Quote:
Originally Posted by Thremp
jively,
Are you really charging .1-.3% commissions? Or is it closer to 1%?
1% would be grossly high and .1% is grossly low.
Though to be fair most people are ******s. I just don't see why you charge someone more to manage 10 mil than 1 mil. Are adding zeros that hard? Could you outsource it and cut some costs?
i have NO CLUE what you guys are talking about. why aren't you railing on hedge funds for the 2%??
is it that much harder to "manage" 100mil, than it is to manage 30bil?? sure, it costs maybe a bit more, but c'mon...
basically, the answer to your question in bold above is:
no. they charge that because they can.
and the logic is correct, the people who are willing to pay 100bps:
a) are not smart enough/dedicated enough/ have enough time to manage the portfolio on their own and thus would easily cost themselves more than 1%/year if they did it themselves.
b) are not smart enough to realize that what the advisor could do with 10mil they could easily do with 100mil.
all the "small cap" "value" fund stuff is simply reliance on past trends with no logical basis for that outperformance (i.e. why isn't the bias priced in and thus expected to be nil going forward?).
if the funds REALLY wanted to add value, theyd use leverage to increase the risk/reward of bonds/IL bonds and other less risky products in order to generate true diversification and provide highly targeted returns.
that is the investment strategy of the fund that i'm building for the future (once i figure out the LEAPS vs. -or in addition to- futures thing).
and my fund will not charge over 100bps and i GUARANTEE you that it:
a) is way harder to administer/manage than anything any traditional advisor does
b) will provide way more return per unit risk.
so overal, advisors are NOT useless at all to their clients (ie. their clients are not smart w.r.t. their ability to manage their own money/realize they could research it and do it more cheaply etc.) AND they charge those fees because they can (and they provide a service).
Barron