Quote:
Originally Posted by kyleb
I have no idea why this is so difficult to grasp for most people. I do it in limit and no-limit games alike before pushing chips. It makes things very clear and eliminates any sort of confusion.
Eh, it avoids vocalization tells I guess. But if it carries a tiny chance of screwing up your bet, then how much is that tell worth? Better yet, learn to verbalize in a flat monotone or anything else consistent.
That said, "cross the line" is a moderately dumb house rule invented sometime in the past by people who didn't really get poker or didn't think through it very carefully. It lends itself to angles and other behavior that's still not in the spirit of poker. So am I allowed to feint with a stack of chips as long as I don't cross the line? Can I insist my opponent's huge bet stand if I have the nuts, yet forget to point it out if I want to call a smaller bet?
And please don't say, "Well, you should know the house rules before you sit down!" Of course it's good to know the rules, but that's beside the point.
Tracking the "Live Casino Poker" forum taught me that experienced floors/managers respect clear intent where at all possible. This is the best way to protect those who are less experienced. If someone holds out a stack of red to cut off $15 so quickly the next person can't give a tell, then it's preposterous to say ruling it a $100 is respectful intent. Clearly it's the opposite.
Sometimes intent isn't clear, but there it is. Respect the intent.