I have a similar story about a "bad idea" project that wasn't so bad.
I was hanging out at a grad student retreat for my department with Rebecca Sloot in like 2000. She was the girlfriend of a friend, another grad student (she was also a grad student but in another department). The group was having a beer shindig and Rebecca and I were having a smoke on the patio of a cabin where we were staying. She said she was working on a book about a woman whose cancer cells became the subject of much biological research, Henrietta Lacks. I said something mildly encouraging, but thought, "Ya, that's not gonna do any business."
Well, it took her a long time to write and was released a decade later [nothing like being a nobody with a 10-year project hanging over your head], but it won a bunch of awards, was a NY Times #1 bestseller, was the most assigned book for incoming college students, and was made into a movie starring Oprah.
https://www.amazon.com/Immortal-Life.../dp/1400052181
So I guess my "radar" regarding its potential success was a bit off.
(She married my friend, now a philosophy professor, and they had two kids but later divorced.)
Last edited by simplicitus; 11-19-2017 at 07:18 PM.