Quote:
Originally Posted by davewebb
He banned travel from China early on, and then travel from Europe - actions that were widely mocked and criticized by his opponents but undoubtedly saved thousands of lives.
A lot has been made of this - especially by Trump, who has mentioned it countless times. But it's come up a lot here in Canada as well, as we took a much different path, and our government has been taking a kicking for it by some. But is it important?
The US currently has over 188,000 Covid cases. Canada, at ~1/9 the population, has ~8,600. On a per capita basis, US has about 2.5x the cases that Canada has. New cases today running at almost the same ratio. Fatalities, about 4x.
The US closed their borders to China on Feb. 2nd. Canada? Mar. 16th. Italy? Jan. 31.
Vancouver has "more direct mainland Chinese flights than any other airport in North America or Europe" as of 2017.
https://www.cnn.com/travel/article/v...hub/index.html
Vancouver is the biggest city in the province of British Columbia, and BC's cases per capita are lower than Canada overall.
So, what does this tell us? Right now, nothing conclusive. Although we're entering the thick of it over the next few weeks, it's still early. Numbers could shift dramatically. But right now, we have some pretty strong trends, and if they continue, it appears there will be a significant difference between our countries' results. If that happens, it would lead me to conclude one of two things. Either:
1) Closing borders makes little to no difference, or
2) Closing borders is a small factor relative to others
A lot of experts in the field contend closing borders doesn't help. Maybe they're right?
Quote:
Originally Posted by SetSetter
There's a clear middle ground where he could have cautioned the nation while simultaneously assuring people there is nothing to panic about and that his administration would keep an eye on it and guide the nation through it.
Yup. We've been living that here for a few weeks. I'm hoping Trump might have finally got there.