Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Big Blind "opens" out of turn - how should this situation be handled? Big Blind "opens" out of turn - how should this situation be handled?

07-26-2023 , 06:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by javi
You're getting 50% more money in the pot. Why do you think people raise big at LLSNL? Because people will call. I once ran a little experiment whereby my objective was to ensure all the money got in by the turn. To do this I'd open 20BB's, cbet pot or maybe 1.2x pot and then just jam turn. For the most part opponent ranges didnt adjust. If they had 77 or A4s they were in preflop. Many live players dont even consider preflop to be relevant, to them nothing matters until you see a flop. If you have a high degree of certainty your opponent will call a 20BB PFR and you look down at AA you'd be a fool not to raise 20BB's. You can raise 3x all you want, you're just leaving money on the table, and making the hands slightly more difficult to play multiway.

2 sides to this debate.
  • You're OOP and want to keep the pot small - raise small
  • You're OOP and want to reduce your opponents positional advantage and wider calling ranges - raise big

Personally I feel raising larger penalizes your opponent greater and therefore that is the the most +EV play. Since our EP range should be tighter we arent as concerned with the pot being big because we'll have a big hand.
All of this.

I play in a few different rooms locally. I don't see winning players opening to $10, unless the table is just super-nitty. And in that case, most good players will switch tables. If the table is just a little nitty, maybe we lower our open to $12, just until people loosen up.

Straddle a few hands, show one bluff, people will call a $15 open soon enough.

I see online players, mostly kids, coming in and opening to $9, and it's laughable. People are running over from other tables to call a $9 raise.

I must have a liar's face. I could open one or occasionally two hands per orbit, and people still don't believe I have anything. I've been in games where I had to raise my open to $20 or more just to keep the number of callers under 3.

The player pool at 1/3 is just so loose pre-flop, and so bad post-flop (making them harder to range), that the only way to beat the game is to find the open size that limits the pot to just 2 or 3 players, tops.

I used to vary my raise size based on position. I went back and forth about going bigger or smaller OOP vs IP.

I mostly stopped, because it just seems like most low-stakes players are pretty inelastic with their calling ranges. They call based on the strength of their hand, not position, or stack size, or how many players have already entered the pot.

I'll sometimes raise larger from late position, when I see the EP players don't like to limp-fold or will over-defend their blinds, but otherwise, I just use the same raise size whenever I'm opening, or the same basic formula whenever I'm 3B-ing.
Big Blind "opens" out of turn - how should this situation be handled? Quote
07-26-2023 , 07:15 PM
pretty good rule of thumb for "standard" raise sizes at parx is:

1/3: 5x
2/5: 4-5x
10/10: 3-4x

+1 on getting 8 callers at parx if you open for $10 at a 1/3
Big Blind "opens" out of turn - how should this situation be handled? Quote
07-26-2023 , 07:22 PM
Guys, I appreciate all the expertise being thrown at me in an effort to help, but that's not what I was looking for with this thread.

Don't want to sound like the OMC in the room, but I'd be willing to bet I've been playing NLHE longer than some folks here have had hair on their balls. I'm 51, been playing since college (that's over 30 years), semi-regularly for the last 20, and weekly for the last 2-3. I've read all the books and watch all the videos. All the 20-somethings in my circle of poker friends will attest that I can hang with the best players in the local 1/3 pool.

Trust me. I'm good without anyone here holding me down and forcing their advice into me.

Other than wishing I'd sized up on the turn or just jammed from up front on the river, I'm fine with all the decisions I made in this hand.

I'm 99% sure BB started the hand with $10 in front, and UTG1 didn't realize it until the action got back around to me, and that he apparently thought I was just screwing around when I 3B. The rest of the hand only makes sense if we understand what he knew or thought and what I definitely did not know pre-flop.

Just to sum up...

1. The dealer should make it clear to all players what happened if the BB started the hand with $10 out.

2. $15 opens at 1/3 are fine. Feel free to roll up to Parx on any Friday night and have a seat with me if you want to show me I'm wrong.

3. My range in this hand crushes UTG1's. My analysis is solid, to the extent I didn't realize he thought I was out of line when I 3B.

He has Jh6h. He's blocking JJ. My range has AK, AQ, A10, A5, at a minimum, plus probably 1 or 2 other AXs hands, one combo of JJ, and if UTG1 really thought I was 3B'ing light, I could also have one combo of 44.

Let me see here...[checks notes]...I have at least half a dozen hands that beat his and get played this way.

My river bluffs are basically just AA, KK, and QQ, which the vast majority of 1/3 players are going to check on the river, with this runout. No one at 1/3 is turning over-pairs into a bluff when the hand is played this way.

Even if he thinks I'm Doug Polk's idiot half-brother, I'm only bluffing with the combos containing a heart.

I wasn't bluffing. He shouldn't be there with JX of hearts, as played. I was very certain he had AhJx. I happened to be wrong. The vast majority of the time, when I bet that river, I'm going to have the nizzles, and if I don't, I'm bet-folding for thin value or just check-folding.

Thanks for playing along.
Big Blind "opens" out of turn - how should this situation be handled? Quote

      
m