Quote:
Originally Posted by Gilmour
I respect alot of your posts ANL, but i have to say i disagree with you big time here.
Getting 5 callers when we raise it up is with AQ is NOT a good result at all. We are stucked to play totally fit or fold postflop and got zero room to manouver after the flop.
I am all about being like water and exploit whatever strategy our opponents deploys, and one way to do that is to raise bigger when our villains obviously dont have the ability to fold after limping in. If hero made it 35 here and got 2 callers instead of 5, we could have C-bet bluffed this flop and taken down the pot a healthy percantage of the time: rinse and repeat.
Not to forget how this will set up insanely proffitable dynamics when or if we start being hit by the deck: people are used to see us raising big and will start getting frustrated and loosening up their limp/calling ranges more and more.
A frustrated reg in a homegame i usually sit in once said to me in frustration/tilty moment when we got it allin pre when he had JJ and i had AA: "OMFG you ONLY play the nutz or what, i know it". And i coudnt resist responding:Yeah, and still you call my allin bet with jacks? And then i continued to talk inside my head, of course i play the nutz hard when people cant resist calling it off.
My point is: if people shows that they want to call off big raises and big bets- set them up and let them do just that.
This is VERY hard to quantify. I used to play low limit games in Virginia where you could only raise like $20 preflop (limp $5 or Max raise open to $20) and then pot limit postflop. The game was 10 handed. Most players played 350 to 600 behind. It was at a country club and all the players were rich and would see the flop with ANYTHING that resembled a hand. lol.
I won more per hour in this game over a 2 year period than my hourly at grinding 5-10. I just think if you adjust to the conditions, that more players seeing the flop with garbage ends up in higher EV ---but IF---IF---you adjust properly postflop.
Since most players (not necessarily anyone in particular) play a certain style and stick to it, getting lesser callers preflop is a must.
I had THIS conversation back in the day with David Sklansky at the Stardust Hotel. He convinced me that having the whole table call "could" end up giving us the highest winrate but one had to play a very good huge multiway pot game postflop.
I doubt this is worth the discussion since anyone can adjust their pre bets and create the environment they prefer anyhow.
Note: I used to try and guage my answer to what level i think the OP is on. I got into some issues doing this and thus now i just say what I do myself and why. Thats just me, and im sure that you make it work as how you see it as well.
Like T Angelo said. There IS a lot of grey in poker. Which is why top players can disagree and each player make it work within each players gameplan.