Quote:
Originally Posted by Dunyain
If the KKK had been democratically elected to rule all the southern states on a platform of destroying the Northern states, was supplied heavy weaponry by outside actors for the purpose of attacking the North, and used such weapons to periodically attack the North over 20 years, I am pretty confident the strategy after 20 years of this wouldn't be "moderation"
It's not a perfect analogy. But certainly, many open racists and sympathizers were elected to office, like George Wallace.
If you voted for George Wallace, would it be morally reasonable to execute your entire family and blow up the nearest hospital?
To state the obvious, this is an analogy that bends over backwards to be fair to Isreal. For example, blacks had to actually live under the rule of people like George Wallace as second class citizens. To this day, Southern states provide minimal assistance to the poor, since many are black, and this causes people to die. Israelis live in their own, prosperous country.
The point is, "there are bad people who would like to harm me and sometimes they do," even if it is true, is not a good reason for the large scale masacre of civilians, blowing up hospitals, assassinations and all the other stuff Israel is doing.