Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Police brutality and police reform (US) Police brutality and police reform (US)

09-03-2020 , 08:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GodgersWOAT
Finally, an actual straw man!
No, what my post states is that they need to be prepared to use force if needed, i.e., trained. What do you think happens when untrained people are in a situation in which violence is likely to occur??
You are wrong. That is the problem with police right now. They approach every single situation with the desire to implement aggressive force.

If 99.999% of interactions do not require aggressive violence, that shouldn’t be the first, second, third, fourth, or fifth option.

The reality is police create their own worst case scenarios by escalating situations with their aggressiveness and violence.
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-03-2020 , 08:52 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GodgersWOAT
Pray tell, what’s the difference between decriminalizing and legalizing as it pertains to drug users’ actual behavior?
This should help
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-03-2020 , 08:52 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by markksman
You are wrong. That is the problem with police right now. They approach every single situation with the desire to implement aggressive force.

If 99.999% of interactions do not require aggressive violence, that shouldn’t be the first, second, third, fourth, or fifth option.

The reality is police create their own worst case scenarios by escalating situations with their aggressiveness and violence.
If what you say is true there would be hundreds of George Floyd cases every day.
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-03-2020 , 08:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GodgersWOAT
A massive majority of cases is what like 90%?

So thousands of monthly interactions between social workers untrained in the use of force and violent folks (gangs, domestic abusers, people on meth) will occur, and you’re cool with it? K bro.
Again, why do you think police are better trained or more experienced in dealing with people who are high.

You simply do not understand the discussion and are ignorant about so much you think the police hammer is the first best solution always.

No not 90%. If 10% of police interactions are violent (lol) then police are responsible for escalating 99% of that 10%.

Police are pretty much the worst people to confront someone who is high.
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-03-2020 , 08:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GodgersWOAT
Pray tell, what’s the difference between decriminalizing and legalizing as it pertains to drug users’ actual behavior?

If anything

https://www.economist.com/leaders/20...nt?frsc=dg%7Ca

it seems like half measures only empower the bad guys without affecting end user behavior for substances already in wide use and easily available.
Uhh, that is basically what the original article was addressing by looking at the impact of the change in Portugal.

To summarise though, since drug use was decriminalised in 2001 (while distribution and such was still illegal) overall drug use has declined, HIV/Hepatitis and other illnesses associated with injecting drugs has drastically declined, and drug related crime has declined. It's important to note that the policy change also included significant improvements to social welfare provisions and a focus on drugs as a health problem rather than a crime problem but it is a very good case study of how the issue can be handled without draconian policing.

If you're genuinely interested and not just trying to score points then there is a very well referenced report on the impacts of the changes in Portugal available here https://transformdrugs.org/wp-conten...Portugal_0.pdf
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-03-2020 , 09:06 PM
Interesting read.

It’s still tangential to the point: Wookie claims that we won’t need to investigate violent drug gangs if we adopt Portuguese model. That doesn’t follow. If drugs are still illegal then violent drug gangs will continue to peddle them and violence will result and someone will need to address that. It won’t be social workers.
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-03-2020 , 09:07 PM
Also, it looks like the article didn’t really address violent crime rates? Except to note that robberies went up?
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-03-2020 , 09:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GodgersWOAT
If what you say is true there would be hundreds of George Floyd cases every day.
Oh really? And why is that?

You think every time the police escalate a situation it results in a shooting murder of a civilian?

You simply are not on the same playing field of understanding here. It seems like a waste of typing to have to keep explaining every single thing to you so you can discuss it.

There are a myriad of results that happen due to police aggressiveness and escalation. An encounter that could have ended in a polite discussion gets pushed by police until they end up arresting the person for resisting.

Quote:
Police officers often use the charge of “resisting arrest” to criminalize black people who try to defend themselves from brutal, punitive, and often illegal police actions. They also do so to justify the violence it takes to compel compliance—even if that violence results in taking a life. The Minneapolis officers who killed George Floyd, for example, claimed that he refused to get into the squad car when ordered to do so. But Floyd was claustrophobic. He knew that if the officers claimed he was resisting arrest, they could use violence to force him into the car. He tried to save his life by telling the officers that he was not resisting arrest, that he was claustrophobic. Instead, armed officers pinned him to the ground, and Derek Chauvin killed him.

Today, resisting arrest typically only counts as lawful self-defense when one is protecting oneself against excessive force. In practice, that is the moment when it is already impossible for individuals to protect themselves.
http://bostonreview.net/race-law-jus...sisting-arrest

Resisting is another one size fits all tool for police. They approach almost every interaction with civilians with aggressiveness in hopes of getting it into a resisting situation where the rules shift into their favor. This is SOP for law enforcement.

Quote:
Understanding how this came to be helps to shed light on the wider repression of black self-defense in the face of policing as an activity of racial social control. For instance, a New York Times article revealed that between 2009 and 2013 in Greensboro, North Carolina, police charged 836 black people (but only 209 white people) with “resisting, delaying, or obstructing” as their only charge.
White or black, nobody should ever just be charged with resisting arrest. It does not even make sense and should be entirely illegal.

Quote:
NBC 7 Investigates looked at seven years of police data and found out San Diego police are arresting one group of people for this misdemeanor offense more often than others.

The data shows blacks are 10 times more likely than whites to be arrested for resisting, delaying, or obstructing a police officer.

Quote:
NYPD officers appear to be far more likely to file resisting arrest charges against black suspects than white suspects — with dramatic differences in some parts of the city, according to a WNYC Data News analysis of court records.

Law enforcement experts say resisting arrest charges are a strong indicator that an arrest went bad and a cop had to use force. So, with the death of Eric Garner over the summer during an arrest for selling loose cigarettes, WNYC's Data News team analyzed court records to look at who gets charged with resisting arrest.

The data shows that when blacks and whites are arrested for some of the most commonly charged crimes in New York City, blacks are far more likely to also be charged with resisting arrest.
Quote:
That means a black defendant in a misdemeanor drug possession case is 85.4% more likely to get charged with resisting arrest than a white defendant.
Those dang uppity blacks!

https://www.wnyc.org/story/resisting...t-black-white/
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-03-2020 , 09:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GodgersWOAT
Interesting read.

It’s still tangential to the point: Wookie claims that we won’t need to investigate violent drug gangs if we adopt Portuguese model. That doesn’t follow. If drugs are still illegal then violent drug gangs will continue to peddle them and violence will result and someone will need to address that. It won’t be social workers.
thats why I am for full legalization. as a capitalist, I prefer my violent gangs to be reputable corporations.
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-03-2020 , 09:56 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GodgersWOAT
Interesting read.

It’s still tangential to the point: Wookie claims that we won’t need to investigate violent drug gangs if we adopt Portuguese model. That doesn’t follow. If drugs are still illegal then violent drug gangs will continue to peddle them and violence will result and someone will need to address that. It won’t be social workers.
Why aren't they a problem in Portugal?
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-03-2020 , 10:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by MrWookie
Why aren't they a problem in Portugal?
Looks like Wild’s article, ostensibly favoring Portugal’s policy against naysayers, concedes that homicides went up sharply in the years after the decriminalization was implemented.

Why are you so bad at knowing the facts?
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-03-2020 , 10:25 PM
Guy in here saying resisting arrest shouldn’t be illegal.

Hahaohwow.

Also, maybe people are charged with resisting arrest more because they, stay with me here, resist arrest more!
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-04-2020 , 12:01 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GodgersWOAT
Looks like Wild’s article, ostensibly favoring Portugal’s policy against naysayers, concedes that homicides went up sharply in the years after the decriminalization was implemented.

Why are you so bad at knowing the facts?
Why are you so bent on misrepresenting everything? They also went back down, and it's not clear the rise was due to the drug policy change.

Quote:
A widely repeated claim is that, as a result of Portugal’s decriminalisation policy, drug-related homicides increased 40% between 2001 and 2006.29 30 But this claim is based on a misrepresentation of the evidence. The 40% increase (from 105 to 148) was for all homicides, defined as any ‘intentional killing of a person, including murder, manslaughter, euthanasia and infanticide’31 – they were not ‘drug-related’. In fact, there are no data collected for drug-related homicides.

This claim stems from the 2009 World Drug Report, in which the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime speculated that the increase in homicides ‘might be related to [drug] trafficking.’32However, neither the UNODC nor anyone else has proposed a causal mechanism by which the decriminalisation policy could have produced this rise, and given that the policy did not include any changes to how drug trafficking offences were dealt with, the possibility of such a link seems highly implausible. Furthermore, Portugal’s homicide rate has since declined to roughly what it was in 2002.
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-04-2020 , 12:47 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
less than innocent black kids that get murdered by police for sure. also, I wont cry for them as I feel the same way about them as lagtight feels about blm. or joe6pack feels about anyone on the left. we all know that both of those people are quite happy when black people and protesters are murdered and jailed and otherwise get their lives totally ****ed up.

I cant use the same language as Schlitz but I will just say that his celebration of the violence against protesters is exactly how I feel about your side.
Oh really? Care to cite a post of mine where I celebrate the deaths of black people or protesters. Otherwise kindly stfu.

Interesting to see you actually admit that you would celebrate violence against Trump[ supporters. No doubt you were happy when that Trump supporter got murdered in Portland. Pretty disgusting but not surprising coming from the likes of you.
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-04-2020 , 01:23 AM
If you really want to end drug violence, just legalize all drugs completely. Then Bayer can go back to selling heroin and the street gangs will find themselves unemployed and in need of a new line of work.
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-04-2020 , 08:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by joe6pack
Oh really? Care to cite a post of mine where I celebrate the deaths of black people or protesters. Otherwise kindly stfu.

Interesting to see you actually admit that you would celebrate violence against Trump[ supporters. No doubt you were happy when that Trump supporter got murdered in Portland. Pretty disgusting but not surprising coming from the likes of you.
I learned from you Dad
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-04-2020 , 08:07 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PokerPlayingGamble
If you really want to end drug violence, just legalize all drugs completely. Then Bayer can go back to selling heroin and the street gangs will find themselves unemployed and in need of a new line of work.
then how would the CIA make money? and how would we be able to lock up hundreds of thousands of people so that private prisons make money?
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-04-2020 , 09:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GodgersWOAT
Thank you for admitting you’re for legalization of all drugs.

Or is this more of your LOTS OF PEOPLE ARE SAYING garbage that you don’t actually ascribe to??
Nancy? Nancy is that you?
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-04-2020 , 10:02 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GodgersWOAT
Guy in here saying resisting arrest shouldn’t be illegal.

Hahaohwow.

Also, maybe people are charged with resisting arrest more because they, stay with me here, resist arrest more!
You are a racist.

Plus your first sentence is total gibberish.

If they are ONLY charged with resisting arrest what arrest were they resisting. I know logic, thoughtfulness, compassion, and understanding are not your forte but try to at least pretend you don’t qualify to be a police officer.
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-04-2020 , 10:28 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor
I learned from you Dad
Hey, I was browsing through and for some reason I was reminded that Hillary is still free.

I thought the law and order conservatives were going to lock her up.

All talk, no action. What a let down.
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-04-2020 , 12:40 PM
Everyone is a racist, to some degree.

Only actual racists wouldn’t realize that and would point the finger with such self-congratulation.
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-04-2020 , 12:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GodgersWOAT
Everyone is a racist, to some degree.

Only actual racists wouldn’t realize that and would point the finger with such self-congratulation.
I agree with this. We all favor our own and distrust strangers. It starts with family and goes down the line. It's natural instincts.
The big difference is, some of us act out on that racism. Even if it's just agreeing with or condoning repressive and violent behavior towards people that are different than us.
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-04-2020 , 01:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GodgersWOAT
Everyone is a racist, to some degree.

Only actual racists wouldn’t realize that and would point the finger with such self-congratulation.
Racism being common doesn't mean we have to accept or normalize it, or set our policies in a way that builds it in. Generally, we should organize society around our highest principles, not our basest instincts.
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-04-2020 , 02:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by GodgersWOAT
Everyone is a racist, to some degree.

Only actual racists wouldn’t realize that and would point the finger with such self-congratulation.
I took an anti-racism class in college (luckily it was mandatory) and literally the first thing we discussed was that to be anti-racist it's necessary to acknowledge our own internal biases. But what you seem to be implying is that it's fine for you to say and do racist things because we all have these biases, so who cares. Going to have to disagree with that.

I do agree with your point that usually the people who have to keep saying they aren't racist or claiming racism isn't a real problem tend to be the most racist.
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote
09-04-2020 , 02:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by tgiggity
I took an anti-racism class in college (luckily it was mandatory) and literally the first thing we discussed was that to be anti-racist it's necessary to acknowledge our own internal biases. But what you seem to be implying is that it's fine for you to say and do racist things because we all have these biases, so who cares. Going to have to disagree with that.

I do agree with your point that usually the people who have to keep saying they aren't racist or claiming racism isn't a real problem tend to be the most racist.
This. I am always analyzing my actions, behaviors and words to see how biases might be impacting the way I interact with people and the world.

GodgersWOAT is “F it man, everyone is racist bro n word n word n word!”

To clarify GodgersWOAT you are fully racist, with no care or consideration for your bigotry or how it impacts others,
Police brutality and police reform (US) Quote

      
m