Quote:
Originally Posted by raconteur
I have a couple of suggestions for the smoother operation of the online share selling forum. Admittedly their primary purpose is to make my own life/participation easier, but anyway...
1) full disclosure
This was motivated by an experience I had on Sunday. I want to emphasise that Tourbound, the guy in question, is in no way to blame for the fact that I spent half an hour or so excitedly watching him climb the chip counts in the Warmup, only to double check the package details and see that I didnt have an interest :|. He also states that hes backed in his action selling posts, but without wanting to sound annoying, I dont think this goes far enough. I have a right to know if people Im buying action in are playing anything else, whether it be mtts, cash games, or Monopoly, during the period of the tournaments Im buying action in. I had shares in eight or nine people, and I remember having all their names pulled up on the stars search function simultaneously (very cool btw, compared to searching for people on ftp), only to see that more than one - Im being purposely vague because I dont remember the who or the what - were in several tournaments not mentioned in the package. Quite apart from the argument above, this is a pain for those who have shares in multiple people because we then have to track back to the thread(s) and check which tournaments we care about and which we dont. In Tourbounds case, its also relevant because if his backer wants all of his action in some events but doesnt mind him selling a package including some others, it doesnt take a genius to work out the reason why, and that significantly affects the value of the package as a whole. (since I singled him out, I feel I should reiterate that I dont think he did anything intentionally shady, but had I known he was selling action to some Sunday majors and not to others of equal or lower buyin, it wouldve factored into my decision on whether or not to buy a piece).
On a related point, for those of you who have multiple IDs on diff sites that are different from your 2p2 handle, and who dont already do this, it would be useful if you post those IDs in your rail threads as well as your action threads. Frequently those have drifted off the front page and finding them, especially when you have a whole bunch of shares and have to do it twenty times, becomes annoying.
Well, it does really stink that you singled me out in your "gripe" ... But I understand your concerns given what happened on that sunday... But seeing that I have bought plenty of shares of people, I think I have a pretty good understanding from both sides.. And my honest response to your "full disclosure" is that, most every package I have seen has been "fully disclosed":
As a seller, we post a list of tournaments, or tournament, that we wish to sell action to.. You (and me) the investor looks at that list, and the players "credentials" and make a decision on if that is a good investment or not.. The end.. In your case, i believe i sold action to 6 tournaments that day... Unless you expect a horse or any serious MTT to only play 6 tournaments on the biggest day of the week to play, you should only know, that horse will be playing other tournaments that day that weren't listed.. I would say that 25-45 tournaments on a sunday is a standard range for MTTrs.. I played 29 that specific sunday, and think the other 23 tournaments that were spread out throughout the day didn't have any "negative" affect of the value of your package..
The only concern I see as a investor is if, I purchase shares of a horse that has what looks like a "full schedule"... Then it comes a matter of what else he might play and how much, etc... But even then, It is up to ME the investor to bring these concerns up before I pull the trigger on the investment.