Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism)

06-19-2019 , 10:35 AM
The Weeds "illiberal right" podcast has a succinct section where they talk about how there's not much of a constituency for libertarian free markets and not much of a constituency for hardcore Catholic fundamentalists but there is a huge constituency for white resentment and the conservative project has been to transmute that constituency into more respectable and presentable facades
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-19-2019 , 10:57 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kelhus999
I dont watch CNN (or Fox News FWIW). I am sure Don Lemon is good at what he does, or he wouldn't have lasted as long as he has. TV news seems to be a pretty cutthroat business, so I would not expect there to be a lot of incompetent people that lasted a long time.
Spoiler:
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-19-2019 , 11:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trolly McTrollson
No one’s yet come up with a good name for this new venue.
Maybe you guys should just go with Chezfront, and then ban Chez from the forum.
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-19-2019 , 11:13 AM
Or let him return and call it Chezback.
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-19-2019 , 12:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kelhus999
I guess you missed the post where I acknowledged this already. Or it doesn't fit your narrative, so you conveniently ignore it, per usual.
Yeah man check the timestamps on that before you accuse me of dishonesty.

But after being suitability chastened, any chance of you returning to my question about who taught you about the left? Because it kinda seems that the self-serving fairytales about how the white ones are all just as racist as you but faking tolerance to cause income inequality and the black ones are black nationalists seem to keep falling apart.

Maybe... it is possible to just not be racist? And also to morally oppose racism on the merits as a bad thing?

The Biden thing is actually a great springboard into your nonsense about where the empathy deficit lies. In defending the segregationist Biden says that he never called Biden "boy". Like, no ****, and if he had you wouldn't have been offended. Being nice and civil to a white fellow member of Congress is not really as strong of a mark of good character as Biden thinks.

The analog to this thread seems pretty straightforward.
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-19-2019 , 12:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trolly McTrollson
No one’s yet come up with a good name for this new venue.

I was fond of the politics and eugenics moniker.
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-19-2019 , 02:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by FlyWf

Maybe... it is possible to just not be racist? And also to morally oppose racism on the merits as a bad thing?
Sam Harris would probably answer yes, and argue that is his MO, but you would probably disagree.

To answer the question in a more broad, philosophic manner; do I believe it is possible for human beings to divorce themselves from custom and circumstance, and be a truly moral self moving soul. No, not really.

And even if there was a way, I don’t think it would be accomplished through moralizing and name calling.
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-19-2019 , 04:26 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kelhus999
That is actually an interesting observation, that who the out of group other is is very situational, and there is nothing like an outside threat to bring disparate people together into a unified front.



In Wookie's forum where non leftists were not tolerated at all, people with varying degrees of leftism would be in conflict. However, in a true open forum, like this one, people like Fly and Suzzer would never take shots at each other. They would always show a unified front against the new other (eg. me and Luckbox). In this forum iteration I doubt any of the "woke" crew have taken any shot at each other at all.



This is very well understood sociological concept. It is no accident that pretty much every alien invasion movie/book ever made involves all the people of the world who couldn't ever get along before putting aside their differences and banding together against the common alien enemy; because this is how human sociology works and probably pretty close to what would happen in such an occurrence.
This post is a lie, but hey civility!
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-19-2019 , 06:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trolly McTrollson
No one’s yet come up with a good name for this new venue.
Stormnamed?
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-19-2019 , 06:20 PM
Kontentions, Kontroversies, and Konflicts?
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-19-2019 , 06:30 PM
I think if we're going that route I'd like to change it to "Kontentions, Kontroversies, and Krispy Kremes"
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-19-2019 , 06:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by FlyWf

The Biden thing is actually a great springboard into your nonsense about where the empathy deficit lies. In defending the segregationist Biden says that he never called Biden "boy". Like, no ****, and if he had you wouldn't have been offended. Being nice and civil to a white fellow member of Congress is not really as strong of a mark of good character as Biden thinks.
Just based on the tweet itt, I don’t think he was trying to say that.
“At least there was some civility. We got things done”
His job as a senator is to get things done for his constituency, just like foreign diplomats are supposed to get things done for their country. Oftentimes doing so requires being civil to the morally repugnant or political opposition in order to get things done. I think that’s what he was trying to say. He probably could have found a better example to make his point, though.
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-19-2019 , 09:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kelhus999
To answer the question in a more broad, philosophic manner; do I believe it is possible for human beings to divorce themselves from custom and circumstance, and be a truly moral self moving soul. No, not really.

And even if there was a way, I don’t think it would be accomplished through moralizing and name calling.
I don't think you're gonna like what's behind door number 2, then. Here's a hint: it isn't "agreeing with you"
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-20-2019 , 02:04 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kelhus999
I dont watch CNN (or Fox News FWIW). I am sure Don Lemon is good at what he does, or he wouldn't have lasted as long as he has. TV news seems to be a pretty cutthroat business, so I would not expect there to be a lot of incompetent people that lasted a long time.
Or maybe there're reasons why people are on tv besides being effective communicators with well thought out ideas?


Quote:
Most elected officials aren't ideologues, at least not in public. That being said, I actually think on both the right and left I could find members where as far as who they criticize/praise there is a very strong tribal pattern that goes along race/sex/other identity lines.
But that wasn't your claim. You said that you knew from that one quote that he was only ever about race issues, would never say anything negative about minorities, and is openly hostile to whites who aren't actively taking positions against racism.

I can understand why someone wouldn't take bidens chummy response as an endorsement of the guys politics but it gets pretty close to that line. He went above and beyond to signal positive vibes for one of the most prolific racists still alive.

Do you really think he was being uppity for drawing attention to it? Or are you just the target market that biden was signaling to?

That's not a personal attack... clearly his comment had intent. He wanted to convey something to some group of people regardless of whether it was a transparent account of how he feels. What do you think that message was?
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-20-2019 , 02:34 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Abbaddabba
He wanted to convey something to some group of people regardless of whether it was a transparent account of how he feels. What do you think that message was?
CBS News Battleground Tracker
Democrats in Early Primary/Caucus States
34. Which is a priority in a Democratic nominee...someone who, if elected President, would try to...
Work with Republicans to get things done . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 65%
Get things done without Republicans . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35%
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-20-2019 , 05:07 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Abbaddabba
Or maybe there're reasons why people are on tv besides being effective communicators with well thought out ideas?




But that wasn't your claim. You said that you knew from that one quote that he was only ever about race issues, would never say anything negative about minorities, and is openly hostile to whites who aren't actively taking positions against racism.

I can understand why someone wouldn't take bidens chummy response as an endorsement of the guys politics but it gets pretty close to that line. He went above and beyond to signal positive vibes for one of the most prolific racists still alive.

Do you really think he was being uppity for drawing attention to it? Or are you just the target market that biden was signaling to?

That's not a personal attack... clearly his comment had intent. He wanted to convey something to some group of people regardless of whether it was a transparent account of how he feels. What do you think that message was?
There is so much bad faith in this post I am not even going to bother.
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-20-2019 , 12:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by John21
CBS News Battleground Tracker
Democrats in Early Primary/Caucus States
34. Which is a priority in a Democratic nominee...someone who, if elected President, would try to...
Work with Republicans to get things done . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 65%
Get things done without Republicans . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35%
I’d say there’s a bit of a gap between a commitment to bipartisanship / working with republicans and fondly remembering a democratwho last held office in the 70s whose legacy is being a passionate segregationist.
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-20-2019 , 12:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kelhus999
There is so much bad faith in this post I am not even going to bother.
Is it bad faith, or is that I’m not using the tiniest shred of plausible deniability to rationalize the conclusion I want to arrive at?

It’s not a lie if you believe it.
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-20-2019 , 03:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Abbaddabba
Is it bad faith, or is that I’m not using the tiniest shred of plausible deniability to rationalize the conclusion I want to arrive at?

It’s not a lie if you believe it.
Well, when you tell me what I said 2 posts ago and get it wrong in a very uncharitable fashion, it is going to be a nonstarter, whatever your motives.
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-20-2019 , 04:20 PM
Quote:
“I think of America, the great assimilator, as a rubber band, but with this — we’re at the breaking point,” Ms. Crockett said. “These aren’t people coming from Norway, let’s put it that way. These people are very visible.”
Quote:
Others said that markers of progress were more interpersonal, and they would only be comfortable in their community if the Somali-born refugees converted to Christianity.

One woman, who declined to give her name after the group discussion, bemoaned the city’s so-called no-go zones, or the areas where white residents said they felt so uncomfortable with the Somali-American presence that they would not return — a shopping mall, a community housing center and Beaver Island Trail, a hiking area that borders the Mississippi River.

“They were just —” she said, searching for the words to describe the offending behavior of the Somali-Americans. “They were just walking around.”
I think the concept she's looking for is....existing.

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/20/u...ees-trump.html
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-20-2019 , 06:03 PM
lol I lived next to some Somalis once. Super nice and friendly. Basically everyone is.

****ing xenophobes.
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-21-2019 , 06:29 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kelhus999
Not really. You have 27000 posts on this forums. How many of them do you think show empathy towards people you perceive as out group (conservatives) How many of your posts are extremely antagonistic towards conservatives. I think the ratio is extremely disparate, much more so than actual political or personal differences would warrant. That is becauSe deciding who is and who isn’t deserving of empathy is pretty much solely determined by identity.



Spoiler:
...of course the difference is, you can take that stupid hat off any time you want to...
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-21-2019 , 06:58 AM
Like srsly I wouldn't post uTubz if the guy wasn't good and the guy is scary good.


What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-21-2019 , 07:20 AM
It's a bit dubious.We don't elect em and they aren't 'unaccountable men with guns' but minorities still have a very healthy mistrust of the police. Nothing like as bad as 'merica but that's in large part down to improvements made via a parliamentary democracy.

Nice beard through.
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote
06-21-2019 , 07:30 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by FlyWf
I don't think you're gonna like what's behind door number 2, then. Here's a hint: it isn't "agreeing with you"

Heh.


Kelhus, here's the first time I "punched a nazi":


Quote:
I stand before the Galactic High Court Of Social Justice Warring.

So, back in the day, when I was about 13-14, I was playing basketball with some kids in my grandmother's neighborhood, in an alley. I put my wallet and keys and stuff on the ground. My wallet fell open. One of the kids asked me, with a look of disgust, and I quote, "Ugh, why do have all these picture of n****rs in your wallet?" 1 of the pictures happened to be my GF. So, I paused, then shoved him into the garage, then forearm checked him in the throat and held him there whilst asking, "Why do I have what mother****er?" He didn't utter a peep. After about 30secs I let him go and he ran off like a coward.

The question is, am I a SJW or no?
https://forumserver.twoplustwo.com/s...6&postcount=59
What is "identity politics"? (also: Orwell, 1984, and socialism) Quote

      
m