Quote:
Originally Posted by vixticator
big mike - wow very good
john - ehhh this dude kinda sucks
casey - think he's gonna win
alex - is this the same guy? great voice
todrick - i dunno i have mixed feelings
jermaine - absolutely terrible
andrew - meh this dude sucks
aaron - middle of the road
tim - why is he still here?
lee - it was ok
------------
1. big mike
.
.
2. alex
3. casey
.
4. lee
5. aaron
.
6. andrew
7. todrick
.
.
.
8. john
9. tim
.
.
.
.
10. jermaine
um. level? He's easily a top 3 talent in the competition. IMO him and crystal bowersox are the two best all around in the competition. The way these judges are critiquing is starting to get annoying though. Last week Andrew arguably had one of the best performances of the night yet they were still all disappointed. Tonight he wasn't great but he wasn't bad either. All these other singers are getting the no but yes kinda treatment because they're delivering better than what is expected of
themselves, but it's still not good.
Most of the positive critiques are singers singing good relative to their own talent level. Andrew's bad is better than most of their good, it's really that simple. Yes, straight up was incredible but you expect him to hit that level everytime? Just cause he doesn't the judges have something bad to say abt the performance. Watch his sugar performance from last week he sang the song perfect vocally AND the arrangement was dope I dunno what they were on...something tells me if he made top 24 w/o ever doing straight up they'd be much muchhh more lenient on him imo.
And lol wut casey james was weak as **** tonight. That performance was wack sorry, and fwiw I rly ike that gavin degraw song. They said for someone else tonight "it's not as good as the original"..jermaine or todrick maybe. Well umm...casey's was light years behind the original. Big Mike was good tonight prolly the best. Aaron = middle of the road? Yet some others you listed as just flat out sucking. Are you stuck in 1998? Cause aaron looks like he should have been a singer trying to make it over 10 years ago. Dude is just outdated, has no appeal whatsoever...decent voice I guesssss....but he's on some late 90's nsync type **** when it's 2010.