Actually went really well. Girl was a little late, but was much better looking than I was expecting based on her one meh picture. She was smart as hell. Went to some genius <100 person high school in Illinois, really high GPA at Rice. Here for a couple random weeks before her internship starts because her parents work here; doesn't know anyone.
We had dinner. She suggested we look for an ice cream frozen yogurt which I knew nothing about but there happened to be one less than block away. I had paid for dinner but she enthusiastically beat into the pot here. I showed her some of the campus and we played arcade game, which she was really good at. I only won the hit the bag and DDR(which we were both terrible at). Our foosball battle was pretty epic. She had a ridic shot from the back row somehow and beat me in double OT after we started keeping track
We start walking back and I find out she does have a fake ID!(we both got water at dinner; I followed her) So we had a beer( I had 2 because she is 5 2 110 and drinks slow) She tried to leave 10 on the table but ultimately I got the pay in.
Good things
Conversation was amazing. We had like 1 minute of noticable dead time in 3.5 hours, and someone(I think her parents) were texting her then anyway.
She seemed to like all of my stories, including poker which I REALLY didn't want to talk about, but came up because she was wondering why I was 24 and still in undergrad. She seemed to be okay with my rugby hazing and binge drinking and mentioned a few similar stories of her own.
Her idea went pretty smoothly even though I wasn't ready for it.
She made a few references to me being buff/muscular( although I suppose the comment about looking like I could have played D line could go either way
)
On the way back from arcade she asked why I was on online dating because I seemed so normal/wasn't what she was expecting
She didn't drink at dinner, but eventually did have a drink with me.
This may sound really weird but I thought about her as a person first. Like there was actually a connection beyond the physical and like I saw other girls goin out who woulda been objectively hotter, but didn't really look at them.
Bad things
I made a comment she could order what she wanted don't feel like you have to order a salad. I meant like I don't care if it was fattening but it coulda seemed cheap or misogynistic.
Possible I was a bit of a newb at dinner ettiquette. Forgot to put the(paper) napkin on my lap, and ordered a chopstick dish
Though she had mentioned girls/her dressing slutty at her college parties I made comment that one of our rugby parties the girls dressed sluttier which was nice and she didn't have the greatest look on her face, lol
No physical escalation. I was hopin to go for something as I walked her to her car, but somehow she found the most primo parking spot so like multiple people were waiting for her to leave to take that spot and couldn't really fit anything in.