Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Game of Thrones TV Thread - ***NO BOOKREADERS*** Game of Thrones TV Thread - ***NO BOOKREADERS***

05-23-2016 , 12:17 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by plzd0nate
Rewatch the ending. Bran controls holdor but bran doesn't do or say anything to holdor in the past or tell him to ever hold the door, he's just watching. It was the girl saying to hold the door. Holdor shouldn't be able to hear the girl saying that in the past so there is no reason holdor should be saying it
Present Bran can hear the girl. Past Bran briefly warged into past Hodor (you see his eyes). Bran was the connection. Her message got locked into his brain.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Cotton Hill
It involves a time loop paradox, it's not supposed to be able to make sense. It's been done in a ton of different movies and tv shows, usually more sci/fi based, but still, common trope.
It does make sense. It wasn't a paradox it was a causality loop. These are different things.
05-23-2016 , 12:19 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lattimer
Present Bran can hear the girl. Past Bran briefly warged into past Hodor (you see his eyes). Bran was the connection. Her message got locked into his brain.


So you are saying the girl is indirectly controlling bran who is then indirectly control holdor in the past?..... I mean. I guess?
05-23-2016 , 12:20 AM
no I explained that wrong
05-23-2016 , 12:22 AM
Why do some of the children look like actual children with their eyebrows burned off and others look like cat-people?
05-23-2016 , 12:22 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cotton Hill
It involves a time loop paradox, it's not supposed to be able to make sense. It's been done in a ton of different movies and tv shows, usually more sci/fi based, but still, common trope.

I think the implication was that Brann was worging into his mind, implanting "hold the door" so hard it basically broke his brain, he didn't have to say it was happening all mental like.
yeah, i think there was a moment where you see that Bran can hear Meera even though he's in the past. he shows a sign of recognition of what she's saying. and then we see someone warg into present-day Hodor and he starts moving (i think)? but we know that Bran can interact with the visions, so somehow it seems like maybe because he is warged into present-day Hodor while also present in a vision with past Hodor, that it creates a loop and short-circuits past Hodor. or something.
05-23-2016 , 12:23 AM
Bran can warg into two people at once now

I assumed they just thought the army would take longer than five minutes to arrive.
05-23-2016 , 12:28 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lattimer
So if the children created the whitewalkers, why are the whitewalkers trying to kill them?
it's symbolism. they were mad
05-23-2016 , 12:29 AM
Watching scene now. Bran never warged into present Hodor. I think it's what Cotton said. Bran did it without even realizing because he was subconsciously hearing the girl saying it.
05-23-2016 , 12:34 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by FishAndChipss
There are only two possibilities, both of which deserve merit and are not about "luck."

1) GRRM planned the character of Wylis/Hodor around this incident/tragedy which would affect his mental state the way it did, and crafted the name according to the incident

2) GRMM thought of this character who had all the features that Hodor did, and came up with "Hodor" as an appropriate name for him. Then, he decided to come up with a backstory in his universe for how and why this character came to be, and that's when he decided it was because of a warging event gone wrong.

Either way, super well done.
until he says otherwise in an interview, I"m going with #2
05-23-2016 , 12:36 AM
Bran warged into Hodor via young Willis because his conscious was still in the past. This brought Willis into the "future" and he was looking through the eyes of his future self while being controlled by Bran. He watches his own death and "holds the door"

This traumatizes him and he lives the rest of his life presumably knowing exactly how he will die. It's probably why Hodor freaked out in the past when Bran warged into him, because he thought it might have been his time to die. Hell, he freaked out and froze whenever there was any trouble brewing. He knew all along, he just didn't know when. God damnit =(

That's why Hodor has always been "Hodor". Everything is linear from his perspective, Bran is jumping back and forth through time but we have already seen all of the consequences of his actions (because they were in the past). Bran could be the Lord of the Light for example.

Last edited by beansroast01; 05-23-2016 at 12:52 AM.
05-23-2016 , 12:41 AM
That final seen was great.
05-23-2016 , 12:44 AM
phenomenal episode, top 5 death in television history.
05-23-2016 , 12:46 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by hair loss at 19_
until he says otherwise in an interview, I"m going with #2
i don't think we are considering the "inside the episode" materials spoilers, but just in case:

Spoiler:
in the post-show segment for this episode the show-runners claim that GRRM had this planned out all along. which is really the only plausible explanation imo.
05-23-2016 , 12:53 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ham on rye
i don't think we are considering the "inside the episode" materials spoilers, but just in case:

Spoiler:
in the post-show segment for this episode the show-runners claim that GRRM had this planned out all along. which is really the only plausible explanation imo.
Spoiler:
Yes I watched that, thats how we know it was GRRM's idea. I'm saying I doubt he had this planned 20 years ago when he created Hodor
05-23-2016 , 12:56 AM
Rip direwolf, rip Wyllis.

And to you mothe****ers trying to dissect Hodor, how about we just know told how the whitewalkers came to be, the ****ing Bloodraven died, and Bran now is the lock to mayyybe somehow stopping the whitewalkers.

So enough w the dissecting and enjoy. Or just stop watching, if you are somehow unsatisfied.
05-23-2016 , 12:58 AM
And how can you not think Hodor was planned out from the start is beyond me.

Thats like saying the whitewalkers being made by the children wasnt planned from the start, when now that **** makes perfect ****ing sense.
05-23-2016 , 01:00 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 4thstreetpete
phenomenal episode, top 5 death in television history.

This has to be the top one
05-23-2016 , 01:00 AM
And i keep cursing cuz thats all ive done since i saw the episode 30 mins ago. **** that was epic tv. Im a bookreader but damn that episode was the tits, insanely enjoyable.
05-23-2016 , 01:08 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by King_of_NYC
Sansa deserves to die
wtf, her character is better than ever right now. what is wrong with you?

Wow, what an episode. I had a moment where I was losing my faith in this show but holy **** they have really delivered in the past couple episodes.

Hodor!
05-23-2016 , 01:08 AM
Bran had to fly too close to the sun. Seems like there was a lot of learning left on the table.

Leaf went out like a G. So did the big guy.
05-23-2016 , 01:15 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Leo Getz
Bran had to fly too close to the sun. Seems like there was a lot of learning left on the table.
Knowing that while in a "vision/flashback" you shouldn't be touched by the Night King unless you want to suffer immediate and utterly horrible danger seems like a piece of info that Mr. Three-Eyed Raven should have clued Bran in on.
05-23-2016 , 01:17 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by imjosh
Bran warged into Hodor via young Willis because his conscious was still in the past. This brought Willis into the "future" and he was looking through the eyes of his future self while being controlled by Bran. He watches his own death and "holds the door"

This traumatizes him and he lives the rest of his life presumably knowing exactly how he will die. It's probably why Hodor freaked out in the past when Bran warged into him, because he thought it might have been his time to die. Hell, he freaked out and froze whenever there was any trouble brewing. He knew all along, he just didn't know when. God damnit =(

That's why Hodor has always been "Hodor". Everything is linear from his perspective, Bran is jumping back and forth through time but we have already seen all of the consequences of his actions (because they were in the past). Bran could be the Lord of the Light for example.

Really good analysis. I was thinking it was more the control of Hodor because of the previous episode where Bran controlled him (if I'm remembering correctly) but if its just a vision of how he dies that would make sense.
05-23-2016 , 02:40 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jihad2
I'm just going to give GRRM the benefit on this one. I don't think there's anything he's done that could leave one to believe that "HOldDOoR" was an accident. Fkn genius. There's a hundred interviews of him being aske d abut Hodor and him just casually playing it off.

Is it okay to refer to him as our lifetimes Tolkien? Better? The world-building is starting to unfold as incredible. I only imagine what's next....
watching arya watch that street theater performance gave me a great appreciation for the worldbuilding
05-23-2016 , 03:05 AM




LOST.gif
05-23-2016 , 03:19 AM
1. Arya just ****ing die already. God your character has taken an epic 1.5 season nose dive! GOAT episode, and even still all you manage to do is get your ass beaten with a stick for like the 19th time.

Someone give me my 6 minutes back.

2. Ban the guy who spoilered Hodor. Who does that?

      
m