Open Side Menu Go to the Top

08-10-2015 , 09:28 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PartyGirlUK
True Detective Season 2:

Rotten Tomatoes: 65%
Metacritic: 61 (20 positive reviews, 21 mixed reviews, 0 negative reviews)

Suggest it's middling to good. Thoughts?
aren't most of those reviews based off the first 3 eps? (i believe reviewers were sent a 3 ep screener - so most were left hopeful and giving it the benefit of the doubt like us) :P
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness
$25m Guaranteed WPM on CoinPoker
Join the action now
Daily Rewards • Splash Pots • CoinRaces
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness
08-10-2015 , 09:34 AM
I'm sure this will get roundly shouted down in here, but for me:

Episodes 1 - 7 S1 >>> S2
Episode 8 S2 >>> S1

There. I said it.

Last edited by MarsMuzak; 08-10-2015 at 09:43 AM.
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 09:38 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JudgeHoldem
If everyone's dead does that woman still play guitar in the bar
lol
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 09:44 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by MarsMuzak
I'm sure this will get roundly shouted down in here, but for me:

S1 episodes 1 - 7 >>> S2
S2 episode 8 >>> S1

There. I said it.

I mean it's fine you think that, on matters of taste there can be no argument, etc.

But for me it is really hard to judge episode 8 independently just because I didn't care about the characters and didn't really understand their connection and motivations to the plot. Like if you cared about Frank and his wife or Ani and Velcro and wanted them to stick it to those evil cops then sure, maybe it was good. I don't know.

But the Vinci cops were really the only guys I where I actually understood what their motivations were. They were corrupt cops who wanted to keep doing corrupt stuff. I get it! Paul and Ani and Velcro and especially Frank I just either have no idea or don't care.
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 09:56 AM
So when Season 2 finished production and all the execs are watching it together as a final reviews. What do they say to each other? How good it is? Do they know they have a disaster on their hands? Do they realize how they totally miscast VV?
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 10:04 AM
True story, when VV notices he was dead, I looked out the couch and there I was... Apparently I had stopped moving way back around the first dumb shootout.
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 10:12 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by smk67
True story, when VV notices he was dead, I looked out the couch and there I was... Apparently I had stopped moving way back around the first dumb shootout.
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 10:40 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SenorKeeed
I mean it's fine you think that, on matters of taste there can be no argument, etc.

But for me it is really hard to judge episode 8 independently just because I didn't care about the characters and didn't really understand their connection and motivations to the plot. Like if you cared about Frank and his wife or Ani and Velcro and wanted them to stick it to those evil cops then sure, maybe it was good. I don't know.

But the Vinci cops were really the only guys I where I actually understood what their motivations were. They were corrupt cops who wanted to keep doing corrupt stuff. I get it! Paul and Ani and Velcro and especially Frank I just either have no idea or don't care.
You know, I found myself rooting for both Ray and Frank last night. I was interested to learn the results of the paternity test for Ray's son and was glad when they came back to be his. I can't for the life of me figure out why his character would think it is a good idea to ever get behind the wheel of his own car again, and assumed he sealed his own fate once he did. I was interested to see whether his final message to his son would deliver, although driving out of the city seemed like a pretty bad choice to make that work.

I wanted Frank to get away and meet his wife, although it felt unlikely he would make it. I couldn't figure out why he went suicidal over the suit, but I forgot about the diamonds in the pocket. Seems like he could have at least tried to sneak those before taking the suit off.

I wasn't really rooting for Ani and Ray to reunite per se, but I guess I was also rooting for her to escape. I guess I was just rooting for the underdogs. Of the main characters, she did fewer bad things than Ray and Frank, so maybe she deserved to survive over them, but on the other hand you could make a case that Paul was shown to do almost nothing bad over the season (unless I'm forgetting something) and he still got killed, so I guess "deserve" doesn't really have anything to do with it.

Will tune in for S3.
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 10:54 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by MarsMuzak
I can't for the life of me figure out why his character would think it is a good idea to ever get behind the wheel of his own car again, and assumed he sealed his own fate once he did. .
A hit squad is following you and you decide to drive to a remote place to be gunned down. Not a federal building or police HQ where you are safe.
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 10:57 AM
Well he is wanted for murder (I think?)
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 11:07 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Anzat
I assumed the diamonds were in the suit.
Quote:
Originally Posted by nunnehi
I forgot about that, yes, that's where he put them if I remember correctly. Seems like they might have known that too.
Gonna say the Mexicans did not know that as they left him dying in the desert with $3.5mm of diamonds he then used to plug his stab wound. Makes the whole suit thing... odd.
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 11:07 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by walkingzed
So his kid just randomly carries around the Police Retirement Plastic statue to PE?

and since when do kids at PE have a bench to play scrabble?

and velcoro just randomly knows he is at PE?

And the cop goons are just waiting for him?

THIS HAS TO BE SOME KIND OF LEVEL.
Beyond that - how loltastic was it that maybe the secret to Velcoro's son apparently being accepted by his peers is the confidence he got by carrying a police badge covered by a hunk of lucite the size of a softball? Sure - judgmental teens definitely would come around on a pudgy misfit who's carrying around an huge hunk of plastic wherever he goes....
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 11:13 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by walkingzed
So his kid just randomly carries around the Police Retirement Plastic statue to PE?

and since when do kids at PE have a bench to play scrabble?

and velcoro just randomly knows he is at PE?

And the cop goons are just waiting for him?

THIS HAS TO BE SOME KIND OF LEVEL.
That not the most loltastic part of this.

Velcoro parks his car a few blocks away from the the school and walks there. There must be many side streets like that around the school but somehow the bad guys are just at the right street. Of course this is the Lt who seems to know exactly where everyone is going to be at any time.

Also why was this a 90 minute finale? Just so we could have that ridiculous dialog with CM and RM in the bed and then the loltastic train station scene with VV? Those two scenes were the first 20 mins of the show.
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 11:15 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SenorKeeed
Well he is wanted for murder (I think?)
Yeah, Ray's SOL wherever he goes. he chooses to draw them away from Ani.
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 11:23 AM
I just read in the Grantland article that the LA Times reporter in the hotel with Ani was the same one who Ray beat up early in the season. Guess we were supposed to remember him.

Last edited by MarsMuzak; 08-10-2015 at 11:28 AM.
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 11:24 AM
As far as spending an and half watching TV on a sunday evening I thought it was very entertaining. Obviously the season was a disaster but I enjoyed the last 2 episodes very much
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 11:24 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by esad
Velcoro parks his car a few blocks away from the the school and walks there. There must be many side streets like that around the school but somehow the bad guys are just at the right street. Of course this is the Lt who seems to know exactly where everyone is going to be at any time.
I kind of assumed Frank and Ray were both followed from where they made the switch? That's the only way either encounter makes sense imo (although they don't really explain it) ie the Mexican gang randomly tracking down Frank is even less probable than waiting to see if Ray stops off at the school (unless I missed something).

Edit: more I think about these endings the less I like them. Was painfully obvious when he pulled off the highway to visit the kid something terrible was going to happen. I think I would have vastly preferred if Ray just noticed he was being followed and brought the shootout to the woods to deflect heat from Ani instead of involving the kid and the ridiculous tracer aspect.

Last edited by bixby snyder; 08-10-2015 at 11:31 AM.
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 11:59 AM
Rbk, dan, bixby:

I don't think the suit thing was about protecting the diamonds for himself. I think at that point he knew he was gonna be left for dead in the desert and it was just a **** you I ain't goin' out like a little bitch statement to the Mexicans with the added bonus of they don't get the diamonds.
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 12:04 PM
All,

Caspere's blue diamonds: not pawned, just a waste whatever happened to them

Redhead's diamond ring: thrown away into the street

VV's diamonds: left in his pocket for the coroner or vultures to find

!!!
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 12:21 PM
El D,

Obv NP hates diamonds more than he hates e-cigs!
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 12:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by goofyballer
What the hell was Holloway saying before the orphan went nuts on him about Caspere's kids? I was struggling to understand wtf they were talking about then AAAAHHHH STAB STAB STAB

I would love to watch the True Detective alternate universe that took place from Vinci PD's point of view. Following the party scene where Holloway watches (minus the drugged out filter) Rachel McAdams go nuts on a guard and run away, Burris is chilling in a SUV with a bunch of dudes that have machine guns playing cards or some **** outside ginger kid's school and look up all of a sudden and say "holy ****, that moron actually showed up here!"

Oh, another random question - how are we supposed to believe the Mexicans caught up with VV? Did the dudes (Armenians?) who gave him the Audi sell him out? Because get the **** out if we're supposed to think he's just randomly driving around LA and they caught up to him.
Because Frank called Osip a "****," I was expecting one of the jewelers to appear in the desert and go through his carcass, grab the diamonds then turn to a vulture, thank it and warn it not to eat the blue balls around the heart.

Frank finally got his first cavity and it killed him.

When he was hallucinating Jordan, I wanted him to see two water stains on her dress covering her tits; then have him say "I wish I was back in the basement."

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jules22
To me I think the biggest problem with the whole season is all the screen time devoted to closet cop, he was not necessary to the plot in anyway as it turns out the only reason he was there because he was riding his bike with his eyes closed and stumbled on caspere and all his story arcs go nowhere now that he got capped. If they replaced all his angsty scenes with expositionary scenes related to velcoro bezzerides frank and the conspiracy it would probably be more entertaining and cogent. That being said I'm still interested in where the season finale goes
Quote:
Originally Posted by FlyWf
Yep. His entire arc was happenstance. He happened to be driving by the dead body while AT THE SAME TIME his old mercenary buddies had gotten hired by Catalyst, and then shortly after that Dixon started following him for no reason and taking random pictures of him WHICH JUST HAPPENED to uncover blackmailable homosexuality. Which didn't even matter, because they killed him.

The whole story, without him, would have the two actual main characters doing slightly more legwork but no other changes.


Just imagine how many weeks Taylor Kitsch spent eating tuna and broccoli to lose weight to get that role, and then how many hours he had to spend in makeup for all those scens where he took his shirt off to show off his burn scars. None of it mattered! LOL nothing matters. Time is a flat circle.
Woodrugh's story line's purpose, I believe, was to allow the show to intentionally present the all-important theme: "If you'd just been honest about who you are, nobody'd be able to run you."

Quote:
Originally Posted by El Diablo
Nunn,

Thanks. Two things:

1) how did they even find out about the diamonds? I remember that happening but don't remember what exactly happened.

2) not sure if you're joking, but catalyst is a company, not a person.
Quote:
Originally Posted by nunnehi
1. Not sure who the they you're referring to is. If it's our "heroes", when Woodrugh was scanning pawn shops they stumbled across it as evidence (can't remember exactly how this was revealed cuz it was a nothing piece of info at the time it was introduced, though I think they saw the diamonds in the background of some shot and blew it up to see if anyone was trying to dump them). Then, later we find out Dixon (fat lazy cop) was inquiring about those diamonds before Woodrugh had gotten that far. Ultimately, we found out those diamonds were what was stolen from the jewelry store of the orphaned kids' parents. And now, Woodrugh realized that the "dream team of Vinci" were all connected on the beat where the robbery happened, meaning they were obviously in on it. Caspere was probably supposed to get rid of the diamonds, but never did. And now it came back to bite all of them in the azz. To me, the whole season is about corruption and the diamonds.

Season 1 was one case and the effect it had on a bunch of people. For this season, the robbery is the one case that dramatically affected a lot of people, but them waiting forever to introduce this as the big crux of the season is the problem (that robbery made all of those cops' Vinci careers [Caspere's position there too], as well as destroyed the lives of a bunch of other people). That singular case can unravel the entire town of Vinci, but it remains to be decided whether it will. To do that, they're essentially going to have to drop the land side (they have no support, and are completely rogue) and go for the robbery/murder angle if they have any hope of solving the case and breaking up Vinci. So, they'll break up small corruption but lose on big corruption...the way of the world. They have A LOT to get through in 90 minutes.

One other thing to note no one's talked about is the stuff Amarillo was sputtering on about right before he got killed at the end of the shootout. I'm not fluent in Spanish (know enough), and never stopped and rewound to try to catch it all, but I think the gist of it was that it was all b.s. and to look at the "puercos" (pigs). Someone could probably go back and transcribe that scene and see that's probably close to what was going on (as that was revealed in this episode anyway that the shootout was an obvious set up and that it didn't go down the way the guy expected).

2. I was using Catalast as an example (he's the guy running Catalast) cuz I can't remember his name, not saying he was a person. I love how any time I write something I feel might be misconstrued it usually is...lol. By the way, it's Catalast, not Catalyst.
Bezzerides and Woodrugh found some blue diamonds in Caspere's safety deposit box, and were held as evidence.


The shot of Chessani in the pool was a reference to Sunset Blvd., imo.

Quote:
Originally Posted by midas
A hit squad is following you and you decide to drive to a remote place to be gunned down. Not a federal building or police HQ where you are safe.
But then he wouldn't get killed like he dreamt he would back in episode 3.

In that episode, Velcoro's dad's watching William Wyler's Detective Story starring Kirk Douglas as a detective going hard after an abortionist doctor, not knowing his own wife had gone to that doctor for an abortion, and that maybe the reason for her infertility. In this movie, cruel and criminal minds drive wives to lunatic asylums. Chessani had his previous schizophrenic wife committed; she committed suicide just like Ani's mom.

I noticed Ares operatives are incompetent as ****. And tortuous storytelling is torturous to some.
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 12:41 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by riverboatking
so VV tells the chick with the scar he's signing over the bar to her.
then the chick with the scar tells ani that VV gave her the money to buy the bar and never asked for it back what am I missing?
Could have sworn she said the money was for plastic surgery for her face but I dont really pay attention.
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 01:26 PM
||,

Quote:
Originally Posted by ||.||.||
Bezzerides and Woodrugh found some blue diamonds in Caspere's safety deposit box, and were held as evidence.

Thanks! That's what I was trying to remember.

And yeah, lol at those highly trained blackwater operatives. They have an 8 on 1 search pattern that leaves them completely vulnerable to the old hide behind a tree and jump out attack. How did these guys make it back to America alive?
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 01:41 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Michael888
Could have sworn she said the money was for plastic surgery for her face but I dont really pay attention.
nope she clearly said he gave her the $$ to buy the bar like right after a scene where he tells her he's gonna sign the bar over to her.
for the love of God someone pls explain that.
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
08-10-2015 , 01:43 PM
Subverting tropes? You have to remember, this show isn't about who owns what, or who committed a crime, or "plot". It's a character study.
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness Quote
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness
$25m Guaranteed WPM on CoinPoker
Join the action now
Daily Rewards • Splash Pots • CoinRaces
True Detective......more (or less) HBO awesomeness

      
m