Quote:
Originally Posted by coffeeyay
Polycarpus
It feels silly to start a new bandwagon, but his posts are short, always reference other people's arguments, and jump onto bandwagons around votes 3-5 which just SCREAMS wolf to me. Hopefully i'll have time later tonight to do more detailed analysis, but maybe in the meantime someone can reread his posts and see if they see the same things.
Feel free to start another bandwagon, and why not, mine, lol
If you want my reply to above accusations: Yes my posts are short. And "always" referring to other peoples arguments? Lol dude, I have two posts. (not counting my question about bold unvotes)
About my first post: It was short indeed. I had to leave and wasn't sure when I'd get back, and if I'd have the time to get back online. So I needed to be short, and voted for the only one were I could see some arguments at that time. Otherwise I might not have been able to vote. When I got back home, I reread everything, undid my first vote, and voted for you.
My analysis for now:
* Coffeeyay: His accusation at my address confirms my suspicion. Not because it's about me, but because his arguments don't seem to make much sense. I think I made my intentions clear in my first post, and yet he uses this against me. And he makes some "analysis" about all my posts, while it's actually only 2 posts. Plus he's not analyzing further himself, but pushing others to do so. A tactic wolfs like to use if I'm not mistaken. They want to kill a villager, but hope others come up with the reason why they should be killed. He's my nr 1 suspect and my vote atm.
* Yaqh and mers: Give me a villagery impression so far. Decent analysis and no-nonsense.
* filthyvermin: have to think this one over
* raised-by-jews: There's probably another explanation for this, but I expected him to be very active here. At least, if he's a villager. As a wolf it's better to stay low profile. Could of course be a schedule thing as well, too early to call this a "suspicion". Maybe this argument counts for others as well, but there are few I know well, so I don't know who's normally active in topics like this one.