Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm?

01-24-2008 , 07:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by lastchance
Thanks for all teh feedback. Obviously not watching curb first, LDO.

Another question, if I do start seinfeld, which seasons should I go with, and when should I stop before it jumps the shark (which I assume it does from reading a few summaries, etc)?
I'm a completist and would always start at the beginning, but if you really must jump in at a higher point, start with Season 3. There are things that carry over from Season 2 though, so...

If we were talking about like The Golden Girls you could make an argument that you can get away with watching just one peak season or two, but with Seinfeld you should probably watch every single one.

Edit: Also, S1&2 of Seinfeld come in one package because Season 1 is just 5 episodes, and S2 is only a half season. S2 has one of the all-time classics, The Chinese Restaurant, so just start at the beginning as long as you're not going to give up if you're disappointed early on.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 07:15 PM
Season 1 of Seinfeld is probably the weakest but it's still very good but definitely has a more sitcomy feel then the other seasons.

One thing I really hate about Seinfeld, and all other sitcoms that have it, is the stupid laugh track.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 07:16 PM
Arrested Development and it's not even close.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 07:29 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ditch Digger
One thing I really hate about Seinfeld, and all other sitcoms that have it, is the stupid laugh track.
Seinfeld used a live audience.

And the laughter wasn't ever a problem for me because they were never exagerrating their reactions and I was usually laughing whenever they were laughing. It's not like that 70s show where the laughter single handedly ruined it.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 07:35 PM
Come on guys.. I love AD but Seinfield is still so far ahead it's not even funny.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 07:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PatInTheHat
Come on guys.. I love AD but Seinfield is still so far ahead it's not even funny.
I disagree, Seinfeld is even funny. Very funny, as a matter of fact. But AD is even funnier.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 07:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by 21times20
Anyone who likes Scrubs is an idiot imo
+1
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 07:48 PM
Seinfeld, taken as a whole, is way better than the other two. There are a lot of factors contributing to people listing AD first (including ******ation), but you should go with Seinfeld if you are truly not familiar with it (wtf). AD and CYE are both great though.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 07:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by PatInTheHat
Come on guys.. I love AD but Seinfield is still so far ahead it's not even funny.
You obviously didn't read this guy's post:

Quote:
Originally Posted by Predator314
Arrested Development and it's not even close.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 07:50 PM
tuq: DAMNIT I missed that. You got me ;(
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 07:53 PM
On a somewhat related note im on the last disc of the final season of Seinfield after having gone through them all. It's a sad feeling, like the show is ending again.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 08:05 PM
Oh F*CK! I meant that you should start with Season 4 of S if you insist on not starting at the beginning, not Season 3.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 08:21 PM
seinfeld and but it's super close
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 09:52 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Butcho22
+1
+2

I don't get this humor. I can't relate to the characters nor the situations. The show is also too ADHD for me. If I wanted to be over stimulated, I'd do a line.

CYE needs more love. Sure, I used to love Seinfeld when it aired, but the humor has grown amateur in retrospect. It's like watching Married with Children now. Just doesn't age well (like Cheers or something).

Curb, however, is timeless. Never have I discovered a comedy series that led me to laugh out loud on as many occasions or that bore repeated viewings with such ease. No, I'm not Jewish. But I dig the humor.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 10:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by boc4life
AD and it's not even close

As someone said earlier in the thread, Seinfeld is always on TV, just watch it when it's on. You'll be seeing new episodes forever by doing it that way. AD is a show that deserves a few weeks of watching each episode in order, and then watching all of them in order again.

I watched season 1 of Curb and it was boring. Does it get better or do I just not get it?
I started watching season 1 and thought it was horrible. I almost gave up on the series because of it but I decided to keep going. When Larry put the orchestra on that guy's lawn I started cracking up and thought the show was great. I figured the show would keep getting funnier, which it did.

Although, some episodes you can tell they were just trying to think of the craziest predicaments they could put Larry in and it became a little contrived. But the good episodes greatly outweigh the bad ones.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 10:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by AlexM
After watching that, I removed Arrested Development from my Netflix queue.
I'm a huge AD fan and that clip was horrible. Don't let it discourage you.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 10:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by RainDog
Just doesn't age well (like Cheers or something).
Are you saying that Cheers ages well or does not age well? I think it ages well and it's not even close.

Last edited by tuq; 01-24-2008 at 10:39 PM. Reason: forgot to add hyperbole
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 10:11 PM
I thought CYE was pretty bad.

Loved Seinfeld, AD is awesome... CYE just seemed boring.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 10:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by lastchance
Another question, if I do start seinfeld, which seasons should I go with, and when should I stop before it jumps the shark (which I assume it does from reading a few summaries, etc)?
They're all great. One of my favorite things about seinfeld is that there are no episodes I don't want to watch. When I flip to a Simpsons re-run I'll sometimes watch it for 45 seconds and then realize I don't like the episode. That never happens to me with Seinfeld.

While I was personally ok with the Series Finale, I will accept people saying it sucked. Also the clip show. But other than that, I can't think of any other episode that wasn't good.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 11:24 PM
Quote:
I always thought Seinfeld was the consensus number 1 comedy of all time and it wasn't even close.
it is, and it isnt.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 11:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by AlexM
After watching that, I removed Arrested Development from my Netflix queue.
dude.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-24-2008 , 11:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jjshabado
They're all great. One of my favorite things about seinfeld is that there are no episodes I don't want to watch. When I flip to a Simpsons re-run I'll sometimes watch it for 45 seconds and then realize I don't like the episode. That never happens to me with Seinfeld.

While I was personally ok with the Series Finale, I will accept people saying it sucked. Also the clip show. But other than that, I can't think of any other episode that wasn't good.
lol the series finale of seinfeld WAS a clip show. Obv sucked so hard.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-25-2008 , 12:44 AM
The Maid episode is like 10 mins in on Fox...and there's so many lines I've already lol'd at hard.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-25-2008 , 12:50 AM
I'll say curb but whatever as far as order. This show is the nuts imo though, definitely give it a try.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote
01-25-2008 , 02:55 AM
I'm glad my ranting has brought "it's not even close" to a whole new level.
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, or Curb your enthusiasm? Quote

      
m