Quote:
Originally Posted by VPNnewb
#1 A mechanical device is 100% fair to every player
Quote:
Originally Posted by Josem
That's obviously false. Some mechanical devices might be fair. Some mechanical devices might not be fair.
To take a common example, the shuffling machines used in most casinos do just 3 riffle shuffles. That's been proven to not give truly random results - for a 52 card deck, you need 8 or 9 shuffles to give true randomisation. See here for the proof for this: http://mathworld.wolfram.com/RiffleShuffle.html
I am happy with 3 riffles. I would take one riffle live over your RNG any day! I would be more satisfied if they just collected the cards and then cut the deck instead of using your RNG. WHY? Because even though that wouldn't be completley random, it is not picking who should win the hand and then deal certain cards to make that happen like your RNG was desinged to do. Yea, that's what I think your RNG does and there is nothing you can say or show me to prove that it doesn't. I would just have to trust everyone who deals with the RNG.
Quote:
Originally Posted by VPNnewb
#2 It's truly random, unpredictable, and has no patterns
Quote:
Originally Posted by Josem
You only believe that because the site said so.
As explained above, some mechanical devices must not be random. Some mechanical devices are random.
The only reason you believe that some particular mechanical device is random is because someone told you that.
That's no better than the confidence you get from the electronic shuffling used by the major online poker sites.
Also, because the Real Deal shuffle only mechanically shuffled the cards once for every X hands (I think it was 2,000 or something, I'm not sure) there must also be a relationship between those X hands.
Maybe random isn't the word I should be using since you think your RNG is better because it riffles so many times or whatever it does... I should've said it is fair and honest. The machine and system can not pick certain cards to be dealt and doesn't pick certain players to win on certain hands. I don't care how many times your RNG riffles, shuffles and whatever, if it has the ability to deal certain cards or choose a player to win, then it is not fair and honest. And knowing actual objects were being shuffled and having a reputable 3rd party company verify that any single hand was fair gives me a lot more confidence then the poker sites word.
Quote:
Originally Posted by VPNnewb
#3 It can be proven that your hand came from that mechanical shuffle and was fair and random. The system I'm talking about does a 100% fair and random shuffle, then it rearranges(shuffles) the ORDER of that first deck to create many more decks. It can not rig hands because you can't fix a deck when you are rearranging cards as if they were face down. And it can all be traced back to digital and video records by a third party security company.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Josem
I don't see why this proof is any greater than the proof that your hand dealt on an electronic device came from that electronic device.
It uses real cards, can be verified that the algorithm used for your deck was the correct one and traced back to the start to see that nothing was set up. How is that not more proof then an RNG hand that can't be audited and can't even be proven if somebody set the hand up or not? You could change the entire code to the RNG over night and players wouldn't know. I'm not saying you guys set up hands, but the RNG picks players to win because of the way it was designed. I'm wrong right? Well you can't prove it. Show your entire code and that still wouldn't mean it's gonna be fair when I play.
Quote:
Originally Posted by VPNnewb
#4 When using an RNG all you are doing is taking the sites word for it that its fair. The current "proof" that it's not rigged is not enough for many people.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Josem
The same applies to a mechanical device.
I would be taking the sites word for it, but I know this guy and I trust him, his system, and his team.And if that's not good enough, I can get a third party company to come in and give me their word too. Who the hell works on your RNG???
Quote:
Originally Posted by VPNnewb
#5 RNG can easily be manipulated or programed whatever way they want
Quote:
Originally Posted by Josem
Just as a mechanical device can be.
Yea, it could be manipulated, that's why this system has an option for the players to cut the deck which would prevent anybody setting up the deck. If you don't think the cut was real then you can have a third party company audit the hand... The only way to cheat would be to steal the data to get the holes cards just like you would on any site.
Quote:
Originally Posted by VPNnewb
#6 There is no proof whatsoever that a specific RNG hand was 100% fair. You just have to believe it was.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Josem
The same thing applies to a mechanical shuffling device.
Bull ****. Knowing your hand was based on physical, shuffled objects is way more proof that the hand was fair, but you also get to cut the deck and the hand can be audited.
Quote:
Originally Posted by VPNnewb
The site I used to play is the best at everything they did, but there is a serious trust issue because of their RNG which I strongly believe is not random. And in an industry where such a large % are losing players, you are gonna have a lot of people who feel the same, and will not trust the site and stay away.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Josem
Sure, but the fact that a lot of people believe something doesn't make it true. There are a chunk of people in the world who believe that if you blow yourself up and kill a heap of Jews that you'll go to heaven and have a heap of virgins to pleasure you eternally. Simply because they believe it it doesn't become true.
I know it doesn't matter if everybody thinks it's rigged, because most of them are probably just losing players and don't understand poker. I don't care what they say because of that, and I don't care what are these grinders say either. They have no say in this. They play a ton of tables and don't even watch the hands and players and then just look at the stats later(which don't prove anything) and they say, "oh the odds are right, it's fair!". They just fold and go on to the next table. I've always played one table and watch the cards and who wins the pots and I always see a bunch of bull ****. It's not real poker. And I am talking about one site. I have not played enough on other sites to even comment on them except for that I wouldn't trust them.
You set me up. You're trying to pick me apart and made it hard for me to quote ur post...
By the way... I don't wanna argue in this thread. There is nothing I can say to change your mind and nothing you can say to change mine, so this might be pointless. I just don't trust offshore sites using RNGs and can't take online poker seriously unless they regulate it in the U.S. or my state and design their own RNG.
Last edited by VPNnewb; 02-19-2011 at 05:52 PM.