most qualified teams. Qualified means, generally and nearly strictly, teams who are undefeated or have 1 loss. From there, all the candidates are on an even footing, whether with one loss or none ... and the body of work and current status of the team rules.
12-1 in some spots is much better than 13-0 in others, obviously. There is a reason why all the CFP teams are about 2/1 to win it except Washington, who is 7/1. What's up with that? If Georgia played Washington, what would the line be? And if Georgia was in they would also be about 2/1, not 7/1.
A team can generally eliminate themselves by losing twice, but not by losing once, and certainly not by losing once to a playoff team. Georgia and Bama are in the same boat there as the two most deserving teams. Michigan had ten byes to go 10-0 and here they are again. Washington beat everybody and their sister by one score or slightly more. They're Cinderella. If they line up against Georgia, it's about half of the TCU fiasco last year. Every position is a mismatch. 12-1 > 13-0 many, many times.
The qualified candidates based on all factors are Michigan, Bama, FSU, Washington, Texas, Georgia. The most distinguished of those are Michigan, Texas, Bama, and Georgia. You have to drop the "But they're undefeated" argument in the hierarchy several notches.
Georgia out here is about like UCLA out in the '74 NCAA Tournament because USC or somebody beat them in the conference championship game. So I say it's bogus, a bummer for the spectacle of it, where an obviously qualified team is eliminated by some lesser qualifier.