Quote:
Originally Posted by BiiiiigChips
I don't think it would be any tougher either way you go. I don't think Jordan would have any tougher time now and I don't think Kobe and Lebron would have any easier of a time then. When you are talking about players as great as those 3 they'll dominate any era. Skill wise Kobe and Jordan are pretty much a toss up if you ask me. So as far as basketball playing ability alone to me it's a pick 'em. When talking about greatest ever though, career acomplishments and resume is ussually what people are talking about and in that regard Kobe still has a ways to catch Mike. Lebron physically is a different player then MJ and Kobe that's why I like to keep the comparisons to just MJ and Kobe. As far as Lebron's career accomplishments again, he has a long way to catch MJ but he's off to a good start. Just look over Jordan's career and what he accomplished. It's mind boggling. LBJ and Kobe are great but they are going to have to achieve an awful lot in the remainder of their careers to match MJs.
I still don't see where the depth argument is even relavent though. Jordan is an elite player so you should be comparing the elite players of the time not if the 2nd or 3rd guy off the bench on average is better then or now because it doesn't matter. Neither one could hold a torch to an elite player (which is they type of player we are discussing) so why does it matter? What matters is the top 2 or 3 players on each team.
Jordan would def have a tougher time now, defenses are more complex, players are better/more athletic etc. Obv Jordan would still dominate, and imo would still be the best player in the game, but it wouldn't be hands down automatic like people think.
I realize what Jordan accomplished (I grew up during the Jordan era and watched a ton of Jordan) and Kobe/Lebron will have a tougher time accomplishing what he did, because the league is better now than it was back in the 90's, and there supporting cast will very likley never be as good as Jordan's supporting cast was.
Notice during the 80's Jordan didn't win anything, the league was tougher during the 80's as well than during the 90's. Yes his team sucked, but so does Lebron's, and Lebron accomplished more in his career than Jordan has up to this age. Lebron is also a better player at his age right now than Jordan was imo.
Obv a lot has yet to be decided, that's why I specifically said when there
careers are over, Kobe/Lebron will
probably both be able to make cases that they were as good, if not better than Jordan (especially Lebron).