Quote:
Originally Posted by LT22
if you withdraw, you would have to take out the $5k +/- any change in the value of your IRA.
Ex) the value of the $5k is now $5050. You will withdraw $5050, have income of $50, and pay $5 penalty.
Ex2) the value is now $4950. Withdraw $4950, no 10% penalty
Thanks guys, I was mostly confused about which deposit my withdrawal would correspond with.
For example say I deposited 5k in 2008 and 5k in 2012. The total portfolio is now 11k due to gains between 2008 and 2012. I was wondering if I take out 5k now if that would 'include' the 1k gain from 2008. Apparently it doesn't, your withdrawal corresponds to your most recent deposit as long as the same number of shares are taken out.
I ended up pulling the money out with a nice $20 profit. Pretty sure I'll just have to report that next year at tax time and pay the hefty $2 fine.