Quote:
Originally Posted by microbet
Yes, it is. The point is not that Nazis are especially bad, which of course they are, but that you are saying, hey, you know those people who literally killed your Great-Uncle and Aunt? When a black person is being cruel to an employee, you don't call them Simon Legree unless you are literally asking them, and any other black person who overhears it, to fight you. There are plenty of other bad people to be compared to. Stalin and Mao come to mind, but if you don't want to dis communists, there's still South Africa or USA killing Native Americans.
I don't mind dissing Stalin, but that would be a poor comparison imo. Crushing dissent isn't the aim in Gaza, just a determination to eradicate Gazans under the pretext that they might have been in a similar area to someone who may or may not have been in Hamas.
Mao doesn't work either.
Native American genocide was too long ago to upset people now and some probably even quietly think it was a good thing because they're rich as a result of it. Same with Maoris and Aboriginals.
Apartheid sort of describes the separation under duress and restriction of rights but not the months of rocket attacks and the decades of sheling, shooting and killing before October.
Maybe there's no suitable analogy.
Last edited by jalfrezi; 05-15-2024 at 04:52 PM.