I haven't posted in this thread in a while. This won't blow anyone away, I still can't achieve the level of perfection some of you can, but I was pretty pleased with the results.
I decided to splurge and got 2" thick ribeyes from the counter at Wegmans. You get a better price if you get four, so I did then finished my shopping while they cut them for me. Returned to what appeared to be two bricks wrapped in butcher paper that weighed almost 8 lbs. Sweeeeeeet.
Took out one for today, rest were vacuum sealed and frozen for later splurges. Put in the oven at 250 until the inside hit 125 (I like my ribeye steaks closer to medium than rare to make sure all that delicious fat is melted), pulled it and rested while I prepared a garlic potato and cauliflower smash. Heated my stainless steel pan to medium high, threw in butter, seared the edges for two minutes total all around to render the fat, then finished off with a 60 second sear on each side, weighted.
Didn't get any shots of the steak until the end. Too much grey band but outstanding (for me) sear and the inside was perfect for my tastes minus the grey band. Really happy with how this turned out. Served with the aforementioned smash and baby peas, not shown because you guys always mock my plating.