He's available in the majority of my YPL's, not saying I would drop him, but he is definitely barely rosterable in 10-team leagues with 5-6 bench spots if you drafted well.

Anyways, it's a moot point since he said he has great RB depth = never going to touch Gerhart.

It's a snap of course.

I don't think about things with 10 team leagues. If it's not 12 plus I don't play. But yea moot all around.

Non ppr

Kelvin Benjamin, Car WR
Emmanuel Sanders, Den
Russell Wilson, Sea QB

Randall Cobb, GB WR
Nick Foles, Phi QB from
Pierre Garcon, Wsh WR

Who wins?

thanks added cj2k for sankey to the mix as well for some added oomph.

i think cobb=allen and i like bennett ROS but obv gronk is better so the gronk side wins. i'd do it but i don't expect it to be accepted unless the guy is really low on allen.

shady crushes this.

big win. i like kelvin ros, but jordy is a top wr so you gotta go for it.

id go with the top one. its pretty much even tho.

ya i didn't answer because i couldn't decide. the top one has more upside. go with whichever you prefer and it's fine imo.

I know everyone so far has said top or even, but I'd go bottom.

I like your side of this a lot. And if your sister needs sleeping with, PM me.

Is this AJ Green your or some other Green that makes it worth even discussing this?

Do not trade AJ Green. Not even if Manning/Brees/Rodgers is on the table. For Cutlah? Never.

I lean bottom. I like Foles a lot more than Wilson though.

8 team ESPN league. No PPR. 6pt receiving and rushing TD, 4 pt passing. 2 QB, 3 WR, 2 RB, 1 TE, 1 Flex D/ST, K

Here's my team:
QB:Brees, Manuel, Palmer
RB:Spiller, R Jennings, Stacy, Thomas, Sproles
WR:Nelson, Brown, Edelman, V Jackson, Floyd, Hilton
TE: Graham
K:Bryant, Prater
D/ST:Patriots

I'm 3-0 right now and overall very happy with my team. I definitely would like to upgrade at QB2.
I've talked with a couple guys who might be willing to work with me. I THINK Luck or Manning may be available. Question is how much should I reasonably offer for either one?

The guy with Luck really wants Graham and has also been after Edelman. How is a Luck/Gronk for Graham/Edelman deal?

The guy with Manning also is after Graham. Is Graham/Jennings for Manning too much? Too little? He also had picked up Donnell for this week since he has J Thomas, so I may be able to get him in the deal too. This guy also has Kaep and Cutlah. Would either of them be a big enough upgrade to make it worth pursuing. FWIW, he's 3-0 too and sitting on a pretty good team, so it's gonna take higher end players to get him to deal.

Any advice you can give me on what I should offer for a new QB would be appreciated. Thanks.

Graham/Jennings way too much. Just Graham is probably too much. Maybe Graham/Jennings for Manning/Donnell. You do have an excess of RB's I'd look to move.

In a 2Qb league, both of those trades are steals for you, IMO.
Luck/Gronk for Graham/Edelman would be the better of the two.

Are you taking into account that this is a 2 QB league?

i don't see how he does this. gronk/graham are similar so this is basically luck for edelman which is lol. if he has a huge hard-on for graham maybe this works. good luck.

If I have graham above manning in a 1qb league, i don't see why i'd have manning above graham in a 2qb league. i could be wrong, i've never been in a 2qb league, i just dont see how that makes sense.

Thanks for the replies. And yes, he does have a hard-on for Graham. For Edelman too I guess since he was asking for him over Brown or Nelson.

Yeah def try to get that Luck deal done if possible. Also that team actually seems pretty bad for that setup, so don't be fooled by your 3-0 start. You have a lot of work to do. Step one: don't carry 2 kickers.

If Manning is a bigger weekly points improvement over my current QB2 than Graham is over a replacement TE, wouldn't that make Manning more important to me? I'm asking because I don't know if I'm looking at it wrong. I've only recently gotten bigger into fantasy football, so I'm still learning how to rank everyone.

Prater was picked up with my last draft pick. Bryant will be gone when Prater comes off suspension. At least that's my plan. What other weaknesses do I have? Not having a top 3 RB? Or are my receivers not as good as I think they are and have just performed way above expectation so far?

Ugh, the fact that you wasted a draft pick and a roster spot that long on Prater is even worse. Just drop him. In an 8 team league there should be a bunch of guys on the ww worth way more than him. Someone mentioned earlier to look at what McManus has done this year. It's not like the Broncos are going to all of the sudden start attempting a bunch more FG's because Prater is back. Kickers are kickers, don't worry about them, and def don't waste roster spots on superfluous ones.

Yeah your RB's seem terrible for an 8 teamer. Your WR depth is good, but in a non ppr with a flex, that isn't as important. Also you have a bunch of guys who lose a lot of value in non-ppr (Thomas/Sproles/Edleman, even Brown and Graham lose a little bit). Basically you have no QB2 and no RB1 (two of the most important positions in this setup), which is tough to pull off in an 8 team league. And you don't even have a top 5 WR either (though Jordy and ABrown are close). Just seems like it's gotta be one of the weaker teams in an 8 team league, but maybe I just don't have enough experience in that setup to know.

try to get manning/julius for graham/jennings. obv wait until after this week to do that deal tho as the bye weeks make it favorable for you. if not, the graham/edelmand for luck/gronk is a good deal.

ya this is not the way to look at it. then you end up with 0 qbs.

def agree that his team isnt that great and that prater is super lol for holding. theres been a ton of great waiver wire plays that he coulda dropped prater for and made his team better.

but i do have jordy top 5. id say hes 3 after calvin and julio. id put brown like 7.

julio
calvin (injuries suck)
jordy
dez
green
marshall
jeffery
brown
kelvin
maclin
sanders

Thanks for the continued feedback and criticism. I can understand the lol behind holding onto a suspended kicker for four weeks. But how much damage is being done by him taking up that spot instead of a different active player who won't be staring anyway?

Also, I see there's no D Thomas in your receivers list. Is he that far gone or just off to a slow start? Is he worth going after for maybe Edelman? I'm a huge Broncos fan so I tend to get too caught up in picking up Broncos players. Which typically isn't a bad thing.

Something like this:

(Manning - the 21st best QB is) >>>> Manning - (the 11th best QB).
Still starting one TE so you don't need to look deeper than the replacement level TE

When I get to Sunday morning, only about half of my teams have a kicker rostered. I cut them for waivers so I don't have to think to much about who to cut.