Quote:
Originally Posted by einbert
Is Trump really in charge of anything or is Fox News really the true leader of the Republican Party?
It seems like this is actually a rather pedestrian and classic political coalition: you have a huge mass of older whites (not a majority for sure, but there's alot of them) and a much smaller number of mega wealthy who are also mostly older and white. That is the alliance on the ground, so to speak. Then you have a propaganda organ, or really an ecosystem of them (AM radio, FNC, etc). that maintains message and discipline and coordination. And you have political leadership. It's a traditional political model.
The older white people are, in the end, the numerical force behind all of this in the context of democracy (ignore for a moment how vibrant our democracy is). I will reiterate I am not saying they are a majority of Americans but I also wouldn't deny that there aren't tens of millions of them at least and they have a lot of purchasing power and social power and atomized authority (in the careers, communities, churches, etc).
And they are the ultimate enabler of the movement, but numerical force alone isn't the extent of how the system operates. They symbiotically feed and get fed by the rest of the machine. And it's really who this whole shebang revolves around: the GOP gets older white people votes, the right-wing media complex gets their eyeballs and scams them a bit (e.g.,LifeLock gold reverse mortgages), the elites get policies favorable to them. Older whites get tribalist paens and entertainment and some of their economic interests fought for from leadership and the propaganda organs (e.g., Medicare stays, Obamacare goes, racist jokes and anger on Fox News for the yuks and blood sport). Typical bread and circus stuff.
And you have right-wing media entertainment complex industry and its brightest star and parasite Trump are feeding off of each other, and then catering to that same group of people: older middle class and above whites.
And they all work together to get the state and government and authority bent toward their interests. Simple politics.
Whether you see the right-wing media entertainment complex as in control, or Trump, or the Senate GOP, or the monied elites, or the collective whims of older middle class whites as being the real levers of power I think is largely academic. It's a pretty simple political coalition with leadership, propaganda organs, monied elites, and rank and file. The "who is REALLY in charge?" I think misses the point about how actual political systems work with mutual trades and benefits are spread around to all of the actors and of course control is placed in the elites but even then it is spread around in meaningful ways. Trump is a stakeholder, the GOP old Senate guard like McConnell and McCain and Grassley are stakeholders, Sean Hannity and Rupert Murdoch get rich and powerful too, the Kochs wield some authority and get some favorable policies, etc. The white people hoi polloi get fun tabloidy Fox News and AM radio and some reasonable implicit assurances the elites will look out for their best interests which, I mean it's ****ing America, that basically does happen. It's the younger generations who largely get to deal with the economic insecurity and the browns who get to worry about the cops and batons and the old whites get the fun and a small cut of profits and assurances the floor won't fall out for them.
Last edited by DVaut1; 05-10-2017 at 01:22 PM.