I think there's a few acceptable picks in this spot. I think there are 6, maybe 7 second-tier guys who are all somewhat interchangeable but I'm pretty confident in saying that they are a clear cut above the third-tier talent, which is what I would've been stuck with at the 15th pick.
Anyway...my pick:
His in-ring skills are legendary, so I won't waste time talking about them.
I've always thought that Bret has been unfairly criticized for his mic skills. He might not be up there with the likes of the Rock or Stone Cold but he's had some tremendous promos both as a heel and face (which gives me some flexibility with my second-round pick in that I believe Bret could be 1-2 vs. a heel or face). One thing I always appreciate about his promos was that they had this honest, from-the-gut edge to them and you weren't sure if he was going totally off-script or not.
Some of my faves:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O-CaGfjoNjI
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s3tgUIyz1_c