Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
zillow.com (for real estate people) zillow.com (for real estate people)

04-21-2008 , 02:24 PM
Zillow is all over the map. I have seen it give dead on estimates and be 20% out of whack. For example I bought my house 1.5 years ago. According to Zillow I could have sold it the next day for a 18-20% gain and the house had been on the market for 45 days when I bought it....... It's still high by over 10% today.

It does show you recently sold, but you need to be able to look at them and adjust the price accordingly.
zillow.com (for real estate people) Quote
04-21-2008 , 05:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GittyUP
Zillow is garbage. It doesn't work in changing markets and uses very blunt tools to value a property.

I use Realquest.com (paid subscription) and the MLS. Trulia.com also works well for finding active listings if you dont have access to the MLS I can value out a property with extreme accuracy in a few minutes with these tools. Great for sorting out potential deals from lots of leads.
Phenomenal post just glancing these look like good tools. You're a realtor then?
zillow.com (for real estate people) Quote
04-21-2008 , 05:31 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PayPerChase
Phenomenal post just glancing these look like good tools. You're a realtor then?
Investor, wholesaler, and realtor. In that order as well.

Realquest pays for itself in one deal. The MLS is invaluable too but you need to be a realtor to use it.
zillow.com (for real estate people) Quote
04-21-2008 , 10:31 PM
How much would a normal realtor charge me to pull comps and value a property? Never used one before.
zillow.com (for real estate people) Quote
04-22-2008 , 02:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PayPerChase
How much would a normal realtor charge me to pull comps and value a property? Never used one before.
you could find one to do it for less then $50 Im sure. Or offer them a couple hundred to pull many comps on mnay properties. You might even find one to do it for free in exchange for future business.

EDIT: Avoid BPO (Broker price opinon) These cost ~$200 and are nothing more then an official opinion. Its more of a legally binding quote but quite unnecessary and expensive.
zillow.com (for real estate people) Quote
04-22-2008 , 02:06 PM
what about getting comps from a title company? it's a free service sometimes even if you're not closing deals there.
zillow.com (for real estate people) Quote
04-22-2008 , 04:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by dippity doo
what about getting comps from a title company? it's a free service sometimes even if you're not closing deals there.
Really? this is real? My good friend owns a title company.

Never discussed this with them
zillow.com (for real estate people) Quote
04-22-2008 , 05:40 PM
just tell him dippity doo referred you
zillow.com (for real estate people) Quote
04-22-2008 , 08:43 PM
I plan on purchasing another house in around seven months.......I will be using zillow to aid my research.
zillow.com (for real estate people) Quote
04-22-2008 , 08:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PayPerChase
How reliable is info from zillow.com I've been referred to it but have never used it much in comping properties I look at. Is it reliable enough to where I can take the zillow estimated value of a property and use that to structure my offers and bottom lines?
No.

Two big flaws: the data is too old, especially in fast moving markets, the numbers can be absurdly out of phase. Second, their data mining methodology is fundamentally flawed. For example, they will list a foreclosure as a sale, with the price listed as the balance of the mortgage. This is just wrong on both counts and can badly skew the data in areas of high foreclosure rates.
zillow.com (for real estate people) Quote
04-22-2008 , 09:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by eastbay
No.

Two big flaws: the data is too old, especially in fast moving markets, the numbers can be absurdly out of phase. Second, their data mining methodology is fundamentally flawed. For example, they will list a foreclosure as a sale, with the price listed as the balance of the mortgage. This is just wrong on both counts and can badly skew the data in areas of high foreclosure rates.
I remembered something vaguely like this. Thanks for explaining it again.
zillow.com (for real estate people) Quote
04-22-2008 , 09:35 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by eastbay
No.

Two big flaws: the data is too old, especially in fast moving markets, the numbers can be absurdly out of phase. Second, their data mining methodology is fundamentally flawed. For example, they will list a foreclosure as a sale, with the price listed as the balance of the mortgage. This is just wrong on both counts and can badly skew the data in areas of high foreclosure rates.
Confirms my points...
zillow.com (for real estate people) Quote
04-23-2008 , 01:25 AM
I've only glanced at zillow, but in my area the prices are way wrong. I'm sure there are some markets where zillow is closer. but either way to get bank financing you'll probably have to get a appraisal.
zillow.com (for real estate people) Quote
04-23-2008 , 09:06 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by spex x
I've only glanced at zillow, but in my area the prices are way wrong. I'm sure there are some markets where zillow is closer. but either way to get bank financing you'll probably have to get a appraisal.
Bank Financing? what's that
zillow.com (for real estate people) Quote
04-24-2008 , 01:13 AM
When I sold my last house 3 years ago Zillow had it at $100,000 more than it sold for. Needless to say, I wouldn't trust it.
zillow.com (for real estate people) Quote
04-24-2008 , 03:16 PM


First pic is Zillow. Second pic is appraiser/realtor comps.

Not that Zillow is always wrong; it's just that its non-factual information should only be used as a starting point.
zillow.com (for real estate people) Quote
04-24-2008 , 09:04 PM
That chick is super ugly nasty in both pictures.... My perspective
zillow.com (for real estate people) Quote
04-25-2008 , 01:14 AM
zillow is decent for areas where the homes are very similar in age/quality. Specifically, condos, newly constructed homes in stable markets, and neighborhoods with homogenious characteristics.

you must remember that until zillow has the ability to get interior photos of the home, determine the layout, properly adjust for lot size, figure out curb appeal, see if the neighborhood dynamics change, zillow will be flawed.

there is a reason that realtors/appraisers actually go to the property to check it out before determining value.
zillow.com (for real estate people) Quote
04-25-2008 , 03:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Daliman


First pic is Zillow. Second pic is appraiser/realtor comps.

Not that Zillow is always wrong; it's just that its non-factual information should only be used as a starting point.
still laughing!
zillow.com (for real estate people) Quote
04-25-2008 , 05:02 PM
For kicks, I "zillow'd" my house. I think the zestimate is pretty accurate - it's about what I'd be listing it for and is slightly over the taxable value.

That's good.

I also looked up the house next door. The owner died a couple years ago and the kids haven't spent much money keeping the place up. It's a wreck. At a minimum, it's going to need new siding (dry rot), a new roof and major interior remodel. The zestimate is only a few thousand less than my house - which I'm sure is a function of my neighbor's inflated tax value.

Not so good - off by at least 50k, probably more.

zillow's a lot of fun but I wouldn't rely on it for much!
zillow.com (for real estate people) Quote

      
m