Quote:
Originally Posted by JimHalpert
1. 49ers draft Rodgers like initially thought and Alex Smith falls to Green Bay. Rodgers is thrown behind a garbage OLine instantly, rifles through multiple OC's in his first few years. Smith sits behind and learns from Favre. What are each considered today?
I'm not sure that anything was ever actually learned from Favre. By all accounts Favre was selfish and just froze Rodgers out, saying he had no interest in mentoring his eventual replacement, all while doing a public dog-and-pony show each offseason where he would entertain retirement.
If anyone thinks I'm hard on Rodgers, my contempt for Favre was considerably greater. It's not even an anti-Packer thing at its foundation; when the Packers finally told Favre to go away, I actually decided I liked them, and really hoped that Rodgers would just shatter everything that Favre ever did, because **** Brett Favre. Fast forward a bit of time until I went, "Ah, this one's a douchebag too." But I would create a glowing shrine in my home to Rodgers before I would ever say anything nice about Favre.
So anyway, I don't think that Alex Smith ends up any better in Green Bay, except that he has fewer years of toiling away in the hopeless organization that SF was until renowned social defect Jim Harbaugh came along and improved things for a bit.