Typical 1/2 live game. was sitting at a feeder table but just got moved to the main game. villain is incredibly loose-passive fish. i had seen him betting tiny with relatively big hands (roughly 10-20% of the pot) and fail to get max value.

Effective stack: 230

7way limped pot.

Hero (BB): J4dd

Flop: J54r

($14) SB checks, Hero bets 15, utg1 calls 15, folds, .. folds, Villain (late position) raises 30 to 45, folds,

action back to me...

Hero: 3bet 85 more to 130. utg1 folds. Villain thinks and calls.

($289) Turn: 6 completing rambo

Hero: bet 100 all-in.
Villain: time banks, calls.

----

Villain shows 55 for set of 5s. FML.

Did I play this wrong? It wasn't an auto b3b spot given villains tendencies. but i did it anyway.

Don't 3-bet flop against a passive opponent. He is almost never doing this just top pair. Just call raise then call turn and river.

i honestly thought 45 was his probable holding. when he was time banking the turn, i thought he had just a naked jack, so i was thinking "please call please call please call". finally he calls and i think im about to get paid only to find villain roll over the flop second nuts. i reasonably thought, given by 3bet sizing, that all sets would 4bet all-in given i had only 100 behind for turn shove. but of course he just calls. and so should have i. thanks.

As said above you can't really expect to get paid off by TP in this hand OTF so I'd probably flat the flop raise then c/r all in OTT for value.

To be clear you aren't getting away from this hand no matter what, but 3 betting the flop just folds out a lot of hands you could extract value from.