Quote:
Originally Posted by Money2Burn
You’re saying we should not trust the reporting of NYT and Vox. That is exactly the opposite of what Taibbi is saying. I’ll quote it for you again:
I’ll ask you again, why does Vox being neoliberal make its reporting untrustworthy?
A whole chapter of his book Taibbi devotes to how NYT reporters "groupthinked" us into the Iraq war. He says that they didn't lie but then explains how they uncritically swallow official sources and still only present a range of opinion.
I take that to mean don't trust them.
Taibbi is saying that if a plane falls on I-70, that they are going to give you the correct body count. I agree that they will. He says in the vast majority of reporting, trust reporters. There isn't a problem with that statement. Most reporting is on inconsequential stuff.
Let's also point out that Taibbi is a reporter and seems to have a lot of reporter friends, so he's probably not going to be saying that all reporters are pathological liars and he might even find ways to diminish their culpability while still finding ways to attack the news business overall.
You've literally picked one errant line of a book you haven't read and taken it to mean the opposite thesis--that mainstream news is trustworthy.
Last edited by Luckbox Inc; 09-11-2019 at 09:53 AM.