oh well not going to repeat what I said before, but girls just do that kind of stuff. I'm 100% certain that you were way too nice to her and you'd describe that guy more as an ass to the ladies. Then why would he get the girl and you don't? Because girls like the confident macho kind of guys that behave more robust. You need to have an edge so they feel they need to conquer you.
There needs to be a thing about you that makes them wet and tells them that if you want you can get another one. If you can have someone without doing anything it isn't fun anymore. There needs to be a chase and seduction.
It sounds ******ed, but I've had girls ask me if I was a bad boy and I've literally answered "yes I am" that they want you even more lol. It's so crazy, but that's what girls are. I don't even try to comprehend it, because it's too difficult.
I have an almost identical situation to yours btw. I'm also one of those guys that can when I fall in love I'm way too nice to girls and they lose intrest obv.
I had a similar story that you might relate to.
At my weekendjob at the airport I was a personal assistant for vips & kids & ******ed people and at dispatch there worked a fine girl and she always calls everyone honey sweety whatever. One day I had a major hangover and lost my cellphone at work. Someone found it and brought it in and she recognized my picture in the phone and called my parents that I could pick it up the next day.
The next day I go over to her house with a bottle of wine as a thank you and we spend the whole day together chatting and laughing and having an awesome time (8+ hours). At the end of the evening she grabs my hands and tells me that now that I know where she lives I have to visit her more often and we have to meet up again. I'm like **** yeah because I actually liked this girl and almost never have feelings for a girl but I was growing for her.
The next day I call her and we go out for dinner and have an awesome evening. After couple days we do it again and I pick her up from her home and we go on our date. Start with dinner and she orders some cocktail and tells me that when she starts drinking she gets really horny etc.. Me, in love with this girl, immediately tells her that no way will I ever take advantage of her, let alone any girl, if they drink and she can do whatever she wants. After dinner we buy bottle of wine and go rent a movie. She settles on "Love actually" and we go to her home.
She asks me if I want to see her "**** me" boots. (those big white things) and I respond yeah gogo and okay we watch movie etc; BUT ALL THE F TIME I'M NOT DOING ANYTHING because I actually loved her and wanted everything to be special and ****...
Fast forward 1.5 week later she is ill at home. I suprise her with her favourite candy and we sit and she gets a phonecall. She is contemplating to pick it up so I tell her go ahead care... I think it's about work and after minute or 2 she hangs up, but not before saying "love you!" and I'm like O_O What?! She asks me: "nathan what's wrong?" and I'm like who was that? Oh nobody. Nevermind it! So **** that and I leave. She texts me asking why I reacted that way.
Fast forward. I couldn't shut my mouth as my heart was broken and spoke with people at my work about it. Apparently I'm the only ****** there that didn't know she was dating our boss and I was just a boytoy that could have ****ed a really hot girl that I fell in love with :s
Now that I wrote it it's not really the same, but always keep your cool. Maybe buy that bjorn borg boxer and flash it and she'll rip you apart because she wants to feel it