I was comparing the pieces added. Kobe/shaq obv is better than kobe/gasol. But the difference in Nash/Dwight to Payton/Malone is huuuuugely weighted towards nash/dwight given how good they were the last couple of years.
Payton:
Code:
Season Age Tm G PER USG% ORtg DRtg WS/48
2001-02 33 SEA 82 22.9 27.2 114 107 .183
2002-03 34 TOT 80 21.1 26.4 108 107 .136
2003-04 35 LAL 82 17.3 20.4 109 103 .137
nash:
Code:
Season Age Tm G MP PER USG% ORtg DRtg WS/48
2009-10 35 PHO 81 2660 21.6 22.9 121 114 .178
2010-11 36 PHO 75 2497 20.8 21.4 118 114 .153
2011-12 37 PHO 62 1961 20.3 19.6 115 110 .144
Malone:
Code:
Season Age Tm G PER USG% ORtg DRtg WS/48
2001-02 38 UTA 80 21.1 28.8 107 101 .155
2002-03 39 UTA 81 21.7 27.8 109 100 .182
2003-04 40 LAL 42 17.8 19.7 107 98 .151
Dwight:
Code:
Season Age Tm G PER USG% ORtg DRtg WS/48
2009-10 24 ORL 82 24.0 23.9 113 95 .223
2010-11 25 ORL 78 26.0 27.2 113 94 .236
2011-12 26 ORL 54 24.2 26.1 106 96 .179
I'd say Dwight and Payton are hurt the most by having D that doesn't show up very well...but at that point of Payton's career he was much worse defensively than he was at his peak. Dwight is at his peak and a huge part of his value is D ldo.