Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware?

03-12-2018 , 10:52 PM
https://www.uspoker.com/blog/22-bans...-issues/22148/

Nagy actually speaks:

Quote:
But, he continued, if ACR were to abandon its privacy policy to “out” these players, everyone would hate the consequences – and mistakes would inevitably be made as some honest players could be banned in error.

Phil stands by his emphasis on making sure player funds are safe, something that both Mason Malmuth and Joe Ingram have praised, but he thinks that his efforts to ensure game fairness have not been appreciated.

He explains that the reason he has not taken to social media to counter Ingram’s claims is that to do so would be counter-productive and simply give credence to claims which he rejects as unfair.

Last edited by hAmThEkIlLeR; 03-12-2018 at 10:53 PM. Reason: mentioning who the quote is from
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-12-2018 , 10:57 PM
Quote:
But, he continued, if ACR were to abandon its privacy policy to “out” these players, everyone would hate the consequences – and mistakes would inevitably be made as some honest players could be banned in error.
I remember Nagy saying quite emphatically in a podcast that he would ban real players by accident to illustrate how determined he is to getting rid of bots.

I guess it's good he finally acknowledged the ****storm, but it's a pretty cookie cutter response
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-12-2018 , 11:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by tgiggity
I remember Nagy saying quite emphatically in a podcast that he would ban real players by accident to illustrate how determined he is to getting rid of bots.

I guess it's good he finally acknowledged the ****storm, but it's a pretty cookie cutter response
And there is at least one point where he is leaving out a thing or two. He said that he wasn't able to respond because he was on a family vacation in Colombia, but a business associate of his let slip in the internet forum that he saw him in London.

Also I think his explanation of how he isn't responding on social media to the claims that have been made because they are "unfair" is ridiculous. If they are unfair, then the first thing a competent CEO would do is take to every platform available to expose them as false.


Also there are some more troubling developments out of acr.

From the withdraw/deposit thread in the internet forum:


Quote:
Originally Posted by poloplaya1414
Requested a $25K cashout via btc. Had it cancelled and was told to call support. Was told by support that even though the cashier states that the max is $25K, the max is actually $10K. He also said "withdrawal limits are constantly changing."

That's a direct quote. He basically tried to imply that ACR has no control over withdrawal limits and that they had to change them regularly to comply with some "regulation". Which of course doesn't really make much sense.

Anyways, I requested a $10K withdrawal via btc and will keep people posted on how it goes.

So now, we have Nagy in two lies. The first is that WPN is going to be so hard on bots that some real players will be "collateral damage," the second one is about how he will always get players their money.


Winning_TD was caught lying about how the WPN forum wasn't closed because of not responding to an email, to which Mr. Malmuth immediately refuted.


I cannot find a single reason for any player to deposit another cent on WPN until they clean out the sewer from top to bottom.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-13-2018 , 06:11 AM
can u clear ur inbox, joey?
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-13-2018 , 08:30 AM
Quote:
USPoker contacted Phil Nagy to get his side of the story. In a long Skype call, Nagy’s frustration with the situation was very evident. He clearly feels that the criticism is unfair and believes that he takes game security more seriously than most of his competitors in both the US facing and rest of the world market.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Winning_TD
Before you sit here and think security and I are useless we send a warning email when its a first offence. However we don’t sit there and look out for things unless someone reports it.
Most sites have poor security. Saying you have better security than most isn't saying much. While it may be true it's still insufficient. The criticism is completely justified.

Last edited by MCAChiTown; 03-13-2018 at 08:40 AM.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-13-2018 , 10:03 AM
Quote:
The operators would like to name names, but privacy laws and data protection provisions as well as general law make this difficult for them to do. The PokerStars security guy told me that contrary to popular belief, the vast majority of bots and collusion are identified by their own procedures well in advance of any complaints by other players.

As at ACR, action to ban these accounts is taken privately and in line with the site’s terms and conditions. Using the law to prosecute is beset with problems and only works in the most blatant cases.
well if the vast majority is discovered in house why this week is the first ever report of a refund?

and laws pfffff so break every law you can and then follow the law of privacy
what privacy laws we talking about here

and then also say in same breath using the law only works in most blatant cases implying the recourse for law sucks.

also comparing wpn to pstars security and speaking to someone at pstars security pffff like wpn is publicly traded and needs to follow privacy laws

funny stuff
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-13-2018 , 02:52 PM
New video talking about the Winning Poker Network CONFIRMING cheating on the site & issuing refunds to cash game players, bots being banned & reappearing, comments made by ACR CEO & the connection between software creator IG Soft & shady skin PokerKing..

Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-13-2018 , 02:58 PM
I don't play at ACR and haven't for years but thank you, Joey. Good work.

13:37. Coincidence?
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-13-2018 , 03:27 PM
solid work papi. at this point I wouldn't be surprised in the least to learn that in addition to bots there is insider superusing going on. Mr Nagy doesn't seem like an honest, stand up individual. could easily see him pulling a Russ Hamilton on everyone.

in any case, keep up the great work Joey! the poker world needs more people like you in it. massive PLO karmic upswing coming your way, best believe!!!
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-13-2018 , 04:06 PM
damnn thats not good.. Software creator has ability to make accounts and runs his own skin? SuperUser looking possible now.. I think the RNG needs an audit after every server update.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-13-2018 , 04:42 PM
I mean, super using is definitely plausible on these black market poker sites. It's totally plausible that someone could be using a modified client that allows them to see hole cards and/or runouts. They would just need to play their cards wisely in order to not be detected. (Basically don't pull a POTRIPPER.)

All of this would be so much harder to detect on Bovada due to its anonymous nature.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-13-2018 , 05:31 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dick Tracy
I mean, super using is definitely plausible on these black market poker sites. It's totally plausible that someone could be using a modified client that allows them to see hole cards and/or runouts. They would just need to play their cards wisely in order to not be detected. (Basically don't pull a POTRIPPER.)

All of this would be so much harder to detect on Bovada due to its anonymous nature.
I think people underestimate how hard this is to detect. And yeah, a smart superuser can come off as "just another solid regular." It's messed up.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-13-2018 , 05:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by dan_polk
solid work papi. at this point I wouldn't be surprised in the least to learn that in addition to bots there is insider superusing going on. Mr Nagy doesn't seem like an honest, stand up individual. could easily see him pulling a Russ Hamilton on everyone.

in any case, keep up the great work Joey! the poker world needs more people like you in it. massive PLO karmic upswing coming your way, best believe!!!

+1

And many thanks once again to Joe Ingram, a true hero for poker.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-13-2018 , 05:59 PM
A win for Papi!

Can we get a response from Chase Thunder? Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware?
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-13-2018 , 11:25 PM
yeah TY private I papi
we can't erect that shrine after all we didn't get any refunds for the husng bot ring they let run for years, we will make a snowman with this fresh snow and put a tank top on it in honor of you!

Last edited by netgod44; 03-13-2018 at 11:27 PM. Reason: a great tip, don't eat yellow snow
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-14-2018 , 01:59 AM
What is everyone's thoughts on if WPN are potentially manipulating RNG in cash games?
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-14-2018 , 02:30 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by f1tz
What is everyone's thoughts on if WPN are potentially manipulating RNG in cash games?
That's probably heading into rigtard land. I think superusers are more likely than that, and superusers are pretty unlikely. I do think collusion and people using real-time GTO helper software are the most likely things going on.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-14-2018 , 02:37 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by f1tz
What is everyone's thoughts on if WPN are potentially manipulating RNG in cash games?
I am currently about as anti-WPN as anyone can be, and my thoughts are simple: no, RNG works fine. It might be the only thing that works correctly in their software/network, but it seems fine to me.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-14-2018 , 03:31 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by WorldzMine
That's probably heading into rigtard land. I think superusers are more likely than that, and superusers are pretty unlikely. I do think collusion and people using real-time GTO helper software are the most likely things going on.
Yea sounds pretty rigtard but a few people in this thread have said something about it so I just wanted to bring it up
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-14-2018 , 06:45 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by f1tz
Yea sounds pretty rigtard but a few people in this thread have said something about it so I just wanted to bring it up
I don't think it's fair to dismiss it as "rigtard," especially given what we already know about WPN.

The key thing to realize is that we're talking about a black market here. And so we should expect absurd levels of corruption and even outright fraud, as there are strong incentives for both.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-14-2018 , 07:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by clfst17
I don't think it's fair to dismiss it as "rigtard," especially given what we already know about WPN.

The key thing to realize is that we're talking about a black market here. And so we should expect absurd levels of corruption and even outright fraud, as there are strong incentives for both.
I agree with the second part, but not the first. If the site/network were going to intentionally cheat, then rigging an RNG is probably the worst way that they could do it.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-14-2018 , 09:42 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by krcmdc
I agree with the second part, but not the first. If the site/network were going to intentionally cheat, then rigging an RNG is probably the worst way that they could do it.
I responded to the wrong comment and now can't edit it unfortunately; I was talking about WorldzMine's comment that "superusers are pretty unlikely," not RNG rigging.

I agree that RNG rigging would be the worst and least likely way to cheat and can be pretty much fully dismissed as a possibility.

But the odds of other forms of fraud such as superusing, multi-accounting, ponzi-schemes with player deposits, and other shenanigans are substantially higher in the case of a black market such as the U.S. online poker market.

Last edited by clfst17; 03-14-2018 at 09:50 AM.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-14-2018 , 09:46 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by WorldzMine
That's probably heading into rigtard land. I think superusers are more likely than that, and superusers are pretty unlikely. I do think collusion and people using real-time GTO helper software are the most likely things going on.
Agree completely.

How does any site fight/prevent this? The ability to somehow tie in a GTO solver to all the data in a HUD is pretty damaging to the game I would think.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-14-2018 , 09:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by a dewd
Agree completely.

How does any site fight/prevent this? The ability to somehow tie in a GTO solver to all the data in a HUD is pretty damaging to the game I would think.
I don't see a way to prevent this. The writing has been on the wall for more than a decade now.

The only solution is new poker variants that are too complex to collect meaningful data on/approximately solve.

Online poker in its current form is doomed.

Last edited by clfst17; 03-14-2018 at 09:59 AM.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote
03-14-2018 , 05:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by clfst17
I don't see a way to prevent this. The writing has been on the wall for more than a decade now.

The only solution is new poker variants that are too complex to collect meaningful data on/approximately solve.

Online poker in its current form is doomed.
Doomed... doomed.

Online poker doesn't exist anymore. Maybe somewhere in Europe.
Chicago Joey accuses WPN (ACR) of massive botting and cheating, beware? Quote

      
m