Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills?

09-15-2010 , 07:47 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kfs
This.

People who play hoping to get "lucky", or feel they are consistent losers only because of "luck', might as well just pray to jesus for some run good, there really isnt much of a difference.
However this is being naive. Luck is an important part of the game. Sure, over 9999999999x99999999 hands it evens out, but running good in certain spots, situations etc can make or break a player.
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-15-2010 , 07:56 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by acehearts
JJ preferably raise almost all the time, but becareful of raise and reraises pre-flop which is indicative of Aks or top pairs.

Otherwise you might play deceptive and limp, if you hit a set on the flop(roughly 1 in 8 chance) then its jackpot for you.
ROFLMMFAO

Ok. OP is just f**king with us now. But, just in case you're not! There's a cash game at my house on Thursdays every week. Please come show me how your mastery of fundamental poker skills and one year of experience give you just as much of a chance of getting the money as I have. Please.
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-15-2010 , 11:55 PM
lol.


elements of luck do not mean its all luck.

elements of skill do not mean its all skill.

but skill creates positions where you can exploit luck.

if you have 9 guys with equal skill (exactly equal) then it is luck that will be the x factor, but that never happens really.
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 12:05 AM
op u should try to play some headsup ,clearly the form with the most skill involved
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 12:53 AM
grunching

No.
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 12:59 AM
As a high stakes player, I am going to say no. The funamental skills can get very complex and are very hard to learn as you move up in limits.

And I for one am extremely big on fundamentals and poker theory and think that it is the foundation to success all the way to the nosebleeds.
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 01:00 AM
I have not read any post or even the OP, I have just read the title.

Pick ANY game.

Pick two players who have the exact same skill level.

Each wins 50% of the time, thus the outcome of the game between EXACTLY similar players is determined ENTIRELY by luck.

It follows that, as the skill differential between the particular players that happen to be playing a game gets smaller, the outcome of that game will be determined more and more by luck.
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 01:11 AM
Quote:
Just a thought for you guys, if a person plays tight with premium hands and pairs (sometimes limping sometimes raising), consider postion and bluffs at correct times(like when sensing weakness, having position, forcing out drawing hands etc), and play according to pot odds. How can he mathematically lose in the long run?
Easy, if he's up against a highly skilled player who has identified his hand range and ABC strategy and made the necessary adjustments.

That's the beauty of poker. There are winning players that fit every conceivable category - some of the time. For the consumate pro, there is a time for every season under heaven and all that - the very best players identify the way their opponents are playing, and they adjust and counter by adopting any style of play across the spectrum from nut-peddler to lagtard / outright maniac depending on what the circumstances dictate.

The object in poker is to make the right decisions over and over again - and the "right" decision over 1,000,000,000 or more hands is something that requires an amazing array of abilities - Recognition, adaptability, endurance, patience and fortitude in the face of "bad luck", emotional stability, the ability to trust your intuition and "gut" etc. etc. etc. - The same skills that make you successful in the long run at anything. Poker is life.

Anyone who's ready to write it off as simple and simply "luck" after a year or two or even 10, is simply reveling the soft white underbelly of their own lack of understanding - nothing else.
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 01:19 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by acehearts
the neccessary skills mainly calculating pot odds, starting hand selection, hand reading and positional play.

Mainly beginners lose because of a few things. they play almost every hand, they do no calculate pot odds but call rather on gut instincts, they bluff too often and don't understand postitional play.

The internet is available to everyone, so everyone can read up strategies on poker and put the same strategies to practice. The main thing in live games is you get bored and limp too much or you play on tilt, control that emotion and you're good.
Quote:
Originally Posted by imfromsweden
oh dear ****ing god, you really don't have the slighest clue

The room for improvement is endless
Please begin this endless list from where he left off. With the basics mastered and competence at avoiding/exploiting the above situations is achieved, what can a player study to significantly increase his win rate?
If you're able to use all the tools, keep abreast of the latest strategies and ideas, are winning 5k per 100,000 hands 4 tabling within BR, taking occasional shots but you're only finding a very slight improvement over time what (lets just do one) would likely increase the profit to 15k, within 500,000 hands?
I with OP on this one. Ye keep saying everyone's solid, so realise that there will be a time when this thread will meet with a resounding consensus. I think it is fast approaching. When the % of solid tag nanonokos reaches a certain level, then with rake taken into account, the statement "Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills" will be true. What percentage is that? What percentage is it at now? How fast is it rising?

Quote:
Originally Posted by so bad
Can somebody who's read all the strategies please tell me what to do when I get JJ?
fold (UTG-SB) Check/fold (BB), Check/fold every street. If live, fold face up in HU pots.

Quote:
Originally Posted by ben wb
I like Derren but that was a 40BB deep turbo sit and go which lasted for 40 hands, she won a couple of coinflips and they didn't show her making any great plays. There was nothing to suggest she'd even be a winning player in the long term, even at low stakes.
She's dominating the Euros, mainly Betfair 10/20, building BR to gonna crush FT and Stars
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 01:45 AM
Seriously...WTF is luck.
Hitting a 2 outer isn't luck Flopping flushes isn't luck. It's just an equation balancing out.

Lol, luck
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 01:56 AM
You're right OP, poker is all luck after a while.

Spoiler:
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 02:11 AM
level 1: math
level 2-infinity: meta
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 03:49 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Igobustosoon
Why does every single guy who doesn't play profitable think poker is all about luck?
Im married and I think poker is all luck also
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 03:52 AM
op tbh from reading your post you have no idea how to play poker sorry =/
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 04:50 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by spino1i
As a high stakes player, I am going to say no. The funamental skills can get very complex and are very hard to learn as you move up in limits.

And I for one am extremely big on fundamentals and poker theory and think that it is the foundation to success all the way to the nosebleeds.
listen to spinol1 for sure. imo he's probalby one of the very few posters itt that have played poker for more than cheeseburgers.
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 04:58 AM
Poker ain't a game, yo.
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 04:59 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jumboAL
You're right OP, poker is all luck after a while.

Spoiler:
I takes a great player to pass 1 mil three times without falling under it.
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 05:17 AM
OP does not yet realise his cluelessness. I had the same mindset 2.5 years ago when I was playing poker for a year, and boy was I wrong..
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 05:22 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mumrik
Just so you know, at your tables there are probably at least two other players that knows exactly what you are doing playing your predetermined game and they leave with your money more often than not. You didnt notice though, you were to busy taking pots of the bad players going all in with AA. Them two players would probably disagree poker is mostly about luck.
fyp
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 05:41 AM
No money in a game mostly on luck, everyone mastered the fundamental skills
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 05:43 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Criminal
fyp
Fixed your name.
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 08:20 AM
In the short-term luck plays a role, especially in the very short term, like one session or even one week's worth of sessions. In the long run, SKILL, SKILL, SKILL wins out over luck.
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 08:42 AM
OP - yes it's all luck once we reach a certain level. With 23098234098 players online, eventually a few guys are going to go on heaters and reach the top (Durr case in point).

Other posters berating OP - DTTG.
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 09:20 AM
this is the dumbest thread ive ever opened. OP doesnt have a clue and one day hell prolly figure it out. or he wont.
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote
09-16-2010 , 10:32 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by acehearts
Look at victor ramdin in high stakes poker, I could easily play better than him. (If I have his BR lol)
Well,that just shows you are not better than him.
There is a reason he is playing high stakes and how he got there.
Okay,i understand if some good regular is saying he would play there better than Guy Lalibrete,then somehow can agree with it,because he's fortune didn't came from poker.But Victor Ramdin is a poker player and he grind hes way to those stakes,so i highly doubt you would beat him.

Last edited by J0hny; 09-16-2010 at 10:41 AM.
Is poker a game mostly on luck once you mastered the fundamental skills? Quote

      
m